31 Kitchen Drawer Relics Worth Real Money

Every family has one drawer that refuses to close properly. It jams on a rotary beater, a can opener with a painted handle, and a scoop nobody remembers buying.

Some of that clutter has a following. Collectors, chefs and prop stylists pay real money for the right maker’s mark, and the difference between a two dollar thrift find and a 200 dollar sale often comes down to a stamped name.

Butterscotch Catalin Utensil Handles

DepositPhotos

Kitchen tools from the 1930s and 1940s often wear handles of Bakelite or its cast cousin, Catalin, in butterscotch, cherry red, jade green and marbled swirls. Catalin was poured rather than molded, which gives it a deep, glassy color that ordinary plastic never matches. 

Collectors sort genuine pieces with a simple trick: rubbing the handle with a metal polish such as Simichrome usually leaves a yellow residue on old phenolic resin. Single spatulas and pastry forks typically sell for about 10 to 40 dollars, while matched sets in uncommon colors often bring more. 

Cracks, chips at the ferrule and loose rivets cut the price quickly.

A and J Rotary Egg Beaters

Unsplash/Crissy Jarvis

The A and J Manufacturing Company of Binghamton, New York, turned out enormous numbers of hand-cranked beaters in the early twentieth century before Ekco absorbed the brand in 1929. Many models carry the A and J stamp on the gear wheel, sometimes alongside the Ekco name, and some have catchy model names such as the Bingo. 

Painted wooden handles in red, green or ivory make them popular with decorators as well as collectors. Common examples usually sell for about 15 to 35 dollars. Smooth gears, intact paint and blades that are not bent are what lift a beater above the pile at an estate sale.

Dover Stamping Company Beaters

Shutterstock

Before most kitchens had electricity, the name Dover was close to a generic term for an egg beater in America. The Dover Stamping Company of Boston patented its rotary design in the 1870s, and its cast iron gear wheels often show patent dates in raised lettering. 

Early versions with the Dover name cast into the wheel draw the most interest, especially in smaller sizes made for mixing in a cup. Typical examples sell for about 20 to 60 dollars, and rare variants can go higher at specialist auctions. Rust on the gear and a wobbly center shaft both hold the price down.

Holt-Lyon Beaters From Tivoli

DepositPhotos

Tivoli, a small Hudson Valley village in New York, was home to the Holt-Lyon Company, a maker of rotary beaters in the early twentieth century. Holt-Lyon beaters carry the company name and patent markings on the frame, which help collectors tell them apart from the many Dover imitators of the era. 

Unusual frame shapes and earlier patent dates are what specialists look for. Most examples change hands for about 20 to 50 dollars, with scarcer models priced higher. A frozen crank or heavy pitting can make an otherwise good example a decorator piece instead of a collector one.

Androck Painted Handle Tools

DepositPhotos

Androck was the kitchen tool brand of the Washburn Company of Worcester, Massachusetts, and its name appears on whisks, strainers, potato mashers, graters and pastry blenders. The line is best known for wooden handles painted in bright red, green, yellow or blue, often with a contrasting band near the end. 

Matching color groups are what decorators want, so a full set in one shade can sell for well above the sum of its parts. Single tools usually bring about 8 to 25 dollars. Worn paint, split wood and missing hanging rings all count against them.

Ekco Flint Stainless Tools

DepositPhotos

Edward Katzinger founded his company in Chicago in 1888, and its Ekco brand became a fixture of postwar American kitchens. Collectors pay particular attention to the Flint line, a run of stainless spatulas, ladles, turners and forks with riveted handles that home cooks still use daily. 

Pieces stamped Flint and Made in USA are the ones people look for, and complete matching sets with a wall rack are especially popular. Single tools typically sell for about 10 to 30 dollars, while boxed sets often bring around 75 to 150 dollars. Missing rivets and handle cracks matter more than surface scratches.

Foley Food Mills From Minneapolis

Shutterstock

Minneapolis was home to the Foley Manufacturing Company, which sold its hand-cranked food mill to generations of home canners, and many units carry patent number 1,921,936 stamped into the rim. 

The design presses cooked tomatoes, apples and potatoes through a perforated plate while leaving skins and seeds behind, which is why serious cooks still prefer it for sauce. Collectors and working kitchens both buy them. Typical prices land around 15 to 40 dollars, with larger sizes and early examples commanding more. A bent blade, a cracked plate or a missing spring clip makes the mill hard to use.

Bromwell Flour Sifters

DepositPhotos

Jacob Bromwell began making housewares in Cincinnati in 1819, and the company still sells sifters today, which makes vintage Bromwell pieces easy to trace. Older Bromwell’s Measuring Sifters carry printed graphics of flowers, fruit or recipes on the tin body, and those lithographed designs are what collectors chase. 

Crank and squeeze-handle models both appear regularly at estate sales. Most sell for about 12 to 40 dollars. Rust on the screen, faded graphics and a crank that grinds instead of turning all knock the value down, and dented bodies are hard to repair.

Swing-A-Way Can Openers

DepositPhotos

Swing-A-Way was a St. Louis manufacturer whose hand-held and wall-mounted can openers became standard equipment in American kitchens after World War II. Older openers stamped with the St. Louis address and Made in USA are prized by cooks who find modern versions flimsy by comparison. 

The wall-mounted models with a swing-out arm, the source of the brand name, have a loyal following among people restoring mid-century kitchens. Typical prices run about 15 to 45 dollars, more for unused examples on original cards. A dull cutting wheel or stripped gear makes an opener a parts piece.

Hinged Wooden Lemon Squeezers

DepositPhotos

Before glass reamers took over, many kitchens pressed citrus with a hinged wooden squeezer, two maple or hardwood arms joined by a pin with a cup carved into one side. Better nineteenth-century versions added a white porcelain or glass insert in the cup so the acid would not stain the wood, and later makers produced similar presses in cast iron. 

Collectors like the warm, worn color of old hardwood and the hand-shaped look of early examples. Typical prices fall around 25 to 80 dollars. Splits along the grain, loose hinges and a chipped insert all lower the value.

Advertising Ice Picks

DepositPhotos

In the icebox era, ice companies, dairies, coal dealers and hardware stores handed out ice picks with their names printed on the wooden handle. Many of these picks never left the kitchen drawer after refrigerators arrived, which is why they still turn up by the dozen at estate sales. Collectors focus on the advertising, especially small-town businesses, phone numbers with only a few digits and unusual handle colors. 

Most sell for about 8 to 25 dollars, with rare local names bringing more. Faded lettering, a bent point and a loose ferrule reduce the price.

Carbon Steel Sabatier Knives

Unsplash/Joseph Van

Sabatier is a name rather than a single company, used by several knife makers around Thiers, the historic cutlery town in central France, since the nineteenth century. Vintage carbon steel Sabatier chef’s knives are prized by cooks because the steel takes a very fine edge and develops a dark patina with use. 

Buyers study the stamped marks, such as the letter K on K Sabatier blades, to identify the maker. Older chef’s knives typically sell for about 60 to 200 dollars. Heavy rust pitting, a blade worn narrow by years of sharpening and a loose handle all reduce value.

Bull-Head Cast Iron Can Openers

DepositPhotos

Some of the earliest American can openers were cast iron levers shaped like a bull’s head, with a blade extending from the bull’s mouth and a curved tail as the handle. They date to the second half of the nineteenth century, when canned food was common but purpose-made openers were still new. 

Authentic examples show worn edges and old surface color, while reproductions tend to look crisp and uniformly painted. Genuine early openers typically sell for about 50 to 150 dollars. Breaks at the tail, welded repairs and fresh paint all reduce value sharply.

Vaughan Church Key Openers

DepositPhotos

Vaughan Novelty Manufacturing was founded in Chicago in 1910, and its Quick and Easy openers became some of the most familiar church keys in America. The tool took on a new life after flat-top beer cans arrived in 1935, since every can needed a pointed opener to punch the lid. Many church keys carry brewery or soda advertising, and collectors chase rare brands and regional breweries. 

Common examples sell for about 3 to 15 dollars, while scarce advertising pieces can reach about 50 dollars or more. Rust and worn lettering matter, because the printed logo is the main attraction.

Figural Cast Iron Bottle Openers

DepositPhotos

Painted cast iron openers shaped like parrots, pelicans, mermaids, cowboys and drunks leaning on lampposts were popular from the 1930s through the 1950s. The Figural Bottle Opener Collectors club organizes the hobby, and members study casting numbers and paint to spot later copies. 

Companies such as Wilton Products and John Wright produced later versions, which sell for less than period originals. Common originals typically bring about 25 to 100 dollars, and rare figures can sell for several hundred. Original paint matters enormously, so repainted pieces lose much of their value.

Thomason Patent Corkscrews

DepositPhotos

Edward Thomason of Birmingham, England, patented a mechanical corkscrew in 1802 that drew the cork with a turning handle and a threaded barrel. Many examples carry a brass barrel, sometimes with a Royal coat of arms and the motto Ne Plus Ultra. These are serious collector items rather than kitchen gadgets, and specialist corkscrew auctions sell them regularly. 

Ordinary examples often sell for about 300 to 800 dollars, while rare variants have brought far more. Collectors watch for replaced handles, missing side handles and worn worms, because originality drives the price.

Cast Iron Dog Nutcrackers

DepositPhotos

Cast iron nutcrackers shaped like a dog, where pressing the tail closes the jaw on a walnut, were common in American homes from the late 1800s into the early 1900s. Squirrels, alligators and eagles also appear, but the dog is the classic form collectors recognize first. Reproductions are plentiful, so buyers look at casting quality, wear on the tail and old surface patina. 

Period dog nutcrackers typically sell for about 40 to 120 dollars. Broken springs, repainted surfaces and chipped teeth all pull prices down, and new castings with rough seams sell for much less.

Gilchrist Number 31 Scoops

DepositPhotos

The Gilchrist Company of Newark, New Jersey, produced the No. 31 ice cream disher around 1915, and soda fountain fans consider it one of the best mechanical scoops ever made. The cone-shaped bowl, nickeled brass body and thumb-squeeze release are its signatures. 

Sizes are numbered on the key, from large to small, and some sizes are rarer than others. Working examples usually sell for about 60 to 200 dollars, while rare sizes can go higher. 

A sticky release, cracked wooden handle or worn plating all lower the price, and replaced parts are noted by serious buyers.

Zeroll Heat-Conducting Scoops

DepositPhotos

Sherman Kelly designed the Zeroll scoop in Toledo, Ohio, in 1935, with a sealed aluminum handle holding a fluid that transfers warmth from the hand to the bowl. The scoop has no moving parts, and the company still makes it, which explains why old ones turn up in so many drawers. 

Its design has been shown in museum collections as a classic of industrial design. Vintage Zerolls typically sell for about 15 to 40 dollars. A dented bowl or a handle that has lost its fluid is worth far less, and dishwasher damage can dull the original finish.

Reading Hardware Apple Parers

DepositPhotos

The Reading Hardware Company of Reading, Pennsylvania, made a cast iron apple parer marked 78, after its 1878 patent date. It clamps to a table edge and peels an apple with a crank, while a blade on a hinged arm follows the curve of the fruit. Collectors value complete, working examples with sharp blades and intact springs. 

Typical prices run about 50 to 150 dollars. Rust, broken arms and missing forks reduce value, and cracked castings are a serious defect because cast iron cannot be easily repaired without showing.

Enterprise Cherry Stoners

DepositPhotos

Philadelphia’s Enterprise Manufacturing Company, also known for coffee mills and meat grinders, sold cast iron cherry stoners with an 1883 patent date cast into the frame. The No. 1 model clamps to a table and pushes cherries through a rubber-lined opening as the crank turns. 

Other numbered models followed, and collectors tried to assemble the series. Typical examples sell for about 25 to 75 dollars. Missing clamps, rust and perished rubber parts all lower the price, though many buyers simply want the look on a farmhouse shelf.

Edgar Mechanical Nutmeg Graters

DepositPhotos

Called simply the Edgar, this spring-loaded nutmeg grater was made by the Edgar Manufacturing Company in the 1890s, with patent markings from 1891 on many examples. A nutmeg sits in a sliding holder and is pushed against a curved tin grater while the user moves the handle back and forth. 

Specialized collectors pursue these alongside dozens of other patented grater designs. Edgar usually sells for about 30 to 80 dollars. Rust on the tin and cracked wooden handles reduce value, and a missing spring or holder makes the grater incomplete.

Tinsmith Cookie Cutters

DepositPhotos

Handmade tin cookie cutters from the nineteenth century, especially those made by Pennsylvania German tinsmiths, are a serious folk art category. Shapes include horses, birds, hearts, people and stars, often with a flat back plate and solder lines visible inside. The rarest examples are large, complex figures that sell at specialist auctions. 

Common old cutters typically bring about 20 to 75 dollars, while exceptional folk art forms can sell for several hundred or more. Rust, broken solder seams and later reproductions are the main concerns, so careful buyers study construction details.

Advertising Biscuit Cutters

DepositPhotos

Baking powder and flour companies once gave away tin biscuit cutters with their names stamped on the top, and brands such as Rumford and Calumet appear often. These small cutters were kept in kitchen drawers for decades and now appeal to both advertising and kitchen collectors. 

Clear, readable lettering is the main point of value, since the cutter itself is simple. Most sell for about 10 to 30 dollars. Rust, flattened edges and faded lettering all count against them, while rare brands and unusual shapes bring more.

Mirro Cookie Presses

Shutterstock

Mirro Aluminum of Manitowoc, Wisconsin, made screw-driven cookie presses that became holiday staples in the 1950s and 1960s. Complete sets with the full range of shaping discs, decorating tips and the original recipe booklet are what buyers want, because missing discs make the press much less useful. 

The aluminum body ages to a soft gray, and the copper-toned versions have their own fans. Complete boxed sets typically sell for about 25 to 60 dollars. Bent discs, missing tips and a stiff plunger all lower the price.

Carved Springerle Rolling Pins

DepositPhotos

Springerle is a German anise cookie pressed with a carved wooden rolling pin or board that leaves a raised picture on the dough. Antique pins carry rows of small carved squares with birds, flowers and animals, and the quality of the carving drives value. Older pins are usually hand carved in fruitwood or maple, while later ones may be machine cut. 

Typical antique examples sell for about 40 to 150 dollars, and fine early pieces can bring more. Worn carving, cracks and missing handles reduce value, and old pins should never be soaked.

Carved Wooden Butter Stamps

“Butter Mold ca. 1790” by museado, source: Flickr, licensed under Public Domain

Before butter came in paper wrappers, farm families pressed their butter with carved wooden stamps showing cows, sheaves of wheat, flowers and stars. These stamps were a way to identify a family’s butter at market, and many were carved by hand in maple or other close-grained woods. 

Collectors look for deep, crisp carving and unusual motifs. Common examples typically sell for about 40 to 120 dollars, while rare designs bring several hundred or more. Splits, worn carving and replaced handles all reduce value, and later machine-made stamps sell for much less.

Graniteware Ladles and Skimmers

Unsplash/Trnava University

Enameled steel utensils known as graniteware were made in large quantities in the late 1800s and early 1900s, and Lalance and Grosjean sold a well-known version under the name Agate Ware. Ladles, skimmers and dippers in cobalt swirl, green swirl and gray mottled finishes are the ones collectors chase. 

Bright, uncommon colors bring much more than plain gray. Typical prices run about 15 to 60 dollars, with rare colors going higher. Chips in the enamel, rust and repairs all reduce value, though light wear is expected on pieces that were used daily.

Scrimshaw Pie Crimpers

DepositPhotos

Nineteenth-century whalers carved pie crimpers, sometimes called jagging wheels, from whalebone and whale ivory during long voyages, often as gifts for family at home. The best examples have elaborate handles with carved animals, hearts or geometric designs. Auction houses such as Bonhams and Eldred’s have sold them, and fine examples can bring thousands of dollars. Simple pieces often sell for a few hundred dollars. 

Cracks, missing wheels and repairs reduce value, and laws on selling marine ivory vary by state, so sellers check local rules before listing.

Cutco Knives From Olean

“Vintage Union Razor Cutlery Company Men’s Straight Razor, Union City Georgia” by Joe Haupt, source: Flickr, licensed under CC by -SA 2.0

Cutco began in 1949 in Olean, New York, as a joint venture between Alcoa and the cutlery maker W. R. Case and Sons. The brand became famous for selling knives through home demonstrations and for a lifetime guarantee that still applies to older pieces. Vintage knives with brown or swirled handles are popular with buyers who want a set that can be sharpened or replaced. 

Individual knives typically sell for about 15 to 50 dollars, while large sets in wooden blocks bring more. Chipped blades and cracked handles reduce value, though the warranty can sometimes restore them.

Chicago Cutlery Walnut Handles

Photo by James Case, source: Flickr, licensed under Public Domain

Chicago Cutlery began in the 1930s making knives for butchers and meat packers, and its walnut-handled home knives became common in American kitchens later in the century. Older knives stamped with the company name and made in the United States are preferred over later imported versions. 

The heavy riveted walnut handles and carbon or high-carbon blades are the main selling points. Single knives typically sell for about 10 to 30 dollars, while full sets in original blocks bring about 50 to 120 dollars. Rust, chips and loose rivets lower the price.

Utensils Carry the Kitchen’s Memory

Unsplash/Ricky Singh

Most of these objects were bought cheaply and used hard for decades. Their value now comes from the fact that they were built to last, and that the companies behind them stamped names and patent dates into the metal. 

A buyer at an estate sale can often trace a beater or opener back to a town and a decade. A kitchen drawer holds more history than people expect. 

A bent scoop or rusty sifter may still be worth more than a new one, and sellers who check the marks before tossing anything out often find something worth keeping. The best finds tend to be the ones that were used every day.

More from Home As We Make It

DepositPhotos

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.

Similar Posts