30 Salt Cellars and Serving Pieces Dealers Hunt Down

Antique flatware drawers are full of objects that no longer have a job. Nobody serves sardines with a dedicated fork anymore, and nobody puts a dish of loose salt beside each plate.

The tools survived anyway, mostly because they were silver and nobody throws away silver.

Dealers know which of these small items move quickly and which sit in a case for years. The difference is rarely about beauty.

Georgian Sterling Master Salts with Cobalt Liners

The small footed bowls that held salt for an entire table were usually fitted with a deep blue glass liner, since salt attacks silver relentlessly. Original liners are the deciding factor at resale, because the glass cracked easily and replacements are obvious once the color and thickness are compared.

Pairs and sets of four sell far above singles. Interior pitting on the silver, caused by decades of contact where a liner was missing, is the standard condition problem and cannot be polished away.

Pressed Glass Individual Salt Dips

Produced by the thousands in nineteenth-century American glasshouses, these tiny dishes sat at each place setting and were replaced without ceremony when they broke. Collectors organize them by pattern, and a handful of patterns from short production runs carry prices out of all proportion to the object’s size.

Mold seams, fire polishing, and the weight of the glass all help separate period examples from later reproduction. Chips on the rim, which are common, cut value sharply since so many undamaged examples exist.

Cut Crystal Open Salts with Silver Rims

Deeply cut glass bowls fitted with a hallmarked silver collar combine two collecting fields, which widens the buyer pool considerably. The rim carries the marks, so a legible date letter and maker’s mark can make an otherwise ordinary piece worth pursuing.

Loose or dented collars suggest the glass has been replaced at some point, and dealers check the fit closely. Sets of six in a fitted case are what buyers genuinely hunt for.

Figural Novelty Salts

Miniature wheelbarrows, swans, coal scuttles, and rowing boats were made to hold salt and to amuse a table, and they were made in both silver and glass. The best of them have working details, such as wheels that turn or handles that lift.

Value is driven by inventiveness and by maker, with Dutch and German silver examples especially well represented. Soldered repairs to thin cast elements are common and should be assumed until proven otherwise.

Cranberry Glass Salts

The pink-to-red color came from gold added to the batch, which is why cranberry glass was never cheap and why reproduction pieces usually miss the tone. Salts in this glass often carry applied clear rims or enameled decoration, both of which add value when undamaged.

Dealers hold these back for collectors who assemble color runs rather than pattern runs. Enamel loss is the main condition issue, and repainting is detectable under magnification.

Vaseline Glass Salts

Uranium in the batch produces the pale yellow-green tone and the distinctive glow under a black light, which is the fastest authentication test in the business. Salts are a popular entry point for collectors because they are small, affordable, and unmistakable when tested.

Color depth varies between makers and eras, and the more saturated examples bring more. Reproductions exist and also glow, so form and mold quality still matter.

Souvenir Salts from Exposition Years

World’s fairs and expositions generated an enormous volume of small commemorative glass and silver, including salts stamped or etched with the event name and date. Value follows the event rather than the object, with less-documented regional fairs often outperforming the famous ones.

Faded or worn lettering removes the entire point of the piece. Dealers check for later-added decoration, since blank period salts were sometimes engraved decades afterward.

Sterling Salt Spoons with Gilded Bowls

Tiny spoons with gilt bowls were made in vast numbers, and most are worth modest sums individually. What dealers look for is the matched set in its original fitted case, or a spoon by a maker whose flatware patterns have a following.

The gilding protected the silver from salt corrosion, so a spoon with worn gilt and a pitted bowl tells its own history. Bent handles, surprisingly common in such a small object, are usually repairable.

Cased Salt Sets in Fitted Boxes

A silk-lined case holding matched salts and spoons was standard as a wedding or christening gift, and the case is a substantial part of the value. Buyers check whether the fittings match the recesses, because mismatched marriages of case and contents circulate widely.

Silk lining degrades and splits, which is accepted, while a missing lid is not. Complete sets with the retailer’s name printed inside the lid sell fastest.

Silver Overlay Salt Shakers

Glass with silver applied directly to the surface in vine or scroll patterns had a brief period of fashion around 1900, and the technique produced pieces that still look expensive. Overlay lifts at the edges with age and cleaning, and lifted silver is the first thing dealers examine.

Original stoppers and tops are frequently replaced. Marks on the overlay itself, rather than on a separate collar, are worth locating because they identify the workshop.

Muffineers and Sugar Casters

Tall, pierced-top shakers were used for sugar, spice, and sometimes salt, depending on the household, and they are among the most decorative items in this field. The pierced top is the fragile element, since the thin silver between the piercings fatigues and tears.

Hallmarked examples in matching pairs bring the most, and unmarked plated versions bring very little. Dents in the body can be pushed out by a silversmith, but a split top is expensive to address.

Wall-Mounted Wooden Salt Boxes

Before salt came in cardboard, it lived in a hinged wooden box hung near the fire so the contents stayed dry. Country examples in pine or oak with original paint bring solid money in the folk furniture market, particularly with a carved or painted date.

The hinged slanted lid is where wear appears, and replaced lids are common. Interior salt corrosion darkens the wood permanently, which collectors read as evidence rather than damage.

Salt-Glazed Stoneware Salt Crocks

Small stoneware crocks with a lid and a hanging lug served the same purpose in ceramic form, often with cobalt lettering identifying the contents. German and American examples both circulate, and the lettering style helps place them.

Lids survive at a much lower rate than bodies, so a complete example with its original lid carries a real premium. Hairline cracks are tolerated when the piece is decorative rather than functional.

Marrow Scoops

Long, narrow, double-ended silver implements designed to extract marrow from roasted bones look like nothing else in a drawer, which is exactly why buyers want them. Georgian examples in sterling are the core of the market, and the elongated form makes them vulnerable to bending.

Buyers check both ends for repairs, since the narrow channel splits under pressure. Marked examples by known makers sell well above unmarked ones.

Mote Spoons

A pierced bowl for skimming tea leaves and a sharp point on the end for clearing a blocked spout made this one of the more ingenious objects of the eighteenth-century tea table. The pierced bowl damages easily, and a piece with broken piercing loses much of its value.

Genuine examples are considerably less common than the reproduction market suggests. Dealers examine the taper of the point and the quality of the piercing before anything else.

Asparagus Servers

Broad, flat, scissor-action or spatula-form servers made for a single vegetable represent the peak of specialized dining. Pierced blade patterns are the attraction, and the finer the piercing, the stronger the interest.

Silver plate versions are common and inexpensive; sterling examples with matching flatware patterns are what dealers actually chase. Blade distortion from use is normal and correctable, while cracked piercing is not.

Matched Pairs of Fish Servers

A knife and fork with engraved blades and often bone or ivory-colored handles, sold as a cased pair, were a standard wedding gift for most of the nineteenth century. Value depends heavily on the engraving quality and whether both pieces survive together.

Handles shrink, crack, and loosen over time, and a rattling handle signals a repair or a rebuild. Cased sets with original fitted interiors are the version buyers want.

Berry Spoons with Gilded Bowls

Large serving spoons with repoussé fruit decoration and a gilt-washed bowl were often created by decorating plain Georgian spoons decades after they were made, a practice that divides collectors sharply. Dealers check whether the decoration disturbs the hallmarks, which indicates later work.

Original period examples are worth more, but the later decorated pieces have their own steady market. Gilt wear inside the bowl is expected and rarely penalized.

Sardine Forks

Short, broad, and pierced, these were made for lifting fish from a tin without breaking them, and they exist in surprising variety. Many were sold as part of a cased set with a matching sardine box lid. The wide flat tines bend, and bent tines are usually the reason one is priced low.

Novelty examples with fish-shaped handles attract buyers who otherwise have no interest in flatware.

Sugar Sifter Ladles

A ladle with a pierced bowl for dusting sugar over fruit or pastry sits at the decorative end of the drawer, and the piercing patterns can be remarkable. Georgian examples with fine piercing and bright-cut engraving are the standard target.

As with mote spoons, the piercing is the weak point, and a repaired bowl is immediately visible against the light. Gilding inside the bowl protected the silver and is a good sign when present.

Olive Spoons

A pierced bowl with a long handle, sometimes ending in a small fork, gave olives their own tool in a well-equipped house. These are among the cheaper specialized pieces and sell steadily to people assembling a working table rather than a collection.

Pattern matching matters, since most buyers already own a flatware service and want a piece that belongs to it. Unmarked continental examples are common and priced accordingly.

Pickle Forks and Pickle Castors

The fork is a small object; the castor is a glass jar in a silver plated frame with a lid and a hanging fork, and it is the frame that draws attention. Complete castors with the original glass insert, lid, and fork sell for many times the value of a frame alone.

The glass insert is usually pattern glass and is frequently replaced with something close but wrong. Replating diminishes value if it softens the cast detail.

Stilton and Cheese Scoops

A curved blade for lifting cheese from the center of a round, often with a bone or horn handle, is a form that was made for over two centuries with surprisingly little change. Silver-bladed examples with hallmarks and original handles are the premium version.

Handle shrinkage causes the ferrule to loosen, which is the most common defect. Buyers also look for scoops with a small sliding ejector, a refinement that adds interest.

Punch Ladles

Deep-bowled ladles with twisted baleen or turned wooden handles, sometimes with a coin set into the base of the bowl, belong to an era of communal drinking that furnished its own equipment. The inset coin, when original, is a dating feature and a selling point.

Handles snap at the join, and a replaced handle substantially reduces value. Silver bowls with a pouring lip at each side are worth checking for marks along the rim.

Tomato Servers

A flat pierced blade, usually round or leaf-shaped, made for lifting slices without crushing them, sits among the most collectible of the specialized servers because the pierced patterns vary so widely. Sterling examples in recognizable flatware patterns sell reliably.

The thin blade bends and the piercing cracks, and neither issue repairs invisibly. Silver plated versions are abundant and worth little unless the pattern is unusual.

Cake Breakers

A comb-like implement with long thin tines, designed to divide angel food cake without compressing it, is a twentieth-century form that collectors treat with genuine affection. Most are silver plated and modestly priced, while sterling examples in matching patterns bring more.

Bent or missing tines are the common fault and effectively end the piece’s usefulness. Original boxes turn up occasionally and add meaningfully to the price.

Crumb Trays and Scrapers

A curved blade and a matching tray, used to sweep a tablecloth between courses, formed a set that rarely survives complete. Engraved and pierced examples in silver plate were produced in quantity; sterling sets with a hallmarked blade and tray are the ones dealers pursue.

Wear to the blade edge from decades of scraping is expected. The tray is usually the missing half, since it was more easily repurposed.

Butter Picks and Master Butter Knives

A butter pick is a small twisted implement for lifting a pat of butter, and it looks sufficiently odd that buyers often ask what it is before asking the price. Master butter knives with wide flat blades are more common and less interesting to collectors.

Sterling examples in named patterns sell into the flatware market rather than the curiosity market. Bent picks are simple to correct and should not be a deal breaker.

Grape Shears

Scissor-form silver shears for cutting a small bunch from a larger one belong to the fruit service of a formal table, and they are among the most attractive tools in the field. The pivot is where wear concentrates, and loose shears with sloppy action sell for less.

Cast handles with vine and grape decoration are the version buyers want. Cased pairs with a matching fruit knife are sought after well beyond their practical use.

Nut Cracking Sets with Picks

A cracker and six picks in a fitted case turn up at nearly every estate sale, which is exactly why dealers are selective about which they take. Silver plated sets in tired boxes are a hard sell, while sterling picks with a matching pattern go into the flatware trade at once.

The cracker’s hinge and jaw alignment are worth testing, since a sprung cracker is finished. Complete sets with all six picks are less common than the volume of incomplete ones suggests.

The Small Objects a Table Forgot

Almost none of these tools has a function anymore. The salt dips were made obsolete by a cardboard cylinder with a metal spout, and the sardine fork lost its argument the moment anybody decided a regular fork would do.

What survives is the craft, which is why dealers keep hunting. A pierced mote spoon or a Georgian salt with its cobalt liner intact carries more evidence of skill per gram than almost anything else that passes through a sale, and it fits in a coat pocket.

That combination has kept a market alive for objects that stopped being useful a century ago.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.