28 Old Advertising Signs and Tins Dealers Buy on Sight
Advertising was designed to be discarded. A sign hung until the product changed, a tin held its contents until they ran out, and then both went into the burn pile behind the store.
What survived did so by accident, usually because someone nailed it over a gap in a barn wall.
That accidental survival is why dealers move fast on this material. Graphics, brand, and condition set the price, and a strong example can be gone from a booth before the seller finishes unloading the truck.
Porcelain Gas Station Signs
Enamel fused onto steel produced signs that held their color for decades outdoors, and oil company signage from the 1920s through the 1950s sits at the top of the advertising market. Double-sided examples with original mounting rings bring more than single-sided ones.
Chipping around the mounting points is expected, while flaking across the face cuts value substantially.
Motor Oil Cans in Quart Size
Full or empty, lithographed quart cans carry graphics tied to specific companies and eras, and regional brands frequently outperform national ones. Cone-top cans predate the flat metal versions and are scarcer.
Dents in the printed face are the primary condition concern.
Grease Tins With Lithographed Labels
Five-pound and ten-pound grease pails carried bold graphics on the sides and lids, and the lids are often separated from the bodies. A matched tin with its correct lid is considerably harder to find than either piece alone.
Interior residue does not deter buyers.
Coca-Cola Button Signs
The round painted metal signs produced from the late 1940s came in several diameters and were mounted on storefronts and door frames nationwide. Size determines price, with the largest examples well ahead.
Reproductions are abundant, so buyers check the manufacturing stamp on the edge.
Neon Advertising Clocks
Clocks with a neon ring surrounding an advertising face were installed in service stations, diners, and dealerships, and working examples with original transformers and glass command real money. The neon tube is the fragile element and replacements are visibly different.
Original faces without repainting are what buyers pay for.
Painted Thermometer Signs
Vertical porcelain and painted metal thermometers advertising soft drinks, motor oil, and farm products hung outside stores for decades. The functioning thermometer matters less than the graphics around it.
Rust creeping under the paint at the edges is the usual defect.
Seed Company Signs and Boxes
Wooden seed boxes with lithographed paper labels inside the lid, along with the hanging store signs that went with them, appeal to both advertising and agricultural collectors. The paper label is the entire value and is frequently torn or missing.
Regional seed houses that closed early produce the scarcest examples.
Feed Store Signs
Embossed metal signs advertising livestock feed hung on rural storefronts across the country, often with a dealer’s name painted at the bottom. That local name adds interest for buyers from the area.
Bullet damage is common, occasionally acceptable, and generally priced in.
Coffee Tins With Paper Labels
Early coffee came in tins with wrapped paper labels rather than printed lithography, and those labels rarely survived humidity. Key-wind lids and pry-off versions represent different eras.
Collectors pursue defunct regional roasters more aggressively than surviving national brands.
Tea Tins From British Grocers
Decorative tea tins produced for grocers were made in bright lithography and unusual shapes, some designed to be reused as household containers. That secondary use is why so many survived.
Interior rust from damp storage is the flaw that eliminates most examples.
Spice Tins in Matched Sets
Small spice tins with printed labels were sold individually and accumulated on kitchen shelves, and a complete matched set from one brand is far harder to assemble than it sounds. Condition varies wildly within a set.
Buyers photograph the full group because sets sell better than singles.
Biscuit Tins in Novelty Shapes
British biscuit manufacturers produced tins shaped as vehicles, buildings, and books, some with working wheels and hinges, intended to be kept as toys after the contents were eaten. Mechanical examples with moving parts bring the strongest prices.
Paint loss on raised edges is the standard wear pattern.
Talcum Powder Tins
North East Museums, source: Flickr, No known copyright restrictions
Small tins with shaker tops and elaborate printed graphics were produced for dozens of brands and survive because they were kept on dressers rather than in pantries. Art Deco designs are the most pursued.
The shaker mechanism should be intact and the tin should retain its original weight of contents where possible.
Baking Powder Tins
These sat in kitchens for decades and were refilled or repurposed constantly, so they turn up more often than most advertising tins. Early paper-labeled versions predate lithographed printing and are scarcer.
Small regional brands outvalue the familiar national names.
Cocoa Tins
Cocoa containers carried some of the most detailed lithography in the grocery category, frequently featuring illustrated scenes across all four sides. Larger sizes intended for commercial kitchens are less common than household tins.
Fading from window display is a permanent problem.
Peanut Butter Pails With Bail Handles
Small tin pails with wire handles were sold as a package that doubled as a child’s toy pail afterward, which is why they survived and also why they are usually beaten up. Character graphics drive value here.
The handle should be original and attached at both ears.
Lard Pails
Larger pails with lithographed sides and press-fit lids advertised meat packers and local butchers. Butcher shop names on the sides make them collectible regionally.
Interior grease staining is expected and does not affect price meaningfully.
Candy Tins From Confectioners
Confectionery tins ranged from pocket-size mint containers to large counter display tins, with the counter versions being both scarcer and more decorative. Hinged lids and original glass panels raise value.
Buyers check the base for maker’s marks from the tin printer.
Typewriter Ribbon Tins
Flat circular tins holding replacement ribbons were produced by dozens of manufacturers with striking graphic designs on lids barely two inches across. They cost almost nothing and were thrown away by the case.
Collectors assemble them by design rather than brand.
Pharmacy and Aspirin Tins
Small hinged tins from drug manufacturers carried printed dosing instructions and period graphics, and pharmacy collectors buy them alongside apothecary bottles. Unopened examples with original contents are handled carefully and priced higher.
Hinge wear is the common problem.
Veterinary and Liniment Tins
Products for livestock came in tins with illustrations of horses and cattle and claims that no regulator would permit today. Those claims are much of the appeal.
Farm collectors and advertising collectors compete for the same examples.
Soda Fountain Signs
Cardboard, tin, and glass signage from drugstore fountains advertised flavors and prices in period typography, and the cardboard versions barely survive at all. Original easel backs on countertop signs matter.
Water staining is the usual reason a cardboard sign gets passed over.
Beer Serving Trays
Lithographed metal trays from breweries, especially those that closed during Prohibition, are collected by brewery and by region. Deep-dish trays with rolled rims predate the flat versions.
Scratches across the center face from actual service reduce value considerably.
Ice Cream Parlor Signs
Painted and porcelain signs from creameries and parlors combine strong graphics with a nostalgic subject that appeals well beyond advertising collectors. Flavor board signs with movable letters are especially decorative.
Original hanging hardware adds credibility.
Farm Implement Dealer Signs
Large porcelain and metal signs from tractor and implement dealers carried brand colors and dealer names, and they hung on buildings that are now being demolished across rural areas. Size makes shipping difficult and keeps much of the trade local.
Fading on the sun-facing side is standard.
Hardware Store Display Cabinets
Oak and metal countertop cabinets with printed glass fronts held nails, drill bits, and small parts and carried the supplier’s branding across the front. Complete cabinets with original drawers and labels are uncommon.
Replaced glass is detectable and lowers price.
Barber Shop Signs and Poles
Painted and porcelain signs from barber shops, along with the rotating poles themselves, cross into both advertising and Americana markets. Working motors and intact glass cylinders on poles are what separate a good example from a project.
Original mounting brackets are frequently missing.
Sardine and Fish Tins With Lithographed Lids
Canneries printed detailed maritime scenes directly onto their tins, and the coastal packing houses that produced them mostly closed generations ago. Unopened examples exist and are collected sealed.
Key-wind lids with the key still attached are the ones to look for.
The Art Nobody Meant to Make
None of this was produced as art. It was produced to move a product off a shelf in a town that may no longer have a store, by printers who were paid by the thousand and expected their work to end up in a fire.
That is what makes the surviving pieces worth chasing. The graphics record how ordinary companies talked to ordinary customers in a specific decade, and the only reason any of it is still here is that somebody, somewhere, was too practical to throw away a perfectly good piece of tin.
More from Home As We Make It
- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
