30 Holiday Items Resellers Buy in the Off Season

The savviest holiday resellers do their buying in July, when a box of vintage ornaments costs a dollar at a yard sale and nobody else is thinking about December. Prices for the same items climb sharply once the season arrives, so the off-season is when inventory gets built for a fraction of what it will later bring.

The strategy works because holiday decor is emotional and seasonal, two things that make demand spike on a calendar. Condition and completeness matter as much here as anywhere, since original boxes, working lights, and unfaded color separate a quick winter sale from a piece that sits.

These are the items worth stashing while the sun is out.

Boxed Shiny Brite ornaments

The American-made Shiny Brite glass ornaments, especially those still nested in their original printed cartons, are a reseller staple that reliably climbs in value each December. The mica-frosted and stenciled designs in complete boxed sets bring the most.

Original boxes with intact dividers can be worth nearly as much as the ornaments inside.

German blown-glass figural ornaments

Hand-blown figural ornaments from Lauscha and other German glassworks, shaped as birds, fruit, and characters, are prized well above generic round baubles. The detail of the mold and the survival of the original paint and silvering drive value.

Chips at the neck and flaking paint are the flaws that lower a piece.

Antique German kugels

The heavy, thick-walled glass ornaments called kugels, made in Germany in the nineteenth century, are the aristocrats of the ornament world and can sell for hundreds. Their weight, deep color, and ornate brass caps distinguish them from later thin-glass baubles.

Grape-cluster and unusual-color examples command the strongest prices.

Aluminum Christmas trees

The shimmering aluminum trees of the space age, particularly the Evergleam brand, have gone from garage-sale castoffs to sought centerpieces. Complete trees with all their branches in the original sleeves and box sell best.

Bent or missing branches and a battered box are what cut value.

Rotating color wheels

The motorized color wheels that bathed aluminum trees in shifting light are collected alongside the trees and often sell separately. A working motor and unfaded color gels are the desirable traits.

A tree paired with its original color wheel commands a premium over either piece alone.

NOMA bubble lights

The bubbling liquid-filled Christmas lights introduced by NOMA are nostalgic favorites that resellers snap up cheap in summer. Working sets in the original box, with the liquid still bubbling when warm, bring the most.

Cloudy or empty tubes and dead sockets are the common failures.

Bottle-brush trees

The small dyed bristle trees used in holiday village displays, especially those with mica-flocked tips or unusual colors, are collected by the dozen. Vintage examples with original bases and vivid color sell well.

Faded bristles and crushed shapes are the conditions buyers avoid.

Cardboard glitter “Putz” houses

The little cardboard and cellophane houses that sat beneath the tree, often called Putz houses, are collected for their glittered charm and tiny details. Examples with intact cellophane windows and bottle-brush trees still attached bring more.

Crushing, water damage, and lost trim are the usual flaws.

Ceramic lighted Christmas trees

The molded ceramic trees studded with colored plastic bulbs, made from popular hobby molds, have surged in demand among younger buyers. Complete trees with all their plastic pegs and a working base light sell best.

Missing pegs and cracks in the ceramic are the value killers.

Blow-mold lighted figures

The large molded-plastic Santas, snowmen, and carolers that lit up mid-century lawns, especially Empire pieces, are collected for indoor and outdoor display. Bright, un-yellowed plastic and a working light socket are the desirable traits.

Faded color and sun-brittle plastic are the common problems.

Knee-hugger pixie elves

The felt and vinyl elves designed to perch on shelves and hug their knees are a quintessential 1960s decoration with a strong following. Examples with intact felt, wire, and original tags bring the most.

Moth damage, faded felt, and missing pointed shoes are the flaws to note.

Boxed vintage light sets

Early figural and character light sets, including painted Japanese milk-glass bulbs, are collected both for use and display. Complete boxed sets with working bulbs and original packaging sell best.

Cracked bulbs and frayed cords lower the value considerably.

Gurley holiday candles

The wax figural candles made by Gurley, produced for Christmas, Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Easter, are collected across every holiday. Because they were rarely burned, many survive in near-perfect shape, and boxed examples bring more.

Fading and melting distortion are the conditions buyers weigh.

Bisque snow babies

The small bisque figurines dusted with snow-like flakes, called snow babies, are Victorian-era collectibles that still sell strongly in winter. Genuine early German examples outvalue later reproductions.

Chips to the delicate bisque and worn snow texture are the flaws that matter.

Belsnickle Santa figures

The stern early Santa figures known as Belsnickles, made of plaster or composition and often coated in mica, are among the most valuable holiday antiques. Unusual colors beyond the common red and a well-preserved surface command the most.

Later reproductions exist, so authenticity is key to the value.

German figural candy containers

The papier-mâché and composition holiday figures that opened to hold candy, from Santas to Easter rabbits, are prized by collectors of every season. Intact examples that still separate at the seam and retain their paint bring the most.

Missing bases and repainting reduce value sharply.

German feather trees

The early artificial trees made from dyed goose feathers wound onto wire branches are collected as the ancestors of the modern tree. Original examples with a decorative base and intact feather tips sell strongly.

Bare branches and a damaged base are the common condition issues.

Vintage tinsel and lametta garland

The heavy metallic tinsel and lametta icicles of the mid-century, draped thick over branches, are collected for authentic period display. Unopened packages and the heavier older material bring more than modern plastic.

Tarnished or tangled strands are less desirable.

Spun-glass angel hair and toppers

The fine spun-glass angel hair and the spun-glass and foil tree toppers of the era give a period tree its authentic glow. Boxed angel hair and toppers with intact spun-glass halos sell best.

Crushing and yellowing are the flaws that reduce these fragile pieces.

German wooden Christmas pyramids

The carved wooden carousels driven by the heat of candles, called Christmas pyramids, are prized folk-art decorations. Multi-tier examples with all their carved figures and intact propellers bring the most.

Missing figures and a warped frame are the usual defects.

German incense smoker figures

The carved wooden figures that release a thread of scented incense from inside, a traditional German craft, are collected as seasonal folk art. Detailed hand-carved examples in good paint sell best.

Cracks in the wood and heavy soot staining are the conditions to check.
Steinbach nutcrackers

Steinbach nutcrackers

The German hand-carved nutcrackers from makers like Steinbach are collected year-round but sell hardest in winter. Retired designs, original boxes, and maker’s tags drive value.

Cracks, missing levers, and repainting are the flaws that lower a figure.

Annalee felt dolls

The posable felt holiday dolls made by Annalee, with their hand-painted faces and wired limbs, have a devoted collecting base. Early dated examples and complete character sets bring the most.

Faded felt, moth damage, and missing accessories are the usual issues.

Vintage Halloween die-cuts

The embossed cardboard die-cut decorations, especially those made by Beistle with their jointed limbs, are among the most valuable Halloween collectibles. Bright, unfaded printing and intact fasteners are the desirable traits.

Because paper is fragile, condition dramatically affects price.

German pulp jack-o’-lantern lanterns

The molded pressed-pulp lanterns shaped as glowing faces, made in Germany and Japan, are top-tier Halloween finds. Examples with the original paper face insert and unfaded paint bring the most.

Fading, dents, and a missing insert are the flaws buyers weigh.

Tin-litho Halloween noisemakers

The lithographed tin noisemakers, from ratchets to bells decorated with cats and witches, are collected for their graphics and their rattle. Bright, unrusted printing and a working mechanism are what buyers want.

Rust and faded artwork are the common condition problems.

Boxed vintage costumes

The boxed children’s costumes from makers like Ben Cooper and Collegeville, with their character masks and printed smocks, are nostalgic Halloween collectibles. Complete costumes in the original illustrated box sell far above loose examples.

Torn masks and missing boxes lower the value.

Vintage mechanical Valentine cards

The stand-up and mechanical Valentine cards with moving parts, produced by the millions in the early twentieth century, are collected for their charm and graphics. Large mechanical examples and honeycomb-tissue designs bring the most.

Torn tabs and missing easels are the flaws to check.

Christopher Radko ornaments

The elaborate blown-glass ornaments designed by Christopher Radko, especially early and retired designs, have a strong secondary market. Ornaments with their original tags and boxes sell best.

Because reproductions and later pieces vary, the specific design and its retirement status drive value.

Lighted village houses

Ceramic lighted village buildings, including Department 56 and similar lines, are collected as growing display sets. Retired pieces in the original box with all their inserts and cords bring the most.

Chips, cloudy finish, and missing accessories are what buyers screen for.

Why July Is the Best Month to Buy December

The logic behind off-season buying is simple arithmetic dressed up as patience. Holiday goods flood estate sales and thrift stores all year, but demand concentrates into a few short weeks, and the person holding clean, complete inventory when that window opens sets the price.

The deeper truth is that these objects carry memory, and memory is what buyers pay a premium for once the lights go up. A boxed set of ornaments bought for pocket change in the summer heat becomes, in December, exactly the piece of someone’s childhood they are trying to buy back.

More from Home As We Make It

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.