28 Estate Sale Items Small Enough to Pocket

Estate sales run on furniture. The company that priced the house spent its hours on the dining set, the armoire, and the artwork, because those are the line items that justify the commission. The dresser drawers and the desk caddies got a lump price and a shrug.

Which is why the buyers who do best walk past the furniture entirely and go upstairs. Everything on this list is small enough to carry to the cash table in one hand, and most of it was priced by somebody who had four hundred other decisions to make that morning.

Sterling Silver Souvenir Spoons

Commemorative spoons were the standard tourist purchase from the 1890s through the 1930s, and a great many of them are solid silver rather than plate. The bowl usually depicts a landmark and the handle carries a city or state motif, often with enameled detail. 

Look for the word sterling or the number 925 along the back of the handle. Enamel loss reduces value considerably, while patina in the recesses does not.

Single Pieces of Sterling Flatware

Estate sales sell full silver services as a unit and dump the orphans into a box by the door. Those orphans are where the margin is, because collectors completing an inherited set will pay well above melt for one matching fish fork in the right pattern. 

The pattern name is often stamped on the reverse of the handle alongside the maker. Serving pieces such as ladles, pie servers, and sugar tongs outperform ordinary place forks by a wide margin.

Vintage Fountain Pens

A pen with a gold nib is a small object with a global collector market and shockingly inconsistent estate pricing. The nib is stamped with a karat mark, usually 14K or 585, visible under any light. 

Parker, Sheaffer, Waterman, and Esterbrook models are the ones most likely to turn up in an American desk drawer. A dried-out sac inside the barrel is a routine repair and should not scare anyone off a good nib.

Mechanical Wristwatches

Anything that ticks without a battery is worth a second look, since the automatic and hand-wound market has grown steadily for two decades. Turn the crown and listen for the wind, then check the dial for a maker’s name and the caseback for a serial. 

Hamilton, Bulova, Longines, and older Seiko divers all appear in estate jewelry boxes at costume jewelry prices. A non-running movement typically costs a couple of hundred to service, which still leaves room on the good pieces.

Pocket Watches and Loose Movements

American railroad-grade pocket watches were built to strict accuracy standards and are stamped with jewel counts, usually seventeen, nineteen, or twenty-one. Waltham, Elgin, Hamilton, and Illinois are the names to know, and the movement is worth more than the case in most instances. 

Open the back and read the serial number, which dates the watch precisely through published factory records. Cases marked as gold filled are not solid gold, and confusing the two is the most common estate sale error.

Signed Costume Jewelry

Unsigned costume jewelry is worth its weight in nothing and signed costume jewelry can be worth hundreds. The signature is small and sits on the reverse near a clasp or pin stem, so a loupe or a phone camera in macro mode earns its keep. 

Trifari, Coro, Eisenberg, Weiss, Schiaparelli, and Miriam Haskell are the names worth learning first. Missing rhinestones are replaceable; missing prongs are not.

Bakelite Bangles and Pins

The early phenolic plastic has a density and a warmth that later plastics do not share, and carved or laminated examples sell into the hundreds. The standard field test is friction: rub the piece briskly against a palm until it warms and check for a faint chemical odor. 

Colors darken with age, so what reads as butterscotch was often originally cream. Cracks are common at the inner edge of bangles and drop the value sharply.

Cufflinks

A pair of cufflinks occupies almost no space, appears in nearly every man’s dresser from the mid-twentieth century, and is priced at estate sales as an afterthought. Gold, sterling, and enameled examples all have separate markets, and the mark is usually on the reverse of the toggle. 

Designer and advertising cufflinks have their own collectors independent of metal value. Mismatched singles are worth less but not nothing, since replacements are actively sought.

Tie Clips and Money Clips

The same dresser tray that holds the cufflinks holds the tie bars, and the same pricing indifference applies. Sterling and gold-filled examples from Swank, Hickok, and Anson turn up constantly. 

Advertising and union commemorative pieces have a separate collecting niche tied to the company rather than the metal. Money clips in solid silver carry a straightforward weight-based floor.

Powder Compacts

Enameled and engine-turned metal compacts from the 1920s through the 1950s were made by jewelry firms and are constructed to a jewelry standard. Elgin American, Volupté, and Evans produced figural and novelty designs that now sell well above their original retail. 

The original mirror, puff, and interior sifter screen all affect the grade. Compacts with intact enamel and a working clasp are the ones worth carrying to the table.

Silver Thimbles and Sewing Notions

A sewing basket at an estate sale is priced as a sewing basket, and its contents are frequently worth several times the sticker. Sterling thimbles, mother of pearl needle cases, and silver-handled seam rippers all hide in the bottom layer. 

Look for hallmarks along the rim of a thimble, which is where English makers stamped them. Advertising thimbles in aluminum are worth little, so the metal test comes first.

Buttons on Original Cards

Uncut cards of vintage buttons sell to sewists and to collectors of the graphic design on the card itself. Bakelite, glass, and mother of pearl buttons carry premiums well beyond plastic, and realistic figural buttons from the 1930s and 1940s are their own category. 

A jar of loose buttons is worth sorting rather than buying blind. Complete matched sets in a single material are the strongest sellers.

Hat Pins

Long decorative pins from the Edwardian era were made in sterling, enamel, and art glass, and they were produced in enormous quantities before hats went out of daily use. Length matters to collectors, with anything over eight inches attracting more interest. 

The decorative head is where the value sits, and the pin itself is usually plain steel. Damage to the enamel or a missing stone knocks the price down substantially.

Eyeglass Frames

Vintage frames from the 1950s through the 1970s are bought by opticians and by wearers who want an original rather than a reproduction. Temple arms are stamped with the maker, the country, and often the material, and the mark is tiny. 

Frames marked as gold filled with a karat fraction contain real gold on the surface. Deadstock frames still carrying the original paper tag command a considerable premium over worn examples.

Case and Buck Pocket Knives

American folding knives are dated by the pattern of dots and symbols stamped alongside the maker’s name on the tang, which lets a buyer establish the year of manufacture in seconds. Case in particular changed its stamp annually for decades. 

Blade wear from repeated sharpening is the value killer, since a blade thinned by half is worth a fraction of a full one. Original boxes and unsharpened examples move quickly and at strong prices.

Swiss Army Knives With Older Tang Stamps

The multi-tool knives have been produced continuously for well over a century, and the earlier stamps and discontinued tool configurations attract collectors who ignore the modern ones. Look at the tang for the shield style and at the scales for the cross emblem, both of which changed over time. 

Unusual configurations made for specific professions are the ones worth carrying out. A knife with a snapped tool is worth considerably less, so open every implement before buying.

Flip-Top Lighters

Brass and chrome flip-top lighters carry markings on the base that date them, though the system changed over time: dot and slash patterns used from the mid-1950s give the year alone, and only from 1986 does the code identify the month as well. Anything earlier than the mid-1950s has to be dated from patent text and logo style instead. 

Advertising and military-issue examples sell for far more than plain models. The insert is replaceable and irrelevant to value; the case is everything. 

Engraved presentation pieces with a legible name and date have a documentary appeal that raises the price further.

Pre-1965 United States Silver Coins

Dimes, quarters, and half dollars minted in 1964 and earlier are ninety percent silver, and their metal content alone gives them a floor many times their face value. Estate sales price coin jars as change with striking regularity. 

The date is the only test required, which makes this the fastest sorting job on the list. Genuinely rare dates and mint marks exist within the same jars and are worth a second pass.

Foreign Banknotes and Obsolete Currency

Travel drawers accumulate leftover paper money from decades of trips, and some of it is worth substantially more than its exchange rate ever was. Notes from currencies that no longer exist, from countries that no longer exist, and from periods of hyperinflation all have collectors. 

Condition is graded strictly in this field, and a crisp uncirculated note outperforms a folded one dramatically. The catalog number printed in reference guides is what buyers search by.

Postage Stamps Still on Envelopes

Loose stamps in an album are usually worth very little, while stamps still attached to their original envelope with a legible postmark can be worth a great deal more. The cover, as collectors call it, carries the routing, the date, and sometimes the historical context that gives the item value. 

First day covers, wartime mail, and anything routed through an unusual location are the pieces to look for. Soaking stamps off their envelopes destroys most of that value.

Real Photo Postcards

These are actual photographic prints on postcard stock, produced from the 1900s through the 1940s, and they are distinguishable from printed postcards by the absence of a dot pattern under magnification. Small-town main streets, occupational portraits, disasters, and storefronts with legible signage are the strongest subjects. 

Regional collectors pay well for images of their own county. A box of a thousand postcards is worth twenty dollars on the lid.

Tintypes and Cabinet Cards

Nineteenth century photographs turn up in estate sales in shoeboxes with no context, priced at a dollar apiece. Tintypes are on thin iron and can be tested with a magnet, while cabinet cards are mounted on a stiff board with the studio’s name printed below. 

Occupational portraits showing tools of a trade, and images of identifiable places, carry premiums far above generic portraits. The photographer’s imprint on the mount is worth reading, since some studios have their own following.

Military Medals, Patches, and Insignia

A small box of service items can hold campaign medals, unit insignia, and shoulder patches with well-documented values. Named and numbered medals that can be traced to an individual are worth substantially more than anonymous examples. 

Reproduction insignia is widespread, and the weave and backing material of a patch are the usual tells. Anything connected to a specific unit with a notable service record moves fastest.

Antique Fishing Lures

Wooden plugs from Heddon, Creek Chub, and Pflueger were made from the early 1900s and are identified by the eye hardware, the hook hangers, and the paint scheme. Glass eyes generally indicate earlier production than tack-painted eyes. 

Original cardboard boxes can be worth more than the lure inside them. Tooth marks and chipped paint are expected on a fished lure and are priced in rather than treated as ruinous.

Matchbox Models in Original Boxes

The small British-made cars from the 1950s and 1960s carry a model number on the base along with the maker’s name. The regular wheels era, before the switch to low-friction wheels in 1969, is the period collectors focus on. 

A model in its original printed box is worth a multiple of the same car loose. Paint chipping along the roof edges and axle wear are the standard condition checks.

Lead and Composition Toy Soldiers

Hollow cast lead figures from Britain and composition figures from German makers predate plastic and have a stable collector base. The maker’s name is usually cast into the underside of the base. 

Paint condition drives value more than anything else, and repainted figures are worth substantially less than honest wear. Broken rifles and detached heads are common and repairable, but disclosed rather than hidden.

Programmable Calculators

Hewlett-Packard calculators from the 1970s and 1980s have a following among engineers and collectors that has pushed working examples to prices well above their original cost. The reverse Polish entry system and the machined key feel are what buyers are paying for. 

Corroded battery compartments are the main failure and are sometimes salvageable. The model number on the faceplate determines everything, since the range spans the trivial and the genuinely scarce.

Enamel Pins and Convention Badges

Small enameled pins from theme parks, trade organizations, political campaigns, and fan conventions occupy a shoebox and sell individually online. Limited-edition park pins with edition sizes printed on the back have the most active market. 

The pin back and the maker’s mark on the reverse are what distinguish an official issue from a knockoff. A lidded tin of these is one of the easiest estate sale purchases to justify and one of the slowest to list.

The Economics of the Junk Drawer

The pattern behind every item here is the same. Value and volume came apart somewhere in the twentieth century, and the objects people bothered to store carefully were rarely the ones worth storing carefully. 

A dining table gets appraised because it is visible. A gold nib in a desk caddy does not.

There is a slightly melancholy version of this observation, which is that the small things people carry daily are precisely the things nobody thinks to look at when the house is emptied. The pocket contents outlast the furniture in interest, if not in price per square foot. 

Somebody wound that watch every morning for forty years, and it went into a box marked five dollars.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.