33 Button Tins Buyers Sort Through

An inherited button tin weighs almost nothing and takes up no shelf, which is why so many survive in attics long after the sewing basket they came from was thrown out. Most of what rattles inside is worth nothing at all. A small fraction is worth more than the furniture it was stored in.

Dealers who buy these tins unseen are betting on that fraction. The sorting goes quickly once the eye learns which materials pay.

Bakelite Carved and Laminated

Phenolic resin reached the button trade in quantity in the 1920s and was cut and molded by the million, but the tin worth opening holds carved examples rather than plain discs. Deeply carved florals, laminated layers of contrasting color, and pieces with applied dots command real money among collectors, while a flat brown circle does not.

Color matters more than size, with translucent apple juice and true red drawing the strongest interest. Condition governs everything, since a chip on a carved edge cuts value sharply. Laminated examples, built from bonded sheets of two or three colors, are the ones dealers set aside first.

Metal Polish Test and Its Limits

Rubbing a cotton swab of metal polish along an inconspicuous edge remains the standard field test for phenolic resin. Simichrome turns from pink to yellow on contact, and a mild ammonia household cleaner gives the same reaction.

Black and deep red pieces often fail to react even when genuine, and old wax or polish on the surface blocks the reaction too, so a negative result settles nothing. Running the piece under hot water and checking for the sharp phenol odor works as a second opinion, though noses vary.

A heated pin has no place in the procedure, because several early plastics sitting in the same tin are flammable.

Celluloid Sheet and Its Thin Skin

Celluloid predates phenolic resin and behaves nothing like it. Most celluloid buttons are a thin skin of cellulose nitrate wrapped over a metal or cardboard core, which is why so many survive with lifted edges and crazed surfaces.

Wafer-thin sheet celluloid imitating pearl or ivory turns up constantly and sells for pennies, but molded figural celluloid and pieces with painted detail are collected seriously. Heat and humidity degrade the material over decades, and a tin that smells faintly of camphor holds celluloid already breaking down.

Sound examples with crisp molding and no warping hold the value.

Lucite Clarity and Moonglow Shimmer

Acrylic reached the button trade in the late 1930s and offered something phenolic resin could not, which was optical clarity. Clear Lucite with carved reverse designs, embedded glitter, or a metal insert suspended in the middle is the version buyers want.

Moonglow describes acrylic with a pearlized inner layer that appears to glow from within as light passes through, most often in pastel blue, pink, and green. Moonglow cards from the 1940s and 1950s regularly sell as sets rather than singles.

Acrylic resists the deterioration that ruins celluloid, so condition problems are usually limited to surface scratching.

Vegetable Ivory Turned from Tagua Nuts

Tagua palm nuts from South America were turned into buttons on a scale that is difficult to picture now, with American factories consuming shiploads through the late nineteenth century and into the 1920s. The material takes dye beautifully and carves like a fine hardwood, so vegetable ivory appears in deep red, green, and brown as well as its natural cream.

A grain of fine irregular lines separates it from plastic imitations, and unlike an injection-molded copy it shows no seam. Carved and dyed examples with pierced work bring the most.

Plain dyed discs in quantity have modest value but sell steadily to sewers.

Pearl Shell in Its Better Grades

Shell buttons dominated the trade before plastic and still fill the bottom of most tins. Ordinary white pearl cut from freshwater mussel shell at Muscatine in Iowa and the other Mississippi river towns is common enough to be nearly worthless, but the darker grades are another matter.

Abalone shows green and blue fire under a tilt of the light, smoked pearl carries a gray to brown iridescence, and both bring steady prices when carved or pierced. Thickness is the quickest guide, since heavy blanks cut from the best shell feel entirely different from thin stamped ones.

Carved pearl with a metal shank and a relief pattern sits at the top of the category.

Carved Shell Cut in Relief

Relief carving in shell is a separate discipline from plain pearl cutting, done mainly in Italy using the helmet conch and cassis shells that supplied the cameo trade. Figures, profiles, and flower heads were cut so the darker underlayer of the shell reads as background against a pale raised design.

Nineteenth century examples were often mounted in brass or gilt rims and sewn as sets down a garment front. Damage shows first on the highest points of the carving, which is where a loupe goes.

Genuine carved shell warms in the hand and lacks the seam line that betrays a molded copy.

Mourning Glass and Genuine Jet

Black glass buttons run to the hundreds in ordinary tins, a consequence of Victorian mourning dress and the cheapness of pressed glass. Most are worth very little alone, though pieces with silver luster, painted decoration, or an unusual molded pattern are collected by pattern name.

True jet is a different material entirely, a fossilized wood mined chiefly around Whitby in Yorkshire, and it is markedly lighter and warmer to the touch than glass. Jet leaves a brown streak when rubbed against unglazed ceramic, which glass will not.

The weight difference alone sorts a tin of black buttons within a few minutes.

Bohemian Pressed Glass in Deep Color

Glassworks in northern Bohemia turned out pressed and molded buttons in enormous variety from the late nineteenth century onward, and the region remains a source today. Color is the draw, running to cobalt, uranium green that fluoresces under an ultraviolet lamp, amethyst, and opaque custard.

Many carry a luster finish applied over the pressed design, and the better ones show crisp detail with no softening in the mold. Czech buttons of the 1920s and 1930s made for export often came mounted on printed cards, which multiplies what a group brings.

Loose singles are common and cheap unless the molded design is unusual.

Paperweight Glass with Encased Flowers

Paperweight buttons use the technique of glass paperweights at a fraction of the scale, encasing a colored design under a clear dome that magnifies it. Antique examples from Bohemian and French works are scarce, and modern studio versions by known makers sell well in their own right.

The test is optical, since a genuine encased design sits at depth and shifts slightly as the viewing angle changes, while a printed or painted imitation stays flat. Air bubbles trapped deliberately in a pattern signal intention rather than a flaw.

Size matters here, and larger domes with complex interiors bring multiples of what small plain ones do.

Brass Picture Buttons Telling Stories

Victorian picture buttons are stamped brass, often an inch or more across, carrying scenes drawn from opera, mythology, fable, and popular novels. Collectors catalog them by subject, and specialists can name the story from the figure arrangement alone, which is why a single large one can outprice an entire tin of ordinary shell.

Condition centers on the stamped detail, since a rubbed high point kills the scene. Many were built with a tin or steel back and a wire shank, and corrosion at the reverse is common.

Those with inset cut steel accents or a colored celluloid insert rank above plain brass.

Cut Steel Facets and Steel Cups

Cut steel work uses individually faceted steel rivets set into a backing plate, each polished to throw light like a dark diamond. The count matters, and a densely set button carrying a hundred or more facets is a different object from one with a dozen.

Rust is the enemy, because a pitted facet cannot be restored without destroying the surface around it. Steel cup designs, in which facets sit in stamped cups, were a later and cheaper method that collectors grade separately.

Eighteenth and early nineteenth century French and English work brings the strongest prices when the facets remain bright.

Enamel Grounds and Champleve Cells

Enameled buttons cover several techniques that sell at very different levels. Champleve work has cells cut or stamped into a metal base and filled with colored glass, then ground flush, so the metal lines between colors become part of the design.

Cloisonne uses applied wire to form those cells instead, and basse taille lays translucent enamel over an engraved ground so the pattern reads through it. Losses and chips in the enamel are the standard fault and cut value hard.

French and Austrian work of the late nineteenth century is the ground most collectors cover first.

Satsuma Miniatures in Gilt and Crackle

Japanese Satsuma buttons carry hand-painted scenes on a crackled cream glaze with raised gilt outlining, worked at a scale that seems impossible until examined under magnification. Figures, dragons, chrysanthemums, and landscape vignettes are the usual subjects, and a signed reverse raises the price considerably.

Export production ran heavily through the Meiji period and continued into the twentieth century, with later pieces generally coarser in the painting and thinner in the gilding. Gilt wear is the standard condition issue, since raised gold rubs away first.

A matched group with consistent painting is worth far more than the same pieces sold as singles.

Hand-Painted Porcelain Scenes

Beyond Satsuma, European factories painted porcelain faces with flowers, birds, portraits, and landscape views, usually mounted in a brass or gilt rim with a shank soldered to a metal back. French and German work of the nineteenth century dominates what turns up in American tins.

Brushwork quality separates the grades immediately, and a painted face with individual petal strokes and shading outranks a transfer print given a little hand touching. Transfer decoration is not worthless but sits well below hand painting. Hairline cracks in the porcelain are easy to miss and easy to find with a strong light placed behind the piece.

Wedgwood Jasperware Mounted in Metal

Wedgwood supplied small jasperware cameos to the button and buckle trade, and examples mounted in cut steel date to roughly 1785 through 1800. Mounts are often attributed to Matthew Boulton of Birmingham, though Wedgwood sold jasper to several mounters across Birmingham and Wolverhampton, so a Boulton attribution on a loose example is rarely provable.

Pale blue with a white relief figure is the familiar combination, but green, lilac, and black jasper grounds exist and bring more. The steel setting is usually the weak point, since rust spreads outward from the rivets.

Later reproductions exist and tend to show a thicker, softer relief.

Calico Prints on Prosser China

Calico buttons are small pressed ceramic discs carrying a transfer-printed pattern, made possible by the dust-pressing method Richard Prosser patented in 1840 and sold as the Patent Agate Button. Hundreds of distinct patterns exist in blue, pink, brown, and green, and specialists identify them by print design the way quilters identify fabric.

Most run between a quarter and half an inch across, with four sewn openings and a slightly domed face. Value depends on pattern scarcity rather than material, since the ceramic itself costs nothing, and a common blue print is worth pennies while an unusual pattern in good register brings dollars.

Chips at the rim are the usual damage.

Line Sizes Collectors Measure

Button size is stated in lines, an old trade measure in which forty lines equal one inch, and collectors sort china buttons by it before anything else. Small white china buttons under about eighteen lines fill sewing tins by the hundred and were the standard shirt and underclothing fastening for generations.

Rarity within china runs to the decorated types, including concentric ring patterns, gingham prints, and the notched piecrust rim. A gauge card with cutouts for each line size costs almost nothing and turns an unsorted pile into something a buyer can price.

Without sizing, even a good group reads as bulk.

Uniform Buttons and Their Backmarks

Uniform buttons carry their history on the reverse, where the backmark names the maker and often narrows the date to a decade. American military issue from the Civil War era, state seal patterns, and early naval designs are collected hard and priced by reference works keyed to device and backmark.

Railroad buttons name the line on the face, and an obscure short line usually outsells a major road. Fire departments, transit companies, hotels, and steamship lines all issued their own, and the smaller the issuer the better.

Corrosion and a missing shank reduce value but rarely destroy it on a scarce example.

Livery Buttons Bearing Family Crests

Livery buttons were worn by household servants and carry the crest of the family that employed them, usually in stamped silver plate or gilt on a domed face. British examples dominate, and a crest can often be traced through published armorial references to a specific family and a rough date.

Sets sewn on a coat were made in matching large and small sizes, so a run of consistent examples is far more useful than a single one. Firmin, in the London trade since the seventeenth century, stamped its name on the reverse, which helps with dating.

Plating wear on the high points of the crest is the common flaw.

Denim Closures and Work Clothing Marks

Metal fasteners from work clothing sit at the opposite end of the aesthetic scale and still sell well, because the market for vintage denim pulls them along. Stamped brand names on the face, doughnut-shaped backs, and a rivet fixing rather than a sewn attachment all help date a garment.

Scovill of Waterbury supplied much of the American hardware, and marks from the 1920s through the 1940s carry real value to collectors who date jeans by fittings alone. Condition here means legible stamping more than shine, since honest wear is expected on work clothing.

A loose example is worth little by itself but tells a buyer what the rest of a lot might hold.

Horn, Antler, and Bone

Organic materials fill older tins and get mistaken for plastic constantly. Horn was softened and pressed into molds, so it takes fine detail and often shows a subtle grain running through the color. Bone shows tiny dark pores under magnification, a giveaway that separates it from ivory and from plastic imitations, and the plainest examples were made by hand with a sunken central well.

Antler and stag appear as cross-cut slices with a porous core showing at the middle, used heavily on Bavarian and hunting clothing. Insect damage is a genuine risk with horn, and a pitted surface usually means poor storage.

Wood and Leather That Survived

Wooden buttons rarely survive a century of laundering, so the ones that turn up intact tend to come from coats rather than shirts. Turned and carved examples in fruitwood and boxwood show tool marks under magnification, and a few nineteenth century types combine a wooden core with an inlaid pearl or metal center.

Leather appears mostly as the braided knot shape still used on sport coats, and older hand-worked examples carry an irregularity that machine production lost. Both materials suffer from dryness and from the sewn attachment pulling through.

Neither category commands much money, but a matched run of carved wooden examples sells to costumers.

Rhinestone and Paste in Metal Settings

Glass stones set in metal cups turn a plain button into something buyers argue over, provided every stone is still present. Paste refers to the older leaded glass of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, cut and foiled at the back to throw light, while rhinestone covers the later machine-cut versions.

A missing stone is nearly impossible to match convincingly and cuts value by more than its share. Foil backing degrades when wet, so a gray dead-looking stone in an otherwise bright cluster usually means water damage.

Signed examples from the mid twentieth century costume trade carry their own following.

Art Deco Geometry in Chrome and Resin

Geometric designs of the 1920s and 1930s appear across materials, and the style itself drives price as much as what the button is made from. Stepped forms, zigzags, and stark contrasts of black against cream or chrome against red define the look.

Phenolic resin combined with chrome or nickel plate is the combination that sells fastest, particularly in large coat sizes. Many were French, and a few carry maker marks on the metal back, which is unusual for buttons of any period.

The design has to be crisp, since a softened edge on a geometric form reads as a later copy immediately.

Victorian Realistics Shaped as Objects

Realistics are buttons made in the shape of a recognizable thing rather than a decorated disc, and the category runs from insects and animals to hats, fans, musical instruments, and kitchen implements. Nineteenth century metal examples with fine stamping and applied elements are the serious end of the field, and specialists compete over unusual subjects.

Scale is part of the appeal, since the smallest examples carry detail that requires magnification to appreciate. Damage to a projecting element such as a wing or a handle is the usual problem.

Subject matter drives price far more than material does within this group.

Midcentury Plastic Novelties for Children

Injection-molded novelties from the 1940s through the 1960s were made for children’s clothing and sold by the card in variety stores. Animals, fruit, vehicles, and cartoon shapes were produced in bright opaque colors, and the better ones had painted detail that has usually worn away.

Japanese and German production fills the category, and an Occupied Japan mark places a piece in the postwar occupation years, which ended in 1952. Molded detail separates the grades, since the cheapest examples have soft edges and never carried paint at all.

Sellers routinely sweep these into a bulk lot without turning one over.

Studio Glass by Named Makers

Contemporary glass artists make buttons as a discipline of their own, and the market for them runs parallel to the antique trade rather than competing with it. Lampworked designs with encased murrine, dichroic layers, and sculptural surfaces are signed on the reverse or on the shank by makers whose names collectors recognize.

Prices for a single signed example from an established maker can exceed what a comparable antique brings, which surprises people sorting an inherited tin. National Button Society competition includes categories for modern work, which sustains the market.

Anything signed deserves a search before it goes into a bulk lot.

Charm Strings Strung by the Hundred

Girls in the second half of the nineteenth century strung buttons on a cord as a social pursuit, trading with friends to avoid repeats and aiming at a target of nine hundred and ninety-nine. Folklore attached to the thousandth button, in one telling delivered by a future husband and in another condemning the collector to spinsterhood, and surviving accounts disagree about which version prevailed.

The custom faded around 1900, and intact strings are prized because they preserve a dated cross section of what was available. Breaking one up for the individual buttons destroys more value than it releases.

Length, variety, and an unbroken cord are what a buyer assesses.

Card-Mounted Sets Still Intact

Original cards do more for value than almost any other factor, because they supply the maker, the period graphics, and proof that nothing has gone missing. Department store and notions cards from the 1920s through the 1950s carry printed brand names, prices in cents, and artwork that collectors buy for its own sake.

Removing buttons from a card is irreversible and routinely destroys the majority of what a group was worth. Even a card missing two of six buttons outperforms six loose ones of the same type.

Sun fading and adhesive residue are what reduce a card, not the buttons mounted on it.

Confectionery and Advertising Tins Themselves

The container occasionally outvalues its contents. Early lithographed tins from confectioners, biscuit makers, and household goods companies are collected as advertising, and a bright example from before 1930 with legible graphics can bring more than everything rattling inside it.

Scottish shortbread tins, English biscuit tins with hinged lids, and American candy containers are the forms most often repurposed as button storage. Rust inside the lid and scratching across the printed surface drive the grade down fastest.

Anyone about to dump a tin into a sorting tray should read the base first, since the maker’s name is usually stamped there.

Material Before Appearance in Any Tin

Sorting by what a button looks like produces piles that have to be sorted again. Material is the organizing fact, because it determines the buyer, the price band, and the reference book that applies, and two buttons of identical appearance can differ in price by an order of magnitude depending on whether one is glass and the other plastic.

Weight, temperature against the skin, sound when tapped against a tooth, and surface under magnification settle nearly every case. A working method runs the tin once for material, then within each material for size and condition.

Appearance sorting is how a carved pearl piece ends up in the bulk jar.

Lone Designer Buttons Adrift

A single button from a designer garment almost never carries the value people expect from the name stamped on it. Buttons were produced in sets for a specific garment, and the market that pays for them consists of people repairing or restoring that garment, which means a partial run has limited use.

Signed metal examples from mid century French and Italian houses do sell, but the gap between one and a matched run of six is enormous. Replacement buttons ordered from a fashion house often carry the same marking as originals, which complicates authentication further.

The complete set is the unit of value here.

Sorting Through Someone Else’s Patience

A button tin is an accidental archive. Nobody assembled it with intent, and yet it records what a household wore, mended, and could not bring itself to discard across several generations.

The pearl came off a shirt that wore out in 1910, the phenolic resin came off a coat bought in 1935, and the plastic animals came off a child’s cardigan in 1954. Reading the tin in that order costs nothing and changes what the sorting feels like.

Most of the contents will go back into the tin, and that is the honest outcome. Value in these things concentrates in a small number of pieces that reward knowing what to look at, and the rest is the raw material of ordinary domestic repair.

What survives is not the good clothing but the fasteners taken off it before the cloth went into the rag bag. That is a strange way to inherit a century of dressing, but it is the way it has come down.

More from Home As We Make It

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.