30 Old Tackle Boxes Worth Opening

An old tackle box smells like varnish, dried weed, and rust, and most of them contain about six dollars of tangled monofilament. Every so often one holds a wooden plug with glass eyes, or a reel that cost a week’s wages in 1955.

The difference is usually decided in the bottom tray, under the sinkers, where nobody has looked in forty years.

Knowing what to pull out first saves an afternoon. A handful of makers and a few construction details account for nearly all the money in vintage tackle.

Heddon Wooden Lures with Glass Eyes

James Heddon’s company in Dowagiac, Michigan helped build the American wooden plug business, and the eyes date the bait. Glass eyes with a wire pin through the center were standard until roughly 1940, after which Heddon moved to painted and tack eyes to save cost and labor.

A glass-eyed River Runt, Vamp, or Crazy Crawler in a scarce color pattern, with original hardware and no repaint, is the find. Check the belly hardware, since two-piece surface rigs signal earlier production than the later screw-and-cup arrangement.

Common glass-eyed Heddons in fished condition run $20 to $75, while rare patterns with the correct box and papers reach the high hundreds.

Creek Chub Pikies and Wiggle Fish

Creek Chub of Garrett, Indiana produced the Pikie Minnow from 1920 onward in an exhausting range of sizes and finishes, so a plain Pikie is worth very little. The money is in the color patterns that sold poorly, and in jointed models like the Wiggle Fish, which used a hinged tail and a metal lip and ran from the mid 1920s into the 1950s.

Original paint on Creek Chub baits chalks rather than flakes, so a suspiciously glossy finish usually means a repaint. Ordinary examples bring $15 to $50.

A Wiggle Fish in a scarce finish with its correct two-piece cardboard box can reach several hundred.

Pflueger Supreme Casting Reels

Pflueger, operating in Akron, Ohio as the Enterprise Manufacturing Company, made the Supreme level-wind casting reel for decades, and it turns up in tackle boxes far more often than people expect. The early jeweled models with German silver end plates and a free-spool lever are the ones worth setting aside.

Spin the spool: a Supreme in sound condition runs almost silently and the level wind tracks without hesitation. Corrosion under the end cap is the usual killer, and a missing click pawl is difficult to replace.

Clean vintage Supremes commonly sell in the $40 to $150 range, with early jeweled examples and correct boxes going higher.

Shakespeare Wooden Minnows and Level Winds

Shakespeare of Kalamazoo, Michigan held an important early patent on the level-wind mechanism and made both reels and wooden baits in quantity. Early Shakespeare minnows with multiple side hooks, glass eyes, and brass hardware belong to the first decades of the last century and are genuinely scarce with intact paint.

The reels are more common and more variable, ranging from plain steel service models to nickel silver and jeweled versions with engraved end plates. Look for the model name stamped on the end plate rather than the reel foot.

Sound reels usually run $30 to $120, while an early wooden minnow with unbroken paint can be several hundred.

South Bend Bass-Oreno

South Bend, working out of Indiana, introduced the Bass-Oreno in the middle 1910s, and it became one of the most widely sold plugs in the country. That volume means the standard red-and-white or frog pattern in fished condition is nearly worthless as a collectible.

What matters is the early version with glass eyes, the odd factory colors, and the smaller and larger family members such as the Babe-Oreno and the Musk-Oreno. Original wire-through construction and unchipped paint separate a real find from a shelf ornament.

Common examples sell for $10 to $30, while a boxed early glass-eyed Bass-Oreno in strong paint can reach $150 or more.

Paw Paw Wooden Baits

Paw Paw Bait Company of Paw Paw, Michigan made wooden lures from the 1930s through the 1960s, often with hand-painted detail that ranks among the most attractive of the period. Many Paw Paw baits were sold unmarked or under hardware store names, so identification comes down to body shapes, the distinctive rounded lips, and the way the gill marks were brushed on.

The mouse and frog patterns have a following well beyond their fishing merit. Paint chipping at the nose is standard from tackle box contact. Typical Paw Paw lures bring $20 to $60, with scarce patterns in strong original paint reaching $150 to $400.

Fred Arbogast Jitterbugs and Hula Poppers

Fred Arbogast of Akron introduced the Jitterbug in the late 1930s, and its double-cupped metal lip gives the lure the side-to-side waddle that still catches fish. Wartime metal restrictions forced the company to make the lip from plastic for a period in the early 1940s, and those plastic-lipped examples are the ones collectors want.

The Hula Popper arrived after the war and used the rubber skirt Arbogast had already built a business on. Rubber skirts perish, so an intact original skirt adds real money.

Common Jitterbugs sell for $5 to $20, while a plastic-lipped wartime example with a correct box can bring $75 to $250.

Bomber Wooden Plugs

Bomber Bait Company of Gainesville, Texas made a fat wooden diving plug with a distinctive angled nose and no separate lip, patented in the 1930s. The early wooden Bombers have through-wire construction and a rounded body that later plastic versions imitate without quite matching.

Check for the stenciled model information on the belly, which wears off quickly and is often the only marking present. Scale-pattern and shiner finishes in unfaded condition are the ones to keep.

Wooden Bombers in fished condition run $10 to $35, while unfished examples with intact stenciling and original boxes reach $80 to $200.

Early Rapala Balsa Minnows

Lauri Rapala carved his first balsa minnows in Finland in the 1930s, wrapping them in foil from candy wrappers to get the flash of a wounded baitfish. American distribution began at the end of the 1950s, and a 1962 magazine feature turned the lure into a national phenomenon almost overnight.

Early imported Rapalas came in plain cardboard sleeves with Finnish-language printing, and those sleeves are worth more than many of the lures inside them. Balsa dents easily, so undamaged early examples are uncommon.

Boxed early Rapalas commonly bring $30 to $120, while loose fished ones are worth a few dollars.

Al Foss Pork Rind Minnows in Tins

Al Foss of Cleveland sold pocket-sized metal wobblers designed to be dressed with a strip of pork rind, and he packaged them in flat printed tins that are now the collectible half of the equation. The Oriental Wiggler and its relatives used a single weedless hook and a thin spinner, and the tin usually held a jar or packet of rind that has long since dried to leather.

Graphics on the tins are bright, period-specific, and easy to date. A loose Foss wobbler is worth $10 to $25.

The same lure in a clean, unrusted tin with its insert commonly brings $50 to $150.

Shur-Strike Hardware Store Lures

Shur-Strike baits were made by Creek Chub for hardware distributors and jobbers, which is why they look like Creek Chub lures built to a lower price. The bodies are often the same shapes with simpler paint, cheaper eye treatments, and lighter hardware.

Because they were sold as house-brand tackle rather than premium baits, most were fished hard and few survive with strong finish. That scarcity of clean examples partly offsets their lower original status.

Most Shur-Strike lures sell for $10 to $40, though an unusual color in crisp condition with its box can surprise people and reach three figures.

Dardevle Spoons from Lou Eppinger

Lou Eppinger began making spoons in Detroit early in the last century, and the red-and-white striped Dardevle became one of the most recognizable objects in American fishing. The name traces to a First World War nickname for the Marines, and the spelling on the lure has varied across the decades, which is the main dating clue.

Early spoons are heavier brass with hand-applied enamel and a stamped Eppinger mark on the concave side. Later production is lighter and machine-finished.

Ordinary Dardevles are worth a dollar or two, but early marked examples in clean enamel with original card packaging run $25 to $90.

Johnson Silver Minnow Weedless Spoons

The Johnson Silver Minnow is a single-hook weedless spoon with a wire guard, made by the Louis Johnson Company and in production for roughly a century. Early examples are genuine silver-plated or solid nickel silver rather than the later chrome, and they carry a stamped mark on the concave face.

The wire weed guard is the part that matters, since bent, missing, or replaced guards cut the value immediately. Original card packaging with period graphics is uncommon and adds more than the lure itself is worth.

Loose Silver Minnows bring $5 to $15, while early marked examples on original cards reach $40 to $100.

Mepps Spinners and the Antigo Connection

Mepps spinners are French, designed around a rotating blade on a shaft, and they reached American anglers through a tackle dealer in Antigo, Wisconsin who began importing them in the 1950s. The early imports came on printed cards with French text and used a squirrel-tail dressing on the treble hook.

Brass and nickel blades from that era are stamped with the pattern name and tarnish to a warm tone that later copies do not match. More recent production is cleaner and far less interesting.

Loose Mepps spinners are worth very little, while early carded examples in unopened packaging commonly bring $15 to $50.

Zebco 33 and 202 Spincast Reels

Zebco, formed out of the Zero Hour Bomb Company in Tulsa, introduced the 33 spincast reel in the mid 1950s and sold them in enormous numbers, which is why most examples are worth almost nothing. Value hinges entirely on the early all-metal versions: a 33 with a metal foot, metal thumb button, and no plastic in the body is a different object from the later ones.

The 202 is the cheaper sibling and rarely worth anything at all. Check the underside of the foot for a two-letter date code.

Early metal 33s in working order run $30 to $90, later plastic versions under $15.

Mitchell 300 Spinning Reels

The Mitchell spinning reel, made in France by Carpano and Pons, arrived in the late 1940s, took the 300 designation in 1957, and became a design other makers measured themselves against. Early examples have a half-bail rather than a full wire, a distinctive gray crackle finish, and French markings on the foot.

Later production, including reels assembled in other countries, is common and cheap. The half-bail models, along with matching leather cases or original cardboard boxes, carry the value.

A clean early Mitchell 300 with its box commonly brings $60 to $200, while a fished later model is worth $20 to $40.

Abu Ambassadeur 5000 and 6000 Series

ABU of Svangsta, Sweden introduced the Ambassadeur 5000 in the early 1950s, and the round red casting reel became a benchmark for durable bait-casting hardware. Early reels have brass gears, a two-screw takedown, and a code stamped on the foot that collectors use to place them within a year or two.

The matching leather pouch, wrench, and oil bottle raise the price substantially, and most have been separated from the reel. Corroded spool shafts and stripped screw heads are the common faults.

Clean early Ambassadeurs run $80 to $300, with boxed complete sets in unworn condition going considerably higher.

Hardy Fly Reels in the Bottom Tray

A Hardy reel in an otherwise ordinary tackle box is the kind of accident that pays for the box several times over. Hardy Brothers of Alnwick, England made the Perfect from the 1890s onward, and the model name, patent details, and trademarks are stamped on the back plate.

Check the foot for filing, a common alteration that cuts the value hard, and rotate the drum to listen for even resistance. Later mass-market Hardy reels are worth far less than the earlier English-made ones.

Depending on model, age, and condition, Hardy reels range from around $100 to well past $1,000.

Wheatley Fly Boxes

Richard Wheatley of Birmingham, England made aluminum fly boxes with individually sprung lids over small compartments, a design that has barely changed since the early twentieth century. The clips snap with a specific sound, and a box with every spring still working is far less common than it ought to be.

Older boxes carry a stamped maker name inside the lid and use a japanned black finish rather than modern anodizing. Dented corners and sprung lids that no longer seat are the usual faults.

Vintage Wheatley boxes in sound condition commonly bring $40 to $150, more when they arrive filled with period flies.

Hand-Tied Salmon Flies

Classic Atlantic salmon flies, tied on blind-eye hooks with twisted gut loops, predate the modern eyed hook and are small pieces of Victorian craft rather than working tackle. The dressings follow named patterns such as the Jock Scott and the Durham Ranger, built in strict layers of dyed feather over a tinsel body.

Moths ruin them, so examine the tips of the wings and the hackle for grazing. A gut loop that has gone brittle can be stabilized but never really restored. Individual antique salmon flies in sound condition commonly bring $20 to $100, with framed sets by known tyers going far higher.

Orvis Rod Tubes and Split Cane Sections

An aluminum rod tube with an Orvis label often means a bamboo rod is somewhere nearby, and the tube itself is worth keeping even when empty. Orvis of Manchester, Vermont built impregnated bamboo rods with a resin-saturated cane that resists moisture better than varnished rods of the same era.

Loose split cane sections in a tackle box are usually orphans, but check the butt section above the grip for a maker stamp and a model and length designation. Straight, unset sections with tight wraps are worth having.

Complete cased bamboo rods by known makers run from a few hundred dollars into the thousands depending on condition.

Silk Lines and Catgut Leaders

Braided silk fly lines and gut leaders turn up in old boxes as stiff coils in paper envelopes, and they are almost never usable again. Their value is documentary, because the printed wrappers carry maker names, weights, and taper codes from an era before modern line ratings, and collectors of early fly tackle want them.

Gut leaders were drawn from silkworm gut, soaked before use, and they crack once dry. Unopened envelopes with intact printing are the ones worth pulling.

These typically sell for $10 to $40 per envelope in clean condition, more for early English makers with strong graphics.

Cork and Cedar Floats

Hand-shaped floats made from cork, cedar, and quill predate injection-molded plastic and are the quiet sleeper category in old boxes. Early commercial floats carry painted rings in specific color sequences, and some are stamped with a maker name on the stem.

English float makers produced elegant tapered forms with cane stems and peacock quill bodies that have a following among traditional anglers. Paint loss and shrinkage cracks are the usual damage.

Common wooden floats are worth a dollar or two each, but marked English quill floats in clean paint can bring $15 to $60 apiece.

Lead Sinker Molds

Cast-iron sinker molds with hinged handles settle to the bottom of boxes where their weight has pushed them, and they are collectible as tools in their own right. Period molds carry the maker name and a cavity size cast into the body, and older ones show hand-filed sprue cuts rather than machined ones.

Rust staining and pitted cavities are common, but the mold still functions if the faces close flat. Many anglers still pour their own sinkers, which supports demand beyond collectors.

Marked vintage molds in working condition typically sell for $25 to $80, with unusual shapes and early makers above that.

Hand-Carved Ice Spearing Decoys

Fish decoys carved for ice spearing, weighted with lead and fitted with metal fins, are folk art that happens to be tackle, and they are the item most likely to be badly underpriced. Great Lakes carvers produced them from the late nineteenth century onward, and Oscar Peterson of Cadillac, Michigan is among the names that move the market hardest.

Look for a carved wooden body with tin or copper fins set into saw cuts, original paint with age crazing, and a lead belly weight. Copies are abundant and often artificially aged.

Anonymous decoys in honest old paint bring $50 to $250, while documented Peterson carvings reach thousands.

Fillet Knives with Marbles and Case Stamps

A rusted knife in a leather sheath is usually a five dollar item, but the tang stamp decides that. Marble Arms of Gladstone, Michigan and W. R. Case and Sons of Bradford, Pennsylvania both marked their blades, and Case used a dot system on the tang through the 1970s that narrows a knife to a single year.

Older Marble patterns have stacked leather washer grips and a distinctive aluminum pommel. Blade pitting and a shrunken sheath are common. Sound marked fillet and hunting knives generally run $40 to $200, with early Marble patterns and scarce Case stamps going well above that.

Licenses, Pin Badges, and Marked Leader Wallets

Paper and cloth items pinned inside a lid are often the most datable things in the entire box. State fish and game commissions issued metal pin badges and button licenses for decades, each year in a different color and number series, and collectors assemble runs by state and year.

Leather leader wallets stamped with a maker name, frequently a tackle shop or a rod builder, held soaked gut leaders between damp felt pages. Both survive poorly, which is what makes clean examples desirable.

Early pin licenses in readable condition commonly bring $15 to $75, with scarce states and early years considerably higher.

UMCO Aluminum Boxes

UMCO of Minnesota built the aluminum tackle box that serious anglers carried, with riveted corners, cantilever trays, and a model number such as 1000A stamped or labeled on the lid. The trays are the fragile part, since thin aluminum bends and rivets loosen, and a box missing trays loses most of its value.

Later possum-belly models with a deep front compartment are the ones people actively hunt. Oxidation cleans off with care, but deep pitting does not. Complete UMCO boxes in sound condition with all trays commonly bring $60 to $200, with the larger possum-belly models at the top.

Kennedy Steel and the Painted Metal Era

Kennedy Manufacturing of Van Wert, Ohio applied its tool-chest engineering to tackle boxes, producing heavy steel cases with sliding cantilever trays and baked enamel finishes. Falls City, My Buddy, and Old Pal of Lititz, Pennsylvania competed in the same painted-steel market for decades, and their decals are usually the first thing to go.

Plano then moved the industry to molded plastic and effectively ended the era. Rust staining around the hinge and a seized latch are the usual problems. Clean steel boxes with legible decals sell for $30 to $90, while rough ones are worth more as props than as tackle.

Oak and Wicker Creels

Before plastic coolers, fish rode home in a woven willow or split-oak creel with a leather harness and a slotted lid. Good ones have brass or leather hardware, a maker label under the lid, and a shaped body meant to sit flat against the hip.

English and American makers both produced them, and examples with contrasting weave patterns are the most sought after. Dryness cracks the willow, so flexibility in the weave matters more than appearance.

Plain creels in sound condition run $40 to $120, while labeled examples with intact leather and original harness reach $200 to $500.

What the Bottom Tray Keeps

Most tackle boxes are exactly what they look like: forty years of rusted trebles, split shot, and a plastic worm that has melted into the tray. The odds of finding a glass-eyed plug in a scarce color with its box are poor, and anyone who says otherwise is probably selling something.

What these boxes reliably hold is a record of how one person fished, which is interesting even when it is not valuable.

The discipline is simple enough. Empty every tray, turn each lure over, read the stamps on reel feet and knife tangs, and resist the urge to clean anything before you know what it is.

Polish and repaint have destroyed more value in old tackle than rust ever managed.

More from Home As We Make It

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.