28 Thrift Store Frames Worth Buying for the Frame Alone

Charity shop walls are covered in bad prints, and the print is usually the reason the thing was donated in the first place. The frame is another matter entirely.

A molding that cost real money in 1890 or in 1955 does not stop being that molding because somebody glued a supermarket poster into it.

The work happens in poor light, at speed, with the art still in place and a price sticker already stuck to the glass. Recognition has to be quick, and almost everything that matters can be checked in the aisle with a fingernail and a willingness to turn the thing over.

Tunbridge Ware Mosaic Frames from Kent

A narrow border of minute colored squares, each one a genuine piece of wood rather than a printed pattern, marks the mosaic work made at Tunbridge Wells in Kent from the 1830s to the end of the century. Makers such as Edmund Nye and Thomas Barton glued bundles of square-section sticks in contrasting timbers, boxwood, holly, ebony and yew among them, into a picture the width of the bundle, then sliced the bundle crosswise into identical veneers.

The result is end grain, so under magnification the pores read as tiny open pits rather than as long grain lines. That is the fastest separation from a lithographed imitation.

Frames turn up holding forgettable Victorian photographs and get priced as ordinary brown wood. Intact borders with no lifted veneer and no bleached surface bring roughly 60 to 250 dollars, and chips or sun fade cut that hard.

Mauchline Ware Souvenir Frames in Varnished Sycamore

Pale, close-grained sycamore under a thick amber varnish, printed with a black-line view of a Scottish town or an English seaside resort and captioned with the place name, is Mauchline ware, the souvenir woodware associated above all with W. and A. Smith of Mauchline in Ayrshire. Tabletop and easel frames were a standard line alongside the boxes and sewing tools, and the transfer sits beneath many coats of varnish and not above them, which settles it against a modern decal.

Fern ware, with a dense pattern of printed fern fronds covering the surface, is a related and slightly scarcer finish from the same trade. Production ran through the 19th century and ended in the 1930s after fire destroyed the works.

Legible transfers with unbroken varnish run 25 to 120 dollars depending on the view; crazed, flaking or overcleaned varnish drops a frame to almost nothing.

Penwork Frames on Black Japanned Grounds

Penwork frames carry chinoiserie figures, foliage and diaper patterning drawn in white or pale yellow on a dense black japanned ground, then sealed under varnish. The technique belonged to English decorators working between 1790 and 1830, and the giveaway is that the ornament is drawn rather than inlaid: fine pen strokes cross one another, lines vary in width where the nib loaded and ran dry, and the design sits flush with the ground rather than standing proud of it.

Papier-mache and lacquer pieces get confused with penwork constantly, so that flush, linear quality is the thing to settle first. Small frames and easel backs survive in far smaller numbers than boxes and tea caddies do.

A sound example with crisp linework and no varnish loss sits in the range of 150 to 500 dollars at specialist dealers, and far less if the black ground has been overpainted or the drawing rubbed thin at the edges.

Rolled Paper and Quillwork Frames

Rolled paper work, also called filigree or quillwork, builds ornament from narrow strips of paper coiled on end, their exposed edges gilded or colored, packed together into scrolls and rosettes. It was a girls’ school accomplishment in Britain and colonial America across the 18th and early 19th centuries, applied to sconces, tea caddies and small frames, usually protected behind glass because the surface cannot survive handling.

Recognition is simple once the technique has been seen once: the ornament is built from hundreds of paper coils standing on edge, catching light along their gilded rims, and the entire assembly is bone dry and weightless. Survival rates are low, and that is what makes an intact example matter.

Damp is the enemy, and a frame with foxed, collapsed or water-stained coils has lost most of its value. Sound rolled paper frames run 200 to 700 dollars, and an example retaining its original glazing and an academy or school inscription on the backboard runs several times that.

Straw Work Frames from Napoleonic Prison Workshops

Straw work uses split, flattened and often dyed straw laid down in geometric panels, and the surface has a silky, faintly metallic sheen that no wood veneer produces. Much of the finest material was made by French prisoners of war held in British depots during the Napoleonic wars, who worked in straw, bone and wood to raise money, and the tradition continued in Continental souvenir workshops through the 19th century.

Under magnification the straw shows its natural nodes and a fine parallel striation running the length of each strip. Frames read as cheap and brown from across a shop because the straw dulls with grime, which is precisely why they get passed over.

Value tracks completeness, since lifted or missing straw is effectively unrepairable and water damage turns the surface gray and brittle. Intact small frames commonly run 100 to 400 dollars, with early prisoner work well above that.

Pyrography Frames from the Flemish Art Craze

Burnt-wood frames came out of the pyrography boom that ran from the 1890s to about 1915, when firms such as the Flemish Art Company of New York and Thayer and Chandler of Chicago sold pre-stamped basswood blanks to be burned at home with a platinum-tipped pen heated over a benzine reservoir. The design was printed on the blank in light ink and then followed by hand, so the outline is precise while the shading wanders, and skill varies enormously between one example and the next.

Depth is the test. A burned line is charred into the wood and reads under a fingernail as a shallow groove with a scorched shoulder, while the stained and printed imitations sold alongside them are dead flat.

Poppies, grapes and conventionalized flowers dominate the subject matter, and a dated or initialed piece is scarcer than an anonymous one. Clean examples with strong shading and no later stain over the burning run 25 to 90 dollars; cracked, sun-bleached or heavily revarnished ones are close to nothing.

Anglo-Indian Bone-Veneered Frames of the Vizagapatam Trade

Frames veneered in thin plates of cream-colored bone or ivory, pinned with tiny pegs and engraved with foliate scrollwork whose lines are filled with black lac, come out of the Anglo-Indian export trade centered on Vizagapatam on the east coast of India, now Visakhapatnam. Eighteenth and early 19th century work used ivory over sandalwood, while later 19th century pieces increasingly used bone.

Separating them matters legally as much as financially: ivory shows faint crosshatched Schreger lines when viewed end on, and bone shows fine dark canals running through the material. Ivory sales face federal restriction under the Endangered Species Act, and several states, New York, California and New Jersey among them, restrict or prohibit intrastate sale with narrow and inconsistent antique exemptions that a seller has to document rather than assume, so a frame that reads as ivory is better admired than moved.

Bone examples are unrestricted and run roughly 150 to 600 dollars according to size and to how crisply the engraving is cut, with cracked or sprung veneer knocking that down sharply.

Balinese Carved Frames from the Import Boom

The deeply undercut frangipani, lotus and vine frames that flooded American import stores from the late 1980s onward are carved in fast-growing tropical timbers such as suar and albizia, and they weigh almost nothing for the volume of carving on show. Recognition is a matter of feel more than sight, since the mass is wrong, the reverse is left rough and open behind the carving, and the whitewash or gold wash sits directly in the tool marks rather than over a gesso layer.

These are not antiques and pretending otherwise is pointless. What makes them worth lifting off a wall is scale: a carved surround over thirty inches works as a serious mirror frame for a fraction of what comparable molding costs new, and the carving quality on 1990s Ubud work is genuinely good.

Expect 15 to 70 dollars retail, less if the finish has been resprayed, and the small ones are material rather than objects.

Trumeau Mirrors with a Painted Panel Above the Glass

A trumeau is the wall panel between two windows or above a chimneypiece, and the frame form takes its name from that position: a single molding enclosing a mirror plate below and a painted or carved panel above. French examples run from the 18th century onward, and the type has been reproduced continuously ever since, so age has to be argued from the glass and the joinery rather than from the shape.

Original plates are thin, slightly wavy and gray rather than bright, and mirrors made before roughly the middle of the nineteenth century were commonly backed with a tin and mercury amalgam, a method that overlapped for some decades with the silvering process that replaced it. Degraded amalgam appears as a crystalline, faintly sparkling film, and it must never be scraped, sanded or picked at; a flaking old plate is best left undisturbed or handled by someone equipped for it.

Reproductions run 80 to 300 dollars, while period examples with original glass and paint move into the low thousands.

Girandole Mirrors with Candle Arms

Girandole mirrors carry candle arms, usually a scrolled pair springing from the lower frame with a drip pan and commonly a ring of cut glass drops beneath each socket. The arms are the entire point and the reason most examples are broken, because they are the first thing to snap in a move, and a frame missing both arms has lost about half its value even when the empty sockets survive.

Giltwood and gilt gesso versions from the late 18th and early 19th centuries turn up in charity shops with the arms removed and taped to the backboard, so the backboard settles the question before the thing gets dismissed as a plain mirror. Pairs bring substantially more than twice a single, and singles in reasonable condition run 100 to 400 dollars.

Replacement arms are common and generally detectable, since the gilding tone rarely matches and the fixing screws are modern.

Pier and Overmantel Glasses in Two or Three Plates

Long mirrors divided into two or three separate plates by applied moldings were built that way because large sheets of glass were expensive before the middle of the 19th century, so the division is a dating cue rather than evidence of repair. Overmantel glasses run horizontally, pier glasses run tall and narrow to fit between windows, and both were made to hang high, so the gilding is crude along the lower rail and finer toward the top.

These sit at the back of charity shops at absurd prices for one reason: nobody can carry them. That is the opportunity. Even when the plates are past saving, the run of molding on a six-foot overmantel is worth real money to anyone reframing large work, and the gesso ornament can be salvaged.

Shop prices of 40 to 150 dollars are common; the same object at a dealer runs many times that. Anything this heavy needs anchors set into studs, not drywall plugs.

Cheval and Swing Dressing Glasses

Cheval glasses stand on their own trestle feet at something close to full length, while dressing glasses are the smaller version, swinging between two uprights on a box base fitted with drawers. Both types get donated constantly because the mirror is cloudy and the owner assumes the object is finished. The frame and stand are the asset.

Pivot hardware settles the age faster than the timber does: hand-cut screws have off-center slots and threads that wander slightly, where a machine screw is perfectly regular, and period uprights are mortised into the base or into the trestle rather than screwed on from the outside. Drawer construction in the box base confirms it, since hand-cut dovetails are few and uneven while machine-cut ones are many and identical.

Resilvering is a routine job on anything decent and costs less than the frame is worth. Dressing glasses run 30 to 120 dollars in a shop, and a good period cheval glass sells for several hundred once the glass is sorted out.

Chinese Chippendale Fretwork Mirrors

Pierced fretwork mirrors with scrolled crests, pagoda profiles and openwork skirts descend from the mid-18th century English taste for Chinese ornament, and they have been reproduced in every decade since. The useful distinction is structural.

Period and better early examples cut the fret from solid mahogany or from mahogany veneer over a pine core, and the sawn edges show grain running out at the tight curves. Mid-20th century revivals cut the fret from plywood, and the laminations show on any sawn edge as parallel stripes.

Neither is worthless, but the gap in value is wide. Fretwork is also the most fragile part of these frames, and a crest with a broken scroll is a repair rather than a loss, since the missing element can be cut and matched by anyone with a coping saw.

Revival examples run roughly 50 to 200 dollars, while period English work with original glass runs into the thousands.

Syroco Molded Wood-Flour Ornament

Syroco is the trade name of the Syracuse Ornamental Company of Syracuse, New York, founded in the late 1800s and generally credited to Adolph Holstein, which pressed wood flour bound with resin into molds to imitate carved ornament at a fraction of the cost.

Early and mid-century pieces are dense, warm in the hand, and take a stain or a gilt finish convincingly, and the mark is embossed or stamped on the reverse. The tell that separates them from carved wood is the absence of undercutting, since every element has to release cleanly from a mold, so no ornament ever curls back on itself and identical motifs repeat with mechanical exactness.

Later production moved to injection-molded plastic, lighter and colder in the hand and much harder, and that material is worth very little. Gilt mirrors and frames in the earlier wood-flour material run 30 to 120 dollars, and large mid-century wall pieces sit above that.

Oxford Frames and the Corners That Cross Instead of Meeting

Oxford frames have no miters. The four members cross near each corner and project past the joint as square ears, halved into one another where they overlap, and the type carried engravings, illuminated texts and photographs in British and American parlors from the 1850s onward.

Oak and walnut are the usual timbers, frequently with a molded outer edge and a gilt slip at the sight edge. The construction is the reason these sit cheap and the reason they repay attention: a crossed corner cannot be cut down to another size the way a mitered molding can, so the frame is fixed at whatever it was built for and gets passed over by anyone shopping for a standard opening.

The lap joints loosen before anything else fails, and a frame that racks when lifted by one corner needs its joints re-glued rather than rebuilt. Sound oak examples run 30 to 110 dollars, with deep-molded walnut and any surviving original gilt slip toward the upper end.

Turner Manufacturing Wall Accessories from Chicago

Turner Manufacturing Company of Chicago sold framed prints through five-and-dime stores from the 1940s onward, and the label on the reverse reads Turner Wall Accessory. The house style is chalky pastel imagery, birds and flowering branches above all, and the frames were frequently built with mirrored inserts or with mirror strips flanking the print.

Those mirror-inset frames are the ones to take. The signature on a Turner print is worked into the image rather than placed in a margin, so a reframed print looks anonymous when it is not.

Bird subjects and mirrored designs bring 40 to 120 dollars, while the historical painting reproductions the company also issued sit closer to 15 to 30 dollars. Foxed prints and clouded mirror inserts pull those figures down, though a clean frame carrying a poor print still earns the purchase.

Burl and Faux-Finish Frames of the 1970s

The 1970s produced enormous quantities of frames finished to look like burl walnut, and the difference between printed and genuine comes down to a fingernail check at one corner. Printed foil and paper wraps show the identical grain figure repeating at a fixed interval along the molding, and the pattern runs straight off the mitered corner instead of meeting itself.

Real burl veneer has figure that never repeats, and the miter shows the veneer wrapping a solid or hardwood-faced core with a visible glue line. Genuine burl veneer frames from the period were not cheap when new and run 40 to 150 dollars in sound condition.

Printed ones fetch a few dollars and earn their place only by fitting a size already needed. Both fail the same way, through veneer or foil lifting at the corners where hands touch the frame, and a lifted foil wrap cannot be laid back down.

Smoked and Antiqued Mirror Panel Frames

Frames whose borders are made from strips of gray, bronze or peach-tinted mirror, many of them with the deliberate gold speckling that trade catalogs called antiqued, belong to a run of American and Italian production from the 1960s through the early 1980s. They are usually assembled with small brass or chrome corner clips over a wood or particleboard core.

Recognition in bad light is easy, because the border reflects and a painted frame does not. These have followed Hollywood Regency and 1970s decor back into fashion, and clean examples with all panels intact and no delamination now run roughly 50 to 200 dollars.

Delamination shows as black creeping in from the edge of a panel and cannot be reversed. The glass here is plate rather than tempered, and the exposed edges of mirror strip are sharp enough to cut, so one of these travels better wrapped than tucked under an arm.

Gilt Metal Vanity Mirrors of the Hollywood Regency Years

Cast and stamped gilt metal dressing mirrors, with borders of rose swags, ribbon knots and pierced scrollwork, were made in quantity in Italy and the United States between the late 1940s and the 1970s, most often as tabletop easel mirrors or small wall pieces. The metal is thin and the gilding is a lacquered finish over brass or over a zinc alloy, so the recognition cue is weight relative to apparent mass, plus the slightly soapy softness of a casting compared with the crisp chasing on an antique.

Italian pieces sometimes carry a paper label or a stamped country of origin on the easel strut. Condition is about the lacquer, which yellows and flakes and cannot be touched up invisibly, and about the strut, which is frequently missing. Sound examples run 30 to 130 dollars, with larger Italian wall mirrors above that.

Aggressive polishing strips the finish and destroys the value in an afternoon.

Acrylic Box and Floating Acrylic Frames

Acrylic box frames are five-sided sleeves that drop over a backing block, and floating acrylic frames sandwich the work between two sheets held apart by metal standoffs. Both are expensive new and both turn up in thrift stores for a few dollars because they look like packaging.

Cast acrylic shows a faint green or blue cast along the polished edges and cuts with a slightly waxy feel, while extruded sheet is cheaper and scratches more readily. Surface decides value here, since a scratched acrylic frame reads as damaged from across a room.

Light scratching polishes out with a plastic polish and a soft cloth, but ammonia-based glass cleaner crazes acrylic permanently and is the most common way these get ruined. A large acrylic box frame retailing above 100 dollars new sits on a charity shop shelf at 5 or 10 dollars, one of the widest margins in the building.

Heydenryk Frames and the Wormy Chestnut Finish

The House of Heydenryk traces to Amsterdam in 1845 and was established in New York in the first half of the twentieth century, running under Henry Heydenryk Jr., who lived from 1905 to 1994 and framed work for Georgia O’Keeffe, Edward Hopper and Andrew Wyeth among many others. The workshop’s paper label on the backboard is the fastest identification, and it survives more often than expected because these frames were treated carefully by their first owners.

The house is also credited with popularizing wormy chestnut frames from the late 1930s, using timber salvaged from blight-killed American chestnut, and that surface reads as a network of insect galleries and dark tracks under a scraped or stained finish rather than under gilding. A Heydenryk frame is worth several hundred dollars empty and considerably more in a size that suits a standard canvas.

Condition questions concern the finish, which was deliberately left soft and responds badly to modern varnish.

Max Kuehne Frames with Incised and Silvered Surfaces

Max Kuehne, who lived from 1880 to 1968 and worked largely in Gloucester, Massachusetts, painted for a living, but the frames he carved and gilded have outrun his pictures in the market. The look is a carved and incised surface, frequently silver leaf toned to a warm gray or gold leaf over a red ground, with cut ornament running as a continuous pattern rather than concentrating at the corners.

The incising is shallow and cut by hand, so the spacing wanders very slightly and parts company with machine-embossed imitation. Some examples carry his name on the reverse, though many do not and are identified instead by pattern and finish.

This is a frame most shop volunteers will price as brown wood with tired gilt, and attributed examples reach four figures with dealers who handle American frames.

The pattern is what carries the identification: a continuous incised rhythm running the full length of every rail, silver leaf toned to a warm gray beneath it, and corners that carry no more ornament than the rails do.

Bucks County Frames by Frederick Harer and Ben Badura

Frederick Harer, who lived from 1879 to 1948 and worked at Uhlerstown, Pennsylvania, built cassetta-form frames for the New Hope painters, Edward Redfield and Daniel Garber among them, and signed them by carving his name into the reverse. The recognition cue is notch carving at the corners and at the center of each rail, cut into a flat panel inside a raised outer molding, over a warm gilded and toned surface that reads more orange than yellow.

Ben Badura apprenticed to Harer in the late 1920s, opened his own shop in the following decade and is said to have taken on the design books and tools, so the vocabulary continues with new carved patterns and, in some cases, ungilded frames with designs scratched into raw gesso. Harer frames are routinely worth more than the pictures inside them and reach four figures with specialist dealers.

The carved signature on the reverse is the thing to check before the price sticker.

Deep-Rabbet Frames Built for Stretched Canvas

Most frames built for prints have a rabbet, the recess behind the sight edge, of about a quarter inch, which is enough for glass, mat and backing and nothing more. A frame with a rabbet three quarters of an inch deep or more was built to take a stretched canvas, and that single measurement changes who wants it.

Painters and framers pay real money for deep-rabbet molding, because the alternative is building out a shallow frame with strips of wood, and that is fiddly and always shows at the corners. Standard canvas sizes such as sixteen by twenty or twenty-four by thirty-six move quickly at 40 to 150 dollars even with a mediocre finish, which is several times what the same frame is priced at on the wall.

The check takes seconds with the art still in place, since the depth from the front face to the backboard tells the story, and a frame that stands well proud of the wall when hung has already answered the question.

Victorian Crazy-Patch Fabric-Covered Frames

Crazy patchwork frames wrap a core in irregular patches of silk, velvet and ribbon, with every seam covered by feather stitching or herringbone in colored thread, and with a scattering of embroidered spiders, fans and initials. The fashion peaked in American and British parlors during the 1880s and 1890s.

No two patches share a shape, and the embroidery follows the seams rather than forming a design of its own. What the core is made of decides what the object is: a thin wooden stretcher with the fabric tacked around the back was built to last and can be re-stretched, where a cardboard core warps, softens at the corners and drags the fabric out of shape with it.

Period silks were weighted with metal salts and split vertically as they age, so sound velvet beside shattered silk is the normal condition and it is cheap. An example still carrying its original paper or fabric backing, undisturbed on the reverse, runs 80 to 250 dollars, and damp or a previous cleaning attempt removes most of that.

Beadwork Frames from the Niagara Souvenir Trade

Haudenosaunee beadwork frames made for the tourist trade around Niagara Falls from the 1860s onward are built on a cotton or velvet-covered form and worked in glass seed beads, frequently in the raised technique where long stitches arch the beads clear of the surface into standing loops and floral forms. Dates and place names beaded directly into the piece are common and make an example far more desirable.

These get cataloged in shops as generic Victorian craft and priced to match. The recognition cue is the raised beadwork itself, since flat beadwork is far more widely made and the arched, three-dimensional loops belong to this specific tradition.

Losses matter enormously, because one broken thread releases an entire run of beads and a frame that is shedding will keep shedding. Sound dated examples run roughly 150 to 600 dollars, with plain undated ones well below that and damaged ones close to nothing.

Gilt Frames Sold Under a Coat of Modern Gold Spray

Three surfaces get called gold on a charity shop wall, and the resprayed period frame is the one that costs money. Water gilding lays gold leaf over a colored clay ground, usually a warm red, and burnishes to a mirror shine, so an untouched example shows glossy highlights on the raised ornament and red clay at the rubbed corners.

Oil gilding lays leaf over a size, cannot be burnished, and stays matte over a yellow or gray ground. Gold spray and bronze powder read greenish and sit evenly across dirt, cracks and old repairs alike, because a sprayed finish arrives after the wear, not before.

Bronze powder lifts as a brown smear on a swab barely damped with water. Leaf does not, but water gilding sits on a soluble gesso and bole ground and will come away with the moisture, so that swab belongs on a concealed back edge of a frame already suspected of being bronzed, never on a burnished highlight.

Lead is a live risk on any gilded or painted surface older than 1978.

Backboards, Nails and the Ten-Second Turn-Over

Fasteners settle a frame’s date faster than anything on its face does. Hand-wrought nails have irregular heads and taper on all four sides; machine-cut nails are rectangular in section with two parallel sides and were standard from roughly the 1790s through the 1890s; round wire nails point to about 1890 onward.

Staples belong to the second half of the twentieth century, since they entered framing shops from around the 1940s, but they are also the commonest later repair, so a stapled backboard dates the last person to open the frame rather than the frame. Hand-planed backboards show shallow scalloped tracks running across the grain from a plane iron, quite unlike the fine parallel ridges left by a machine planer.

Corner construction runs from mortised and pegged joints on early work, through miters reinforced with splines or glue blocks, to the stapled miters of modern production. Original paper backing, dealer labels and framer stamps survive on the reverse far more often than anyone expects and can add substantially to value.

The Print Was Never the Point

Most ornate frames are worth less than their owners assume, and the fussiest ones are frequently the cheapest. What the trade pays for turns out to be size, depth of profile and ornament that is still all there, which is why a plain wide molding in a large size beats a crowded small one nearly every time.

The detail that catches the eye first is usually the part that has already been repaired. Grime is the only problem on that list that reverses; missing ornament and a respray do not.

The art inside is a distraction and usually a bad one. A frame priced at four dollars because it holds a faded print of a covered bridge has been priced on the bridge, and that error is repeated on every charity shop wall that has a picture on it.

Old glass is not safety glass and old painted surfaces are not safe to sand. Carrying it flat and opening the back at home is all the method there is, and the frame proves what it is or does not.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.