31 Tools in Garage Lots Worth Sorting Through

Estate sales price tools by the box. A crate of rusty steel goes for the price of lunch, and buried in it there is frequently a plane, a saw, or a micrometer worth more than everything else in the garage combined.

Rust is not the disqualifier most people assume. Surface rust cleans off; pitting on a working surface, a cracked casting, or a lost cutter does not, and that distinction is what separates a good box from a heavy one.

Stanley Bedrock Bench Planes

The premium line, distinguished from the standard bench planes by a flat-sided frog seating that allowed adjustment without removing the blade. The quickest identification is the straight rather than rounded sides of the casting, visible in seconds.

Even in poor condition these outsell the standard planes substantially, and the larger sizes are the ones to check for first.

Stanley Bailey Bench Planes

Produced across roughly a century with constant small changes, which has generated an elaborate type study that collectors use to date any example within a few years. The features that matter are the lateral adjustment lever, the frog receiver, and the shape of the lever cap.

A pre-war plane with an original blade and an uncracked tote is worth several times a later one that looks identical to a casual eye.

Combination Plough Planes

Multi-function planes with interchangeable cutters, a fence, and a depth stop, capable of cutting grooves, rabbets, and beads. They were sold with a full set of cutters in a fitted box, and the cutters are what go missing.

A complete set with the box and every cutter present is worth a large multiple of the plane body alone.

Wooden Molding Planes with Maker Stamps

Before metal planes, every profile required its own wooden plane, and joiners owned dozens. Each carries a maker’s stamp on the toe and frequently an owner’s stamp as well.

Planes by documented eighteenth and early nineteenth century makers are collected for the stamp regardless of whether the plane still cuts.

Infill Planes

Dovetailed steel or iron shells filled with dense hardwood, made by a small number of British workshops and by individual craftsmen. The dovetails on the sides of the body are visible as faint lines and are the mark of the better construction.

Even unmarked infill planes of good quality sell for far more than any mass-produced plane.

Disston Handsaws

The medallion in the handle changed design repeatedly across the company’s production, allowing a saw to be dated from that one detail. Earlier saws used better steel and have a distinctive flex when the plate is bent.

Etching on the plate is usually worn away, and a saw with a legible etch is markedly more desirable.

Backsaws and Dovetail Saws

Smaller saws with a folded brass or steel spine along the top edge, used for joinery. Brass-backed examples from named makers outsell steel-backed ones, and the spine can be checked for a maker’s stamp.

A saw with an unmodified handle and an unbent plate is worth restoring, and the sharpening is straightforward for a specialist.

Millers Falls Hand Drills

Geared hand drills with hardwood handles and a storage compartment in the grip for drill points. The company’s numbering system identifies the model, and the larger two-speed drills are the desirable ones.

A drill with its original set of points still in the handle compartment is a pleasant and not uncommon surprise.

Ratcheting Bit Braces

Braces with a ratcheting mechanism and a shell chuck, used for boring with tapered-shank bits. The better versions have a lignum vitae head that turns on a bearing, and the ratchet should engage crisply in both directions.

Sweep size, measured across the crank, determines both use and value, with the larger sweeps generally worth more.

Spiral Ratchet Screwdrivers

Push-action drivers that convert downward pressure into rotation, sold in several sizes with interchangeable bits. The spiral mechanism gums up with old grease and locks, which makes most of them appear broken when they are simply dirty.

Complete examples with the original bits in the handle magazine are worth well above the bare tool.

Machinist Squares and Straightedges

Precision squares ground to a tolerance measured in ten-thousandths, marked by makers whose names still carry weight in machine shops. A square that has been dropped is no longer square and no longer worth anything, so checking against a known reference is essential.

Boxed examples with their original case have usually avoided that fate.

Micrometers

Precision measuring instruments with a graduated thimble, sold in sets covering different ranges. The frames are robust but the anvil faces chip, and corrosion on the spindle threads is terminal.

A boxed set from a recognized maker with the standard gauge bars present is the version worth buying.

Vernier and Dial Calipers

Measuring tools that read to a thousandth of an inch, sold in fitted cases that most have long since left. The jaws wear at the tips and the beam can bend, both of which destroy accuracy.

Older vernier instruments with a satin chrome finish and crisp engraving are collected as much for their appearance as their use.

Machinist Chests

Oak or walnut chests with felt-lined drawers, built to hold precision instruments and frequently carrying the original owner’s name on a plate. The better makes have a locking front panel that secures every drawer at once.

A chest in good condition is a substantial object in its own right, and the contents are often worth more still.

Professional Wrench Sets

Tool sets sold to working mechanics through dealer trucks carry lifetime warranties and were built accordingly. Older sets in the original metal box with a full complement of sizes are what collectors and working mechanics both pursue.

Missing sizes cut into value disproportionately, since a partial set is just loose wrenches.

Drop-Forged Wrenches from Named Makers

Open-end and box wrenches from the pre-war American forging companies are heavier and better finished than modern equivalents. Each carries a maker’s mark and a pattern number forged into the shank.

Odd patterns made for specific manufacturers or industries are the ones that draw specialist interest.

Adjustable Wrenches with Maker Marks

Most adjustable wrenches are worth nothing, with the exception of early examples from the original Swedish patent holder and certain American makers. The marking is stamped into the handle and often obscured by rust.

The jaw should close parallel with no lateral play, which is the functional test and the first thing a buyer checks.

Original Locking Pliers

The locking plier was patented by a blacksmith in Nebraska, and early production carried the town name stamped on the tool. Those early stamped examples are collected specifically.

The adjusting screw should turn freely and the release lever should snap, which is the entire mechanical test.

Bullet-Pattern Machinist Vises

Heavy bench vises with a rounded body casting, produced for machine shops and prized for their rigidity. The swivel base is frequently missing, since vises were often bolted down directly.

Weight is a reliable first indicator, and a vise that moves easily by hand is probably a lighter import rather than the desirable version.

Blacksmith Anvils

Wrought iron anvils with a hardened steel face are dated and located by their shape and by any maker’s stamp on the side. Damage to the face edge and a dead rebound both indicate a delaminated or heat-damaged tool worth far less.

Anvils are heavy enough that sellers price them to move, which is why they turn up underpriced.

Post Drills

Hand-cranked drill presses mounted to a wall post, with automatic feed mechanisms on the better models. They were superseded by electric machines and left in barns.

The feed pawl and the table crank are the components usually missing, and a complete working example has real value beyond its decorative appeal.

Drawknives

Two-handled blades pulled toward the user to shape green wood, used by chairmakers, wheelwrights, and coopers. Blades from named makers command a premium, and the handles should be original rather than replaced.

A blade with substantial life left before the bevel runs out is the practical test.

Froes

An L-shaped blade struck with a mallet to split timber along the grain, used for shingles and chair parts. They look like agricultural junk and are priced that way, which is fortunate for anyone who knows what they are.

The eye where the handle fits should be uncracked, since a split eye is difficult to repair.

Adzes

Curved blades mounted at right angles to a handle, used for hewing timber and shaping bowls. The variety of patterns, from shipbuilding to coopering to gutter adzes, gives this a collecting structure of its own.

The handle is usually replaced, which matters less here than the condition of the cutting edge and the eye.

Spokeshaves

Small two-handled tools for shaping curved work, made in both wooden and metal versions. The wooden ones with a tapered tanged blade are older and frequently overlooked in boxes.

Metal spokeshaves from the major makers are common, but the specialist patterns for concave and convex work are not.

Cast Steel Chisels

Bevel-edge and mortise chisels from nineteenth-century makers used steel harder than most modern production and hold an edge accordingly. The maker’s stamp appears on the blade near the bolster and is often hidden under rust.

A chisel with the original handle, an unbroken bolster, and plenty of remaining length is what to keep.

Natural Sharpening Stones

Quarried stones, particularly the novaculite grades from Arkansas and certain Belgian and Japanese stones, remain sought after despite modern synthetic alternatives. Age is irrelevant; what matters is the grade, the flatness, and the absence of cracks.

A dished stone can be flattened, so a hollow surface is not a reason to leave it behind.

Boxwood and Brass Folding Rules

Jointed rules in boxwood with brass fittings, made in patterns specific to trades including carpentry, cabinetmaking, and gauging. The joints wear loose and the boxwood darkens, both of which are acceptable.

Rules with ivory scales, arch joints, and named makers occupy the top of the category, and the joint quality is where the maker’s grade shows.

Levels with Brass-Bound Hardwood

Rosewood and mahogany levels bound in brass were sold as premium tools and frequently presented as retirement gifts. The vials are the failure point, since the liquid evaporates and the glass cracks.

A level with intact vials, tight brass, and a legible maker’s plate is a genuinely attractive object as well as a working tool.

Machinist Oilers

Long-spouted pump oil cans in brass and steel, used for precision lubrication at a machine. They are decorative, inexpensive, and frequently discarded, which is why good marked examples remain findable.

The pump mechanism should click and deliver, which is easy to test with a thumb.

Saw Vises and Saw Sets

Clamps for holding a saw plate while sharpening, and the pliers-type tools that bend alternate teeth to set the kerf. Both were essential when saws were maintained rather than replaced, and both are now cheap because almost nobody sharpens a saw.

Anyone who does needs them, and the good cast-iron vises are becoming harder to find.

The Economics of a Heavy Box

Tools are sold cheaply at estate sales for a practical reason: they are heavy, dirty, and take up space, and the family clearing the house wants the garage empty by Sunday. Nobody is going to research forty items to squeeze another hundred out of the lot.

That is the entire opportunity, and it will not last indefinitely. The dealers who buy these boxes are pricing them on the two or three items they recognize, which means the value still sits in the items nobody has learned to recognize yet.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.