30 Brooches and Pins Dealers Sort Out of Jewelry Lots

A bag arrives from an estate cleanout, tangled and gray with dust, and gets tipped onto a felt tray. Most of what lands there is broken chain and bent clasps.

Within a few seconds a hand moves across the pile and lifts three or four pins out of it, apparently without looking. That speed is not instinct. It is a short list of marks, mechanisms and materials learned by repetition.

Brooches reward the attention more than almost anything else in a mixed lot, because the evidence sits on the back where it can be read in a moment. A catch shape, a stamped number, a twist of wire, the way a stone sits in its seat: each one narrows the date and the maker before the front of the piece matters at all.

The Crown Mark That Ends the Sorting Argument

A small crown resting over the Trifari name is the fastest read on the tray. The house used that mark through the postwar decades, and pieces carrying it have prong-set stones, heavy plating and hinged pin stems that still swing smoothly.

The design era associated with Alfred Philippe produced the sculptural flower sprays and figural birds that collectors chase. Signed crown pieces in clean condition commonly move in the $40 to $150 range.

A single absent stone, or a replacement in the wrong tone, pulls a piece down farther than the mark lifts it.

Clear Lucite Figurals With a Set Center

Mid-century figurals built around a domed clear Lucite body are worth slowing down for. The Lucite was cut, polished and prong-set into a sterling or gold-washed frame shaped as a fish, a poodle, a rooster or a spider.

Collectors call the type jelly belly, and Trifari examples carry the crown mark on the reverse. Later copies glue an acrylic blank into place, which shows as a flat contact ring and a haze of adhesive at the rim.

Sterling originals reach into the hundreds, though a chipped or clouded center resets that figure immediately.

Two Clips Wearing a Single Coro Frame

A Duette looks like one wide brooch until the sprung carrier releases and two separate dress clips come free in the hand. Coro built the mechanism through the 1930s and 1940s, and the carrier bar usually carries the patent wording while the clips themselves take the signature.

Sorters confirm that both clips are present, because a frame missing one is a fraction of what the matched pair brings. Complete examples with intact enamel sell across a wide range.

A sprung carrier and gaps where stones once sat are the two conditions that settle the number.

The Eisenberg Script and the Crystal Beside It

Eisenberg began as a dress house, and its earliest pins were fixed to garments rather than sold on their own. Those pieces use heavy hand-set crystal in pot metal or sterling and feel dense for their size.

Marks run from a block letter E to Eisenberg Original in script to the later plain Eisenberg Ice. Dealers find the script first, then tilt the piece to the light to see whether the stones hold their original foil backing.

Replaced crystal reads brighter and flatter than its neighbors and costs more value than any other flaw.

Weiss and the Dark Metal Behind Bright Stones

Weiss worked in hand-set rhinestones, frequently on japanned metal, a blackened base finish that makes colored stones read hotter than a bright setting would. The signature sits in a small oval cartouche, and the plating around it should match the rest of the back.

Insect figurals and colored navette clusters are the pieces pulled first. Japanned surfaces chip, and exposed base metal shows as a pale speck against the black.

Common florals sit in the modest tens; an absent stone in an unusual color is the hardest thing to source and the costliest to ignore.

Settings Turned Upside Down at Schreiner

Schreiner set many of its stones with the points facing outward, so the underside of the setting becomes the face of the piece. The effect is spiky and deliberate and carries across a tray from several feet away.

Backs tend to be plain, with a hook-style catch and, when it survives, a plate reading Schreiner New York. Unsigned examples are common because those plates detached.

Strong pieces reach the high hundreds in clean condition, but a lost stone in a keystone or ruffle setting is close to unfixable and takes most of that with it.

Seed Pearls Wired to a Filigree Plate

Miriam Haskell pieces are assembled by hand, with seed pearls and glass beads wired individually onto a pierced filigree backplate rather than dropped into glue cups. Turning one over shows the wire ends twisted and tucked flat, which is a better test than the mark itself.

The earliest work is unsigned; the oval tag came later. Warm cream baroque faux pearls in dense clusters are the house look.

Flaking pearl coating and slack wires are the faults to check, and a section of absent beads costs more than the signature returns.

Numbered Backs on Marcel Boucher Figurals

Boucher stamped a design number near the signature on much of its output, which gives a rare fixed reference point in a pile of anonymous metal. Early pieces carry a bird device beside the name, later ones the name alone or the initials MB.

The figural birds and enameled flowers are cast with genuine depth, and the enamel fills cut recesses instead of lying flat on a stamped surface. Numbered examples with sound enamel run from the tens into the low hundreds.

Chipped enamel decides the price far more than the number does.

Hobe Wirework That Reads as Fine Jewelry

Hobe built layered floral sprays from twisted wire, setting small stones into individual cups and then assembling those units into tiers. The construction is slow and fussy, and it shows: a Hobe spray has depth that a stamped pin cannot imitate.

Marks vary, including a triangle device with the name inside it. Sterling vermeil examples from the 1940s are the ones separated out immediately.

Values run from modest to several hundred depending on size and metal, while loose tiers and empty cups where stones once sat set the practical ceiling.

Five Metal Links Under a Rhinestone Cluster

Juliana is a collector nickname rather than a maker mark, attached to unsigned pieces identified purely by construction. The tell is five small oval links soldered across the back plate, tying the layers together.

Large open-backed rivoli and navette stones, japanned or gold-tone metal and heavy dimensional layering complete the profile. The paper hang tags that once identified these pieces are almost always gone.

Confirmed five-link brooches sell well into the low hundreds when complete, and because the stones are large and specific, one absent stone separates a strong piece from an ordinary one.

Stanley Hagler’s Wired Gilt Filigree

Hagler worked in the hand-wired tradition but pushed the color much further, fixing glass beads, coral-toned branches and seed pearls onto a soft gold-tone filigree described as Russian gold plate. That finish resists tarnish and stays warm rather than turning brassy.

Marks appear on an oval plate, with a first name added alongside the surname after the business changed hands. The backs show the same twisted wire ends found in Haskell work.

Loose beads and snapped wires are common and cut value sharply, since rebuilding a section by hand is slow and rarely invisible.

Mazer and Jomaz Stones That Behave Like the Real Thing

Mazer Brothers and the later Jomaz line used high-grade glass in rhodium-finished settings built to fine jewelry proportions rather than costume scale. Stones are prong-set and cleanly cut, and the metal holds a cool white color instead of the yellow cast of cheap plate.

Marks read MAZER, MAZER BROS or JOMAZ, usually small and placed on a flat area of the back. Faux emerald and sapphire cabochons in pave frames are the recognizable pieces.

Clean examples sit in the low to mid hundreds, with a mismatched replacement stone the standard reason for a discount.

Dress Clips That Should Never Be Sold Alone

An Art Deco dress clip has a flat back and a hinged, sprung jaw that grips a fabric edge, and the pieces were sold in matched pairs meant for the corners of a neckline. Loose in a lot they look like broken brooches, which is why so many pairs are separated.

Chrome, pot metal and sterling versions exist, with baguette and step-cut glass in hard geometry. A matched pair brings considerably more than twice a single.

Pot metal fatigue shows as fine surface crazing and swelling, and once it begins the piece cannot be saved.

Two Prongs and a Spring: the Fur Clip

A fur clip has two sharp prongs on a hinged, spring-loaded back, built to grip heavy cloth and pelts rather than a thin blouse. The fitting appears through the 1930s and 1940s, often on the same design a house also sold as a conventional brooch.

Spring tension and prong tips are checked first, since shortened or bent prongs indicate an old repair. Trifari, Coro and Boucher all produced them. Value tracks the design rather than the fitting, but a clip with one prong snapped away loses most of the premium the mechanism earns.

Victorian Bar Pins and the Catch That Dates Them

A long horizontal bar pin, worn at the collar, is the most common Victorian survivor in a mixed lot. Gold-filled examples carry a line of seed pearls or a single stone at the center, and the pin stem usually extends past the frame, a habit of the period. The catch supplies the date: a simple C-shaped hook with no closing arm points to the 19th century.

Gold-filled bar pins sell in the tens, while a low-karat gold example with intact stones reaches much higher, less any deduction for a sprung catch or a replaced stem.

Woven Hair Under a Glass Panel

Memorial brooches with plaited hair set behind glass were ordinary Victorian mourning goods rather than curiosities. The hair is worked into a flat braid, a basket weave or a coiled feather pattern, laid against a paper or ivory-toned backing and framed in gold-filled metal or pinchbeck.

Condensation beneath the glass and a lifted bezel are the usual faults. Many examples carry an inscription on the reverse with initials and a date.

An intact panel with legible lettering holds real value; a cracked crystal or a shifted braid removes most of it.

Jet, Vulcanite and the Difference a Rub Reveals

Deep black mourning brooches come in several materials that look identical lying in a tray. Whitby jet is fossilized wood, light in the hand and warm to the touch, and it takes a soft luster rather than a glassy shine.

Vulcanite is hardened rubber; sunlight turns its surface a dull brown, and a briskly rubbed spot gives off a faint rubber odor. French jet is black glass and feels cold and heavy.

Jet carries the strongest prices of the three, and a chipped carved edge is the usual reason a good piece grades down.

Shell Cameos and the Test at the Rim

A carved shell cameo shows a faintly translucent field when held against a light, with the image cut through layers of natural color rather than printed on. Molded resin copies have a uniform back, soft detail in the hair and a seam around the rim.

The best 19th century carving stands in high relief with undercut curls and a crisp profile. Mounts in gold-filled or low-karat gold are common.

Condition rests on the fragile edge of the shell, and a chip or a re-glued panel separates a strong cameo from a cheap one.

Lava and Coral Cameos From the Grand Tour Trade

Cameos carved from volcanic lava came home from Italy as Grand Tour souvenirs, with a color range running from oatmeal and putty through gray-green to deep brown. The carving is chunkier than shell work and the surface reads porous rather than glossy.

Coral cameos are denser, cut from branch stock in a warm orange-pink and often set in plain beaded frames. Both types are usually unsigned and frequently turn up unmounted in old lots.

Chips at the high points of the carving, particularly the nose and the hair, decide the price.

Scottish Pebble Brooches in Silver

Scottish agate brooches inlay banded and moss agates, bloodstone and carnelian into silver frames cut as circles, crosses, anchors and belt-and-buckle motifs. The stones sit flush with the metal so the surface reads as one continuous plane.

Victorian examples were made in quantity for the plaid trade and most are unmarked, though later revival pieces carry assay marks. Dealers count the stones before anything else, because an empty cell is the first thing a buyer sees.

Complete brooches reach the low to mid hundreds; an absent or mismatched agate is the main value variable.

Guilloche Enamel Over Engine-Turned Scandinavian Silver

Norwegian and Danish silver enamel pins carry translucent color laid over a machine-engraved ground, so light passes through the enamel and picks up the pattern beneath it. The palette runs to pale blue, white, soft green and a distinctive deep turquoise.

Backs are marked 925S, sterling, or NORWAY, usually in small crisp letters near the catch. Butterfly and leaf forms are the common survivors.

Enamel chips are the fault to hunt for, since they cannot be filled invisibly, and clean examples sit in the tens to low hundreds depending on size and maker.

Taxco Silver With a Deep, Heavy Feel

Mexican silver brooches from the Taxco workshops are cast or hand-wrought rather than stamped, and they carry a weight that machine-made costume metal never reaches. Older pieces show an eagle assay stamp with a number, later ones a registry mark with a letter prefix alongside 925 or 980.

Designs lean on repousse work, inlaid turquoise or obsidian, and broad abstract forms. A worn mark deserves a look under a loupe before the piece goes into the common tray. Silver weight sets a floor under the value, and absent inlay is the main deduction.

Bakelite Figurals and the Hot Water Check

Carved Bakelite pins turn up as fruit, dogs, birds and blunt geometric bars, usually with a pin back riveted or pressed into the material. The material carries no mold seam, feels warm and dense, and gives a dull click rather than a sharp tap when two pieces meet.

A brief run under hot water releases a faint chemical odor that later plastics do not produce. Deeply carved and laminated examples reach into the hundreds.

Surface crazing, a replaced pin back and glue repairs at a carved joint push a piece back toward the common tray.

Micromosaic Panels Built From Glass Threads

A micromosaic brooch is assembled from hundreds of tiny glass rods set into a dark ground, forming flowers, doves, ruins or a landscape reduced to a thumbnail. Under a loupe the individual tesserae are visible with faint grout lines between them, while a printed imitation shows a smooth surface and an even sheen.

Italian workshops supplied the tourist trade with these across the 19th century and into the 20th. Frames are gold-filled, silver or black glass. Absent tesserae leave a dark pit that cannot be matched, and that fault sets the price.

Marcasite Set in Sterling, Not Glued

Marcasite pins in sterling were produced heavily between the wars and again in the postwar decades, and the good ones seat each small pyrite stone in a cut recess with a burnished lip of metal closed around it. Cheaper later work glues the stones into shallow cups, which shows as a gap or grayish film at the stone edge.

Backs read sterling or 925, often with a continental origin stamp. Stones that have lost their facets read flat and dark. Empty seats where stones dropped away are the usual reason a piece prices low.

Rhinestone Christmas Tree Pins Sorted by Signature

Figural tree pins were produced from the 1950s onward by most American costume houses, which makes the reverse the only part that matters when a pile of them appears. Marks from Weiss, Eisenberg, Hollycraft and their peers turn a common holiday pin into a collected one.

The construction worth finding is prong-set colored stones in a dimensional casting rather than flat chatons dropped in glue. Unsigned examples move for a few dollars while signed and complete ones reach the tens and beyond.

A tree with two empty cells sells at the unsigned price.

Sweetheart Pins From the War Years

Sweetheart pins were made for the families of service members and carry branch insignia, a regimental crest or a rank device, often in sterling, gold-filled metal or mother-of-pearl with an enamel emblem. Wartime examples tend to be small, light and marked sterling on the back, since base metals were restricted for other uses.

Some carry a jeweler name or a short motto in enamel. Reproductions exist and usually show crisper, deeper enamel and a modern catch. Original pins with sound enamel sell in the tens, with chipped enamel accounting for most of the spread.

Hatpins and the Safes That Covered Their Points

A hatpin is not a brooch: the shaft runs eight to twelve inches and ends in a point, with the decoration fixed to the head. Heads appear in glass, enamel, sterling repousse and carved materials, and a good one keeps its original steel shaft free of rust pitting.

Point protectors, known as hatpin safes, screw or clamp onto the end and are collected in their own right. Shortened shafts are common and reduce value.

Sterling and figural glass heads run from the tens into the low hundreds, with the head driving the number.

The Catch on the Back Dates the Front

Before anything else the reverse gets turned up. A C-clasp, a plain hook with no closing arm, points to the 19th or very early 20th century. A trombone catch, where a sleeve pulls outward to release the stem, signals European manufacture from roughly the 1890s through the 1930s.

The roll-over safety catch still in use today came into general service from the 1920s onward. A tube hinge rolled from sheet indicates earlier work than a modern soldered joint, and a late catch on an old-looking piece usually means a repair or a reproduction.

Foil, Glue and the Evidence Under the Stone

Older glass stones were foil-backed and set into closed cups, so any moisture that reaches the foil leaves a dark gray patch that reads as a dead spot across the face. Prong-set stones indicate better work and an earlier date than chatons dropped into shallow glue seats.

Dried adhesive around the rim of a stone, cloudy and faintly yellow, marks either cheap original construction or a later repair. A stone sitting proud of its neighbors has been replaced.

All of those observations move value, and absent or replaced stones move it further than anything else.

The Evidence Is Always on the Back

The pins that come out of the pile first are rarely the prettiest ones. They are the ones whose backs answer a question quickly: a crown, a stamped number, five soldered links, a twist of wire, a catch with no closing arm.

Everything else goes into the common tray and gets priced by the handful, which is why sorting speed is worth more than taste in this corner of the trade.

What holds all of it together is that condition outranks the name almost every time. A signed piece with three empty settings competes with an unsigned one that still carries every stone, and the unsigned piece often wins.

Trays get sorted on that arithmetic, and the tangled bag from the estate cleanout is worth exactly what survived inside it.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.