Old Tin Signs With Advertising Graphics Collectors Display With Pride
A rusted panel leaning against a barn wall does not look like much until someone turns it over and the colors underneath are still bright. That contrast between decades of weather and paint that refused to fade is exactly what pulls people into this hobby.
Old advertising signs were never meant to survive this long, which is precisely why the ones that did are worth chasing.
Values swing wildly depending on maker, material, and condition, and two signs from the same campaign can differ in price by a factor of ten based on rust, chipping, and fading alone. Porcelain enamel signs generally outlast lithographed tin because the glass coating resists weather better than painted metal, and that durability shows up directly in what collectors are willing to pay.
Coca-Cola Porcelain Signs

Coca-Cola spent nearly a century commissioning some of the most recognizable graphic design in American advertising, and its porcelain button and rectangular signs from the 1930s through 1950s remain the benchmark against which other soda advertising is measured. Common tin versions from that era can sell for a few hundred dollars, but rare large-format porcelain examples in strong original condition have brought anywhere from tens of thousands of dollars up toward six figures at specialty auctions.
The company’s insistence on consistent red and white branding across decades means collectors can date a sign almost to the year just from the script style and border design.
Mobil Pegasus Signs

The winged red horse that Mobil adopted as its emblem in the 1930s became one of the most counterfeited images in the sign-collecting world, which tells you how desirable genuine examples are. Large porcelain die-cut Pegasus signs in excellent original paint have sold for well over one hundred thousand dollars, while smaller flat versions or those with heavy corrosion trade for a fraction of that.
Because the shape itself is the logo, any distortion, bending, or touch-up paint on the wings drops the value sharply.
Texaco Double-Sided Porcelain Signs

Texaco’s red star and green T logo went through several design generations, and the double-sided porcelain versions meant to hang from a bracket over a service station are among the most contested pieces at petroliana auctions. Top examples with crisp enamel and no restoration have brought thirty to seventy-five thousand dollars, while more common single-sided or smaller pieces sell for a few hundred to a few thousand.
The double-sided format matters because it means the sign was designed to be seen from the road in both directions, a detail that always drives up collector interest.
Sinclair Dino Signs

Sinclair’s green dinosaur mascot, introduced in the 1930s to tie the brand to the ancient origins of petroleum, turned an otherwise ordinary gasoline sign into one of the most instantly recognizable images in the hobby. A well-preserved Dino porcelain sign has sold for around three thousand dollars in recent years, and the largest and rarest examples with strong original enamel have climbed into the tens of thousands.
The character’s continued use in Sinclair branding today, unusual for a company mascot this old, keeps demand steady rather than fading with nostalgia trends.
Shell Clamshell Porcelain Signs

Shell’s scallop-shell emblem is one of the oldest continuously used corporate logos in America, and the porcelain versions shaped to follow the actual outline of the shell rather than a flat rectangle are the ones collectors prize most. Flat shell-shaped signs turn up regularly and sell modestly, but the large dimensional versions that mimic the true shell contour are scarce enough that sellers routinely note how few they have encountered even after decades in the hobby.
Original color saturation on the reds and yellows is the first thing a serious buyer checks, since sun exposure dulls Shell’s palette faster than most other oil brands.
Goodyear Winged-Foot Tire Signs

Goodyear’s mythological winged-foot logo, borrowed from the Roman god Mercury, gave the tire maker one of the more artistically ambitious designs in early automotive advertising. Well-preserved porcelain examples have sold for around seventeen thousand dollars, while worn or rusted pieces from the same production run can be found for closer to a thousand.
The winged foot itself is the detail collectors scrutinize most closely, since it was often the first part of the sign to lose paint from repeated handling during store display.
Firestone Tire Signs

Firestone leaned on bold black and red lettering rather than elaborate imagery, which makes its signs easier to date by typography alone than by artwork. Standard lithographed tin Firestone signs in decent shape typically bring around three hundred dollars, a modest figure compared to the oil majors, but larger dealership-scale porcelain versions with the full company script command considerably more.
Firestone’s steady, unglamorous design has made it a favorite entry point for new collectors who want a real vintage piece without competing for six-figure Pegasus money.
Dr Pepper Thermometer Signs

Dr Pepper’s tin thermometer signs, produced heavily through the 1940s and into the postwar years, combined a working temperature gauge with the brand’s distinctive maroon and white lettering, and the format alone sets them apart from flat advertising panels. The slogan referencing drinking the beverage at ten, two, and four o’clock appeared on many of these thermometers, tying the sign directly to a marketing campaign that reshaped how Americans thought about scheduled soda breaks.
Because the thermometer tube itself is fragile and often missing or broken on surviving examples, a sign with an intact, functioning gauge commands a real premium over one with a shattered dial.
Nehi Soda Signs

Nehi built its identity around fruit-flavored sodas and a name that became a minor pun on how high a woman’s hemline sat, a piece of marketing trivia that still gets brought up at antique shows today. Porcelain Nehi signs, often shaped as flanges meant to hang perpendicular to a store wall, are less common than flat versions and draw stronger bidding as a result.
The brand’s fruit-basket artwork, rendered in saturated color, is what separates a desirable example from a faded also-ran, since collectors are really paying for the graphics as much as the name.
Pepsi-Cola Signs

Pepsi’s bottle-cap logo went through enough redesigns over the decades that collectors use the exact typeface and cap arrangement to pin down a sign’s decade almost on sight. A more common 1960s-era tin sign has sold for around two hundred fifty dollars, while earlier porcelain examples with crisper color separation bring considerably more. Pepsi signs are unusually plentiful compared to some rivals, which keeps prices approachable for newcomers even as top-condition rarities still command real money.
7Up Tin Signs

7Up leaned on its bright green bubble logo and the phrase describing itself as the drink with no dark cola flavor, a positioning that shaped decades of advertising built entirely around what the soda was not. Tin signs from the brand’s midcentury run show up regularly at estate sales and shows, and prices track closely with how much of the original green has survived direct sunlight exposure over the decades.
Because the color scheme is so central to brand recognition, a 7Up sign with heavy fading loses value faster than comparable signs from brands built on red or white palettes.
Orange Crush Signs

Orange Crush’s bottle-shaped die-cut tin signs, molded to the actual silhouette of the soda bottle rather than a flat rectangle, are among the more playful pieces in the soda advertising category. Cardboard store displays from the brand have sold for several hundred dollars, and the sturdier bottle-shaped tin versions in strong original paint bring considerably more at specialty auctions.
The bright orange pigment used in the brand’s signage is notoriously prone to fading, so a sign that has retained its original saturation is treated as meaningfully scarcer than one that has gone pale.
John Deere Porcelain Signs

John Deere’s leaping deer trademark has anchored the company’s identity since the nineteenth century, and porcelain dealership signs bearing the mark are prized as much by farm equipment collectors as by general advertising buyers. Large double-sided examples meant to hang outside implement dealerships routinely bring well into four figures, and the earliest trademark variations with more detailed antler and body artwork climb considerably higher when they surface.
Rust along the edges is almost expected on farm signage that spent decades outdoors near equipment yards, so buyers weigh overall graphic clarity more heavily than perfect edges.
Purina Checkerboard Feed Signs

Purina’s red and white checkerboard pattern, developed in the 1890s and still used by the company today, is one of the longest-running brand graphics in American commerce, which gives its old feed store signs a continuity that few other categories can match. Porcelain versions advertising specific product lines like chicken or hog feed turn up at farm auctions and general stores across the Midwest, and their value depends heavily on how much of the checkerboard grid remains crisp rather than chipped away.
Because the design is so geometric, even small areas of enamel loss are immediately visible, making pristine examples noticeably scarcer than the overall production numbers would suggest.
Quaker State Motor Oil Signs

Quaker State favored a tombstone-shaped double-sided sign format for many of its dealership displays, a silhouette that makes the brand instantly identifiable among a wall of rectangular oil company signs. Prices range from a couple hundred dollars for smaller or well-worn examples up to a couple thousand for large, double-sided pieces with strong original gloss.
The brand’s use of a state outline in its early logo work gives collectors an easy way to distinguish pre-and postwar variations, since the geographic graphic was simplified over time.
Campbell’s Soup Signs

Campbell’s leaned on its familiar red and white can label for advertising far beyond grocery store shelves, and its 1950s tin signs promoting specific soup varieties are a favorite among kitchen and general store collectors. A sign in solid but unremarkable condition typically sells for around one hundred dollars, while a particularly clean, well-graphic example brought roughly twenty-seven hundred dollars at a 2019 sale.
The gap between those two numbers illustrates just how much a single tier of condition can move price within one modest, non-automotive advertising category.
Borden’s Ice Cream Porcelain Signs

Borden’s built its dairy advertising around Elsie the cow, a mascot so effective that many collectors today know the character better than the company itself. Double-sided porcelain signs promoting the brand’s ice cream, often shaped or bordered to evoke a milk bottle or dairy scene, are harder to find than the company’s more common milk delivery advertising, which pushes demand higher whenever one surfaces.
Neon-trimmed versions of these dairy signs, once mounted outside corner drugstores and soda counters, are especially sought after because so few survived the later removal of neon tubing for scrap.
Red Goose Shoes Die-Cut Signs

Red Goose Shoes built an entire regional advertising identity around a bright red waterfowl figure, and its die-cut tin signs shaped like the goose itself are considered a cornerstone of country store collecting rather than automotive or beverage advertising. Beyond the signs, the company distributed tin whistles and clickers shaped like the same goose to children in shoe stores, and those small premiums now circulate as a companion category to the signage itself.
Because the die-cut shape includes thin extended sections like the neck and legs, these pieces are unusually prone to bending and metal fatigue, so a goose sign that has kept its full silhouette intact commands a real premium over one that has been straightened or repaired.
What the Rust Actually Tells You

None of these signs were built to become art. They were meant to sell tires, soda, and feed to people who barely glanced at them on the way into a store, and their survival into the collector market is mostly an accident of neglect.
A sign forgotten in a barn loft outlasted its cousin that got repainted, scrapped for the war effort, or simply thrown out once the campaign ended, and that randomness is part of why so few good examples remain.
What collectors are really paying for, in the end, is graphic design history rendered in a material tough enough to outlive the companies and products it once promoted. The rust, the fading, and the small dents are not flaws to be erased but evidence of exactly how long that piece of commercial art has been quietly doing its job on a wall somewhere.
More from Home As We Make It

- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
