28 Old Harvest Festival Programs and County Fair Memorabilia Dealers Search For
County fairs generated mountains of paper and cheap souvenirs, almost all of which went into the trash the week after the midway closed. What survived tends to be what somebody’s grandmother tucked into a drawer, which is exactly why dealers now pay real money for a folded program that originally cost a dime.
The market rewards specificity. A generic fair souvenir is worth little, but one tied to a named town, a dated event, or a recognizable exhibitor tends to find a buyer quickly.
Premium Books From State and County Fairs
The premium book was the fair’s rule manual, listing every competitive class and the cash prize attached to it. Collectors value them because they document what a community grew, sewed, and raised in a given year, down to the varieties of apples judged and the exact payout for second-place jelly.
Editions from the 1890s through the 1930s carry heavy advertising from local implement dealers and seed houses, which is often what a buyer actually wants.
Lithographed Fair Posters From the 1920s and 1930s
Fair posters were printed in stock formats with the town name and dates overprinted, usually by regional show-printing companies. The stock imagery ran to racing sulkies, aviators, and grandstand acts, and the color lithography holds up remarkably well.
Condition drives value hard here because most were pasted to barns and fences and then weathered for a season.
Grandstand Show Programs
The grandstand act was the fair’s headline entertainment, and its program listed the performers, the running order, and the sponsors who paid for it. Programs featuring touring acts that later became nationally known command a premium far above the rest.
Most are thin, stapled booklets that survived only because someone used them as scrapbook filler.
Blue Ribbon Awards
The first-place ribbon is the single most recognizable piece of fair memorabilia, and dealers buy them by the box for decorators as much as for collectors. Older examples use silk or heavy grosgrain with gilt lettering rather than the printed polyester of recent decades.
A ribbon that names the fair, the year, and the specific class beats a plain one every time.
Grand Champion Rosettes
The multi-layered rosette awarded to a grand champion animal is a substantially larger and more elaborate object than a standard placing ribbon, often with streamers and a printed center medallion. These were made in small numbers by definition, since a fair produces only a handful of grand champions in any year.
Livestock breeders form a steady secondary market for rosettes tied to their own breeds.
Celluloid Exhibitor Badges
Exhibitors and fair officials wore pin-back celluloid badges that identified their role and year, and the manufacturing quality of pre-1920 examples is far better than anything that followed. Collectors of political pin-backs cross over into this category, which pushes prices up.
Rust on the reverse and cracked celluloid are the usual condition problems.
Fair Admission Ticket Rolls
Unused rolls of numbered admission tickets turn up in fairground office cleanouts and sell surprisingly well as graphic objects. The typography and color coding, which changed by day and by gate, do most of the work.
Full rolls are worth considerably more than loose singles.
Midway Ride Tokens
Brass and aluminum tokens redeemed for rides were struck by the carnival companies that leased the midway rather than by the fairs themselves. That makes them collectible to the exonumia crowd, who track them by carnival operator and date.
Tokens naming a defunct traveling show are the ones dealers chase.
4-H Club Record Books
The record book was the annual project journal a member kept, documenting feed costs, growth measurements, and eventual sale price. They read as genuine agricultural documents rather than souvenirs, which appeals to buyers interested in rural social history.
Books with photographs pasted inside sell for multiples of plain ones.
Achievement Pins From Youth Clubs
Small enameled pins marking years of membership and completed projects were issued in graduated designs, so collectors assemble runs. The clover-marked examples from the 1920s and 1930s used better enamel work than later production.
Complete sets in an original mailing card are unusual.
Grange Hall Harvest Supper Programs
Local Grange chapters printed programs for harvest suppers and installation ceremonies, often on colored stock with the chapter number displayed prominently. These sit at the intersection of fraternal-order collecting and agricultural history, giving them two buyer pools.
Many list every officer by name, which makes them useful to genealogists.
Felt Souvenir Pennants
Fair pennants were sold at the gate and tacked to bedroom walls, so most that survive have pin damage at the corners. Earlier examples used stitched felt lettering rather than screen printing, and the difference is visible at a glance.
Pennants for fairs that no longer operate carry a premium in their home regions.
Butter Sculpture Postcards
Sculpted butter displays were a fixture at Midwestern fairs, and postcard publishers photographed them every year. The cards document a genuinely strange tradition and sell steadily to postcard dealers and dairy-industry collectors alike.
Real photo postcards outperform printed ones by a wide margin.
Real Photo Postcards of Prize Livestock
Farmers commissioned photographers to shoot winning animals, and the resulting cards were mailed to buyers and breed registries as advertising. The images are usually sharp, formally composed, and captioned with the animal’s registered name.
Breed clubs actively buy them back for archival purposes.
Harness Racing Programs From Fairgrounds Tracks
Nearly every county fairground had a half-mile track, and harness racing filled the afternoons. Programs list horses, drivers, and pari-mutuel odds, and they are dated to the day, which collectors like. Tracks that have since been demolished generate the strongest local demand.
Livestock Auction Catalogs
Sale catalogs printed for fairground consignment auctions include pedigrees, photographs, and the names of consigning farms. Purebred breeders use them to trace bloodlines, so demand comes from working agriculture rather than nostalgia.
Catalogs with the buyer’s handwritten prices in the margins are more valuable, not less.
Cardboard Advertising Hand Fans
Seed companies, funeral homes, and feed mills handed out stapled cardboard fans at fairs and revival meetings, and the printed side is essentially a small poster. They survived in quantity but rarely in clean condition.
Fans advertising a business still operating today sell fastest.
Seed Company Giveaway Yardsticks
Wooden yardsticks stamped with a hybrid seed brand and a dealer’s name were fair-booth staples for decades. Collectors of agricultural advertising treat them as an entry-level category with real upside for early examples.
Warping and paint loss knock values down quickly.
Fair Queen Coronation Programs
The crowning of a fair queen came with its own printed program listing contestants, sponsors, and judges. These are heavily photographed local social documents, and families buy them back when a relative appears inside.
Programs from the 1950s and 1960s are the most sought.
Tractor Pull Programs
Competitive pulling became a fair headline event in the postwar decades, and its programs name every machine and its modifications. Enthusiasts restoring specific tractors hunt these down for documentation.
Programs from the early years of the sport are scarce because nobody thought to keep them.
Demolition Derby Handbills
Single-sheet handbills advertising the derby were printed in loud colors on cheap stock and posted around town. Their disposability is what makes surviving examples uncommon, and the graphic design has crossed into general poster collecting.
Original tack punctures are expected and tolerated.
Canning Competition Entry Tags
The small numbered tags wired to competition jars carry the exhibitor’s name, class, and placing in a judge’s handwriting. They are tiny, ephemeral, and almost never saved, which is precisely the appeal.
Dealers sell them in framed groupings.
Souvenir Glass Tumblers
Frosted or flashed-glass tumblers bearing a fair name and year were midway prizes and gate purchases. Ruby-flashed examples from the early twentieth century, often personalized with a first name, are the ones to look for.
Dishwasher exposure has destroyed most of the later ones.
Commemorative Souvenir Plates
Fairs marking anniversaries commissioned decorative plates showing the grandstand, the exhibition hall, or the fairgrounds gate. Production runs were small and local, so surviving examples are often the best surviving image of buildings long since torn down.
Historical societies compete with dealers for these.
Anniversary and Centennial Programs
A fair’s hundredth-year program is typically a thick, illustrated volume with historical essays and reproduced photographs from earlier decades. They function as unofficial county histories and are consistently the most useful piece of fair paper for researchers.
Copies sell well above ordinary annual programs.
Concession Stand Signage
Hand-painted menu boards and price signs from church and civic-club food stands have become decorative objects with strong crossover appeal. The lettering was almost always done by an amateur, which is exactly what buyers respond to.
Prices frozen at mid-century levels add to the appeal.
Fair Board Minute Books
Bound ledgers recording fair board meetings track finances, disputes, weather cancellations, and contracts with carnival operators. County historical societies want them, but so do collectors who enjoy institutional records.
A run of consecutive years is worth far more than a single volume.
Parade Broadsides for Harvest Festivals
Large printed sheets announcing the harvest parade listed the route, the marshals, and the participating floats. Because they were posted outdoors, clean examples are genuinely rare.
Broadsides naming a specific year and town are the ones dealers will chase across several states.
What the Paper Trail Actually Preserves
The objects that survive from a county fair are almost never the ones anybody intended to keep. Ribbons went into shoeboxes, programs became scrapbook padding, and tickets stayed on the roll because the gate closed early. The accidental nature of that survival is what gives the surviving material its documentary weight.
Fair memorabilia holds value because it is stubbornly local. A premium book names the families who raised the sheep, the merchants who bought the ad space, and the varieties that grew well that particular year in that particular county, and no general history will ever record any of it.
More from Home As We Make It
- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
