30 Costume Jewelry Boxes Worth Sorting Through

A tangled box of costume jewelry gets treated as a single lot at almost every estate sale, priced at ten or fifteen dollars because none of it is gold. Dealers buy those boxes on sight and sort them at home, which tells you most of what you need to know.

The value sits in signatures stamped on the reverse, in stones cut in ways nobody bothers with anymore, and in materials that were cheap in 1940 and are effectively unobtainable now.

Trifari Crown-Marked Pieces

Trifari’s crown mark over the T identifies pieces made under designer Alfred Philippe, whose training in fine jewelry shows in the stone settings. The Crown Trifari era pieces use invisible settings and pavé work that rivals genuine jewelry construction.

Missing stones are repairable, but replating a worn gold finish is expensive enough to change the math.

Coro Duettes

Coro patented a mechanism allowing two clips to lock into a single brooch and separate again, and the Duette pieces are marked on the frame rather than the clips. Enameled floral and figural versions bring the strongest prices.

The mechanism must operate smoothly, since a sprung clip is difficult to repair.

Weiss Rhinestone Brooches

Weiss used Austrian crystal of unusually good quality and is best known for pieces in smoky black diamond and deep amber tones. The insect and flower figurals are the recognizable signature.

Buyers check every stone under angled light, since replacements never quite match the original foiling.

Eisenberg Original Pieces

Eisenberg began as a clothing manufacturer whose decorative pins were stolen off the garments so frequently that the company sold them separately. Early pieces marked “Eisenberg Original” use large, heavy Swarovski stones in sterling settings.

The weight alone distinguishes them from later production.

Miriam Haskell Beaded Work

Haskell’s pieces are hand-wired onto filigree backplates using glass beads, seed pearls, and Russian gold-plated findings, meaning every piece involved substantial hand labor. Unsigned early examples exist and are identified by construction rather than mark.

Loose wiring and missing beads are common and reduce value sharply.

Juliana Five-Link Bracelets

Pieces made by DeLizza and Elster are never signed, and collectors identify them by a five-link bracelet construction and distinctive oval-and-round stone arrangements on the reverse. Watermelon and heliotrope art glass stones are the ones people chase.

Attribution disputes are constant, which keeps prices volatile.

Schiaparelli Signed Pieces

The pieces sold under the Schiaparelli name in the 1950s use dramatically colored art glass stones with iridescent finishes that catch light unlike anything else in the box. Full sets of necklace, bracelet, and earrings command serious money.

The signature is usually on a small applied plaque that can detach.

Hobé Filigree

Hobé built pieces with hand-set stones on intricately worked filigree frames, often in sterling with a gold wash, and marked them with a triangle logo. The earlier pieces are considerably better made than the later ones.

Buyers examine the filigree for crushed sections, which cannot be straightened without damage.

Marcel Boucher Figurals

Boucher trained at Cartier before founding his own house, and the bird and flower figurals show that background in their modeling and enamel work. Numbered pieces from the 1940s are catalogued by collectors.

Enamel loss is the flaw that most affects value.

Kramer of New York

Kramer produced heavily jeweled pieces including a line made for Christian Dior, marked accordingly, and those crossover pieces are the ones worth pulling out of a box. Rhinestone-encrusted flower sprays are the house signature.

The plating on Kramer pieces wears in predictable spots on the reverse.

Sarah Coventry

Sold exclusively through home parties from the 1950s onward, Coventry pieces were produced in enormous numbers and are usually worth little individually. The exception is the earlier designer-made work and certain retired designs that completists pursue.

Original hangtags and boxes make an ordinary piece worth listing separately.

Monet Gold-Tone Chains

Monet built a reputation on smooth, well-finished chain work and clean modern shapes rather than stones, and the pieces have aged into steady demand from people who wear rather than collect. The plating quality is noticeably better than contemporary equivalents.

Kinked links are the usual reason a chain gets passed over.

Napier Charm Bracelets

Napier produced substantial charm bracelets with heavy links and figural charms, and a fully loaded bracelet is worth considerably more than the sum of its parts. Charms with moving elements attract the most interest.

Buyers verify that the safety chain and clasp function properly.

Lisner Leaf Brooches

Lisner’s molded thermoset plastic pieces in leaf and flower shapes, particularly in blue and amber tones, are instantly recognizable and reliably in demand. Full sets with matching earrings do best.

The plastic elements crack invisibly, so examination under bright light matters.

Vendôme Crystal Necklaces

Vendôme was Coro’s upmarket line, and the beaded crystal necklaces use hand-strung Austrian glass in multiple strands. Complete sets in original boxes surface occasionally and sell strongly.

Stretched or discolored stringing is repairable by a specialist and is not a reason to walk away.

Regency Jewels Art Glass

Regency used unusual molded glass stones in colors that shift depending on the light, producing pieces that photograph poorly and sell in person. The company operated for a relatively short period, which limits supply.

Signed examples are less common than attributed ones.

Kenneth Jay Lane Pieces

Lane’s designs were worn by prominent women through several decades and were sold at high prices when new, giving them a resale market well above typical costume jewelry. Early signed pieces marked with the full name outperform later abbreviations.

Enamel and resin components determine condition grading.

Joseff of Hollywood

Joseff supplied jewelry to film studios and sold retail versions in a distinctive antiqued Russian gold finish designed not to reflect studio lighting. Documented screen-used pieces reach entirely different price levels than retail copies.

The matte finish should never be polished.

Bakelite Bangles

Carved and laminated Bakelite bracelets from the 1930s and 1940s command prices that astonish people who find them in a drawer, with deeply carved and multi-color laminated examples at the top. Simple identification tests exist, and buyers use them before paying.

Hairline cracks are difficult to see and severely affect value.

Jelly Belly Brooches

These figural pins set a large clear Lucite cabochon into a metal body to form an animal’s midsection, and Trifari’s versions in sterling are the benchmark. The Lucite yellows with age and exposure.

Clean, colorless examples with original stones bring multiples of clouded ones.

Aurora Borealis Crystal Sets

The iridescent coating developed in the 1950s appears on necklaces, bracelets, and earrings sold as matched sets, most of which were separated long ago. Reuniting a set raises the value beyond the individual pieces.

The coating wears off with skin contact, so worn areas are visible immediately.

Czech Glass Filigree Brooches

Pieces made in Bohemia before the war combine pressed glass stones with stamped brass filigree in a style nobody has successfully reproduced. Many are unsigned, and attribution rests on construction details.

Original patina on the brass should be preserved rather than polished.

Rhinestone Parures in Original Boxes

A full parure includes necklace, bracelet, earrings, and often a brooch, presented in a fitted box from the maker. Complete boxed sets are genuinely uncommon because pieces were worn separately and lost.

The box, when present, can represent a third of the value.

Screw-Back and Clip Earrings

Earrings made before pierced ears returned to fashion sit unsold in boxes everywhere, and buyers who wear them are willing to pay for interesting designs. Converting them to posts destroys collector value.

The screw mechanism should turn freely without stripping.

Cameo Brooches in Shell and Lava

Carved shell cameos and the rarer carved lava versions from Italian workshops range from mass-produced to genuinely fine, and the difference is visible in the depth and detail of the carving. Lava cameos in muted grays and browns are considerably scarcer.

Cracks running through the carved face are common and permanent.

Mourning Jewelry With Woven Hair

Victorian pieces incorporating braided hair under glass, often with jet or black enamel, were made in enormous quantities and are now collected as social history. Pieces with legible inscriptions and dates on the reverse bring the most.

The glass compartment must be sealed or the contents deteriorate.

Sweater Guards and Chain Clips

Paired clips joined by a decorative chain held a cardigan across the shoulders and disappeared entirely from fashion by the 1970s. Figural and rhinestone versions sell well to vintage clothing buyers.

Both clips must grip properly for the piece to be usable.

Enameled Flower Pins

Hand-enameled flower brooches from the 1940s in poured and painted enamel appear in nearly every box and vary wildly in quality. Signed examples from recognized houses separate quickly from anonymous production.

Chipped enamel is essentially unrepairable at reasonable cost.

Mexican Silver From Taxco

Sterling pieces made in Taxco carry maker’s marks and often incorporate amethyst, turquoise, or abalone in bold modernist designs. Pieces by documented workshops are collected seriously and priced accordingly.

Eagle assay marks help date pieces to specific periods.

Hat Pins and Holders

Long decorative pins that secured wide hats went obsolete with the hats and now sell to collectors who display them in porcelain holders. Elaborate heads with stones, enamel, or figural work carry the value.

The point should be intact and the shaft straight.

What Sits at the Bottom of the Box

The reason these boxes stay worth sorting is that costume jewelry was designed to be disposable and then made too well to throw away. It was cheap fashion built with hand-set stones and hand-wired backplates, produced by people who had trained on the real thing during years when the real thing was not selling.

Every box that comes out of an estate has been picked over by someone who did not look at the reverse of anything. That is the entire opportunity, and it repeats at nearly every sale.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.