29 Family Meals That Stretch Into a Second Dinner

Cooking twice as much is easy. Cooking once so that the second dinner is a different meal rather than the same plate reheated is the skill that keeps a family from revolting on Wednesday.

The trick is almost always the same: cook the expensive component in a form that has not yet been committed to a flavor, then send it somewhere else the second night. Here are the pairings that work.

Roast Chicken

A bird roasted with nothing but salt, pepper, and a lemon comes out of the oven uncommitted, which is the point. Sunday it is roast chicken with potatoes; Tuesday the picked meat goes into enchiladas with a can of green sauce and a bag of shredded cheese.

Season the skin aggressively but leave the meat itself plain. Two chickens roasted at once take no more effort than one and guarantee the second meal.

Pot Roast

A chuck roast braised until it collapses gives up more meat than most families finish, and the leftovers hold their texture better than almost any other cut. The second dinner is hash: chopped beef browned hard in a skillet with diced potato and onion, topped with a fried egg.

Save the braising liquid separately, because it becomes the gravy that makes the hash work. Reheating the roast in one piece and slicing it again produces dry meat, so chop it cold.

Baked Ham

A bone-in ham feeds a crowd and then keeps producing for a week, which is why it survived as a holiday centerpiece long after the holiday reasoning faded. The second meal is ham and white bean soup built on the bone, which carries more flavor than the meat does.

Simmer the bone for two hours with an onion and a bay leaf before adding beans. Diced ham also disappears into fried rice and into a breakfast casserole without complaint.

Roast Turkey

Nobody roasts a turkey for one meal, and the second dinner most families default to is a sandwich, which wastes the opportunity. Tetrazzini is the better answer: pulled turkey folded into a cream sauce with mushrooms and pasta, baked under crumbs.

It absorbs a large quantity of meat and reads as an entirely different dinner. The carcass makes the stock that becomes soup on the third night.

Pork Shoulder

Slow-roasted pork shoulder is the most efficient protein a large family can buy, because a seven-pound piece costs little and yields enormous quantities of shreddable meat. Night one it goes on a platter with rice and beans; night two it hits a hot skillet until the edges crisp and becomes carnitas for tacos.

The crisping step is what makes the second meal better than the first. Freeze a third portion in its own fat.

Beef Brisket

A smoked or braised brisket sliced for dinner leaves the point end and the ragged edges, which are the best parts for what comes next. Chopped and mixed with sauce, they become sandwiches that most families prefer to the original plate.

Slice only what will be eaten, since sliced brisket dries out and unsliced brisket does not. The rendered fat saved from the pan makes exceptional roast potatoes.

Chili

Chili improves overnight, which makes it the rare dish where the second appearance is genuinely better. Rather than serving it twice, ladle the leftovers over cooked elbow macaroni with cheese melted through for chili mac, which stretches the remaining pot across a full second dinner.

It also goes over baked potatoes or under a cornbread topping. Make the batch larger than seems reasonable.

Taco Meat

Ground beef browned with cumin, chili powder, and onion is the most flexible thing in a family refrigerator. Tuesday it fills tortillas; Thursday it goes cold over shredded lettuce with beans, cheese, and crushed chips as a taco salad that nobody identifies as a repeat.

Keep the seasoning moderate so the second use has room to move. A pound and a half stretches to two dinners for six with beans added.

Meatloaf

The second life of meatloaf is so well established that some cooks bake it primarily for the sandwiches. Cold loaf slices thick and clean, then goes into a skillet with butter until the edges caramelize, and onto bread with mayonnaise and sharp mustard.

Bake it in two smaller loaves rather than one large one so the second is untouched. Crumbled leftover loaf also works stirred into pasta sauce.

Marinara Sauce

A large pot of plain tomato sauce is the foundation of two or three dinners and takes no longer to make than a small one. Monday it dresses spaghetti; Wednesday it layers with ricotta and pasta tubes into baked ziti that goes straight from oven to table.

Keep the sauce free of meat and heavy seasoning so it can travel. A quart in the freezer eliminates one takeout night a month.

Bolognese

A proper meat sauce simmered for hours is too much work for one meal, so cook double. The leftovers become the filling for stuffed peppers, bound with rice and baked under cheese, which turns a sauce into a plated dinner.

It also works spooned into a baked potato or layered into a small lasagna. Freeze in flat portions sized to the family rather than in one block.

Slow-Cooked Ribs

Ribs are a project, and a rack and a half costs barely more than a single rack. The second meal comes from pulling the remaining meat off the bones and folding it into baked beans, where it does more work than it would on the bone.

Rib meat also makes an excellent sandwich with slaw. Save the bones for a small pot of stock.

Rice

Cooking three times the rice needed is the oldest stretch in the book and still the most reliable. Refrigerated rice dries out slightly, which is exactly what fried rice requires, and freshly cooked rice never works for it.

The second dinner comes together in ten minutes with eggs, frozen peas, scallions, and whatever protein is around. Spread hot rice on a sheet pan to cool it fast before refrigerating.

Mashed Potatoes

Leftover mashed potatoes are the most commonly discarded good ingredient in an American kitchen. Mixed with an egg and a little flour, formed into cakes, and fried until crusted, they become the base of a second dinner alongside eggs or sausage.

They also top a shepherd’s pie built on leftover ground meat. Make more than needed on purpose rather than treating the surplus as an accident.

Baked Potatoes

Bake twice as many as the meal requires, because a cold baked potato is the perfect raw material and a raw potato is another hour. Split the extras, scoop the interiors, mix with cheese, sour cream, and scallion, refill the skins, and bake again for a second dinner that children treat as a treat.

Bacon or leftover ham goes in the same mixture. The skins crisp better on the second bake.

Pinto Beans

“The way I like my pintos” by Andy Melton, source: Flickr, licensed under Cc by -SA 2.0

A pot of beans simmered with an onion and a piece of pork feeds a family for pennies and then converts into something else entirely. Mashed in a hot skillet with a little of their liquid, they become refried beans for burritos and tostadas on a second night.

The bean broth is worth keeping and using in place of water for rice. Dried beans cost roughly a fifth of what canned ones do.

Lentils

A pot of brown lentils cooked with carrot, celery, and onion is dinner as soup on the first night and something firmer on the second. Drained and simmered with tomato sauce, mustard, and a little brown sugar, they fill sandwich buns in place of ground beef at a fraction of the cost.

Red lentils collapse and will not work for the second use. Cook the batch slightly under for this reason.

Corned Beef

Corned beef is bought once a year by most families and then handled badly. The braise itself is dinner with cabbage and potatoes; the leftovers become hash, which many households prefer outright.

Chop rather than slice, and get the skillet hotter than feels comfortable. The cooking liquid is too salty for stock and should be discarded.

Roast Pork Loin

A lean loin roast slices neatly for a plated dinner and then behaves well in a hot pan, which is unusual for a lean cut. The second dinner is a stir fry: sliced thin against the grain, tossed with garlic, ginger, and whatever vegetables need using, served over the rice already in the refrigerator.

Slice the leftovers cold for clean cuts. Do not reheat the roast in one piece.

Rotisserie Chicken

The supermarket rotisserie chicken is frequently cheaper than a raw bird, and it arrives already cooked, which makes it the fastest possible base for two meals. Night one it is dinner with sides; night two the remaining meat is chopped into chicken salad with celery, herbs, and a modest amount of mayonnaise.

Buy two when they are discounted late in the evening. The carcasses still make stock.

Grilled Chicken Thighs

Thighs cost less than breasts, tolerate reheating without turning to sawdust, and hold seasoning better. Grill twice what dinner requires and slice the extras cold for quesadillas the following night, which take eight minutes and require nothing else in the house but tortillas and cheese.

Boneless thighs make the second meal faster. Season with salt and a neutral spice rub so the meat stays flexible.

Steak

Steak rarely produces leftovers, which is precisely why cooking one extra is worth doing deliberately. Sliced thin and cold, it becomes steak and eggs at breakfast or the protein on a substantial salad with blue cheese and red onion.

Reheating steak ruins it, so the second use should always be cold or barely warmed. A flank or skirt steak stretches furthest per dollar.

Sausage and Peppers

A sheet pan of Italian sausage roasted with peppers and onions is a complete dinner that requires almost no attention. The leftovers, sliced into coins, go into a skillet with pasta and a splash of the pan juices for a second dinner that takes twelve minutes.

The peppers and onions come along and count as the vegetable. Roast a second pan while the oven is already hot.

Roasted Vegetables

Two sheet pans of vegetables roasted at high heat cost little and take one oven cycle. The first night they are a side dish; the second they go into grain bowls over rice or farro with a yogurt sauce, or into a blender with stock to become soup.

Roasted vegetables reheat far better than steamed ones. Cut everything to the same size so nothing burns while something else stays raw.

Beef Stew

Stew is already a stretched dish, built from a cheap cut and a lot of vegetables, and it stretches once more. The leftovers go under a sheet of puff pastry or a biscuit topping and into the oven as a pot pie, which turns a bowl of stew into a dinner that looks like work.

Thicken the reserved portion slightly before it goes under pastry. Individual dishes reheat better than one large pan.

Chicken Curry

A pot of curry with chicken thighs, onions, and tomato holds its flavor for days and improves on the second. Rather than serving it again as curry, spoon it into pastry rounds and bake them into hand pies for lunchboxes and a light dinner.

Leftover curry also folds into rice with peas for a one-pan meal. Make the sauce generous, since the sauce is what carries into the second use.

Salmon

A side of salmon roasted plainly is expensive enough that waste matters. Cold leftover salmon flakes into cakes bound with egg, mustard, and crushed crackers, fried until crisp and served with a lemon sauce, which most families rate above the original preparation.

It also goes into pasta with peas and cream. Roast it slightly under, since the second cooking finishes it.

Pizza Dough

Making dough for four pizzas takes no longer than making it for two, and the extra dough keeps in the refrigerator for several days while improving. The second dinner is calzones filled with whatever the refrigerator holds, which is where leftover sausage, vegetables, and cheese ends go to be useful.

Dough also freezes in individual portions. Let it come to room temperature before it is shaped.

Pancake Batter

A large batch of pancakes on a weekend morning solves several weekday breakfasts if the surplus is cooked rather than kept as batter. Cooked pancakes freeze flat with parchment between them and reheat in a toaster in ninety seconds.

The same approach works for waffles, which crisp better on reheating than pancakes do. Batter left in the refrigerator loses its lift and should be cooked immediately.

The Second Night Was Always the Plan

Every pairing here depends on one decision made before the first meal is even served: cook the protein plain and season the dish, not the ingredient. A chicken rubbed with barbecue sauce can only be barbecue chicken twice.

A chicken roasted with salt can be anything.

The families who eat well on a modest budget are not cooking more often. They are cooking with the second night already in mind, which turns leftovers from an obligation into an advantage already banked by Thursday.

More from Home As We Make It

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.