28 Estate Sale Boxes Pickers Open Before Anything Else

The furniture gets photographed for the listing. The boxes do not. At most estate sales the margin sits in unsorted containers that the company priced by the lot because nobody had time to open them.

Experienced buyers move through a house in a fixed order, and it is rarely the order the sale is laid out in. They go where the sorting stopped.

The Sewing Basket

A wicker sewing basket holds the densest concentration of small silver in most houses. Thimbles marked sterling carry real money when the rim engraving is unworn, and Simons Brothers of Philadelphia has been stamping them since 1839, which makes their mark the one to look for first.

The same basket usually turns up mother-of-pearl buttons cut from shell, Bakelite-handled seam rippers, and a boxed set of Greist sewing machine attachments. Lift the top tray before deciding on a price, because these baskets almost always have a second layer nobody opened.

The Desk Drawer Nobody Emptied

Fountain pens outlive the desks they were kept in, and the good ones sit under decades of paper clips. A Parker 51, released in 1941, and a Sheaffer Snorkel from 1952 are the two most common finds worth stopping for, along with Esterbrook models that take interchangeable nib units.

Check whether the nib is marked 14k, whether the cap threads engage cleanly, and whether the barrel shows hairline cracks near the section. Dried ink is fixable; a cracked cap lip is not.

Shoeboxes of Loose Snapshots

Family portraits have almost no resale value, but the photographs taken outside the studio often do. Images of identifiable storefronts, early automobiles with visible plates, and workers posed with the tools of their trade all have collector audiences that pay per image rather than per box.

Tintypes mixed into the pile are worth separating immediately, since they date to the 1860s and 1870s and survive better than paper. Flip a handful over and read the backs for studio imprints and penciled place names.

The Costume Jewelry Bin

Most estate companies dump costume jewelry into one bin and price it by the handful. Signed pieces are the target: the Trifari crown mark, Coro and Corocraft, and Weiss all move quickly.

So does unsigned work by DeLizza and Elster, sold under the trade name Juliana and identified by five-link bracelet construction and open-back rhinestone settings that let light through the stones. Sort by feel first, since heavier pieces are more likely to be sterling from the wartime years when base metals were restricted.

Boxes Marked Christmas

A box marked for the holidays is one of the few containers people rarely re-sort, so what went in during the 1950s is usually still in there. Shiny Brite ornaments, made by Max Eckardt, are the volume item, and the wartime examples with cardboard caps and unsilvered interiors bring more than the postwar ones.

NOMA brought bubble lights to market in 1946, and working strands with intact liquid vials sell on sight. Original printed boxes with the cardboard dividers add more to the lot than the ornaments do individually, so keep them together.

The Toolbox Bottom Tray

The top tray of a toolbox holds screwdrivers. The bottom holds the measuring instruments, and that is where Starrett micrometers, machinist squares, and dial indicators end up.

Stanley chisels and planes from the heart-shaped trademark era, roughly 1920 to 1935, are the other reason to lift the tray out entirely. Rust on a plane sole cleans up, but pitting on a micrometer anvil or a cracked casting kills the piece.

Camera Bags

Camera bags get priced as one unit, which means a body worth twenty dollars can be carrying a lens worth two hundred. Screw-mount Leica bodies, the Nikon F, and Canon rangefinders are the headline finds, but the Super-Takumar 50mm f/1.4 is the sleeper, since its thorium-doped glass yellows with age and buyers know it clears under sustained light.

Hold each lens toward a bright window and look for fungus filaments spreading across the internal elements. Oil on the aperture blades and heavy internal haze both cut the price by half or more.

Boxes of Sheet Music

The value in old sheet music is the cover art, not the notation. Illustrated covers printed before roughly 1930 were done as color lithographs by named artists, and ragtime, aviation, and transportation subjects have the steadiest demand. A single strong cover can carry an entire box.

Check for spine tears at the fold and for brittleness at the edges, since acidic paper from that period crumbles once it has been in a damp basement.

The Junk Drawer

Every house has one drawer that functions as a sediment layer, and it accumulates small metal objects for fifty years. Case pocket knives are the reliable find, and the tang stamp dates them precisely: Case placed dots beneath the XX mark through the 1970s and removed one each year.

Zippo lighters carry bottom stamps that collectors read down to the year of manufacture. Loose sterling flatware pieces, orphaned from their sets, are worth pulling out and weighing separately.

Wooden Lidded Boxes on the Dresser

A wooden trinket box on a dresser is where a man kept the things he wore. Cufflinks by Swank and Hickok, tie bars, class rings marked 10K or 14K, and service medals with their original ribbons all end up in the same six inches of felt.

Read the inside of every ring shank with a loupe, since gold-filled pieces are marked differently and the difference is the entire price. Military insignia carries maker’s marks on the reverse that determine whether it is period issue or a later reproduction.

Fishing Tackle Trays

Tackle boxes are heavy, which discourages casual buyers, and that is exactly why pickers open them. Heddon wooden plugs are the anchor of the category, and glass eyes generally indicate earlier production than painted eyes on the same model.

Pflueger and South Bend lures fill out most trays. Paint chipping and hook rash around the hardware cut value sharply, so the ones still in their cardboard boxes are worth far more than loose examples of the same lure.

Garage Coffee Cans

Coffee cans on garage shelves get treated as containers of fasteners and ignored. They frequently are, but they are also where people stashed things they did not want in the house, including silver coins, small hand tools, and drill bit sets.

Lift each one rather than looking inside, because weight tells you in a second whether the contents are plastic or metal. The cans themselves have value when the printed graphics and the key-wind strip survive intact.

The Linen Closet Shelf

Textiles are bulky and slow to sort, so estate companies price the shelf as one lot. Irish linen tablecloths, Madeira hand embroidery, and hand-tatted lace edging are the pieces that justify the lot. Vera Neumann scarves are the other consistent find, signed in the corner with her name and, from the 1960s onward, a small ladybug beside it.

Open the folds and look for rust stains from metal shelving and for dye transfer where a colored piece sat against a white one, since neither comes out.

Boxes of Postcards

Postcards get sold by the box because sorting them takes hours. Real photo postcards are the ones that matter, and the stamp box on the back dates them: the AZO paper marked with four upward-pointing triangles in the corners runs roughly 1904 to 1918.

Divided backs came in during 1907, which gives a second dating anchor. Identifiable small-town street scenes, storefronts, and disaster documentation outsell scenic views by a wide margin.

Old Luggage

Old suitcases are usually sold cheap because they take up floor space. Look inside the lid for maker plates: Hartmann, Louis Vuitton, and early Samsonite all identified themselves there, often with serial numbers stamped nearby. Steamer trunks with intact interior trays and original paper lining sell as furniture rather than as luggage.

Odor is the one defect that ends the conversation, since a musty lining transfers to anything stored inside and buyers return the piece.

The Nightstand Drawer

Nightstand drawers hold the objects someone used every day and then stopped using. Wristwatches are the main event, with Hamilton, Elgin, and the Bulova Accutron, introduced in 1960 with a tuning-fork movement, all common enough to expect. Turn the case over and read the back, because gold-filled and solid gold cases are marked differently and the price gap is enormous.

Reading glasses in period frames and pocket knives round out most drawers.

Boxes of Vinyl Records

Records get priced by the crate, and the pressing details that determine value are not on the cover. Blue Note issues showing the 47 West 63rd Street address, RCA Living Stereo pressings in the shaded dog label, and Columbia six-eye labels are the pressings to pull.

The matrix numbers scratched into the runout groove confirm the pressing when the label is ambiguous. Tilt each disc under a light for warps and heavy groove wear, since a rare pressing in poor condition brings a fraction of a clean copy.

Sports Card Shoeboxes

Cards printed between 1987 and 1994 were produced in such volume that most of them are worth less than the shoebox. Anything from before 1970 is a different market entirely, and Topps issues from the early 1950s onward are the ones to check card by card.

Centering and corner sharpness drive the grade, and the grade drives the price by multiples. Hold a card at eye level and look at the border widths before anything else.

The Button Tin

A button tin is a cross-section of a century of clothing, and it takes ten minutes to sort. Bakelite buttons are the payoff, and the standard field test is brief immersion in hot water, which releases a distinct phenolic odor that plastic does not produce. Carved shell buttons, cut from mother-of-pearl blanks, are the second tier.

Military uniform buttons carry maker backmarks, and the Waterbury Button Company of Connecticut, in business since 1812, is the name that appears most often.

Bags of Loose Keys

Loose keys look like the definition of worthless, and mostly they are, but three categories inside the bag are not. Bit keys, the long ones with a single flat ward, sell steadily to people restoring furniture and doors.

Padlock keys marked Yale and Towne, clock winding keys in graduated sizes, and small watch keys all have their own buyers. Car keys with embossed manufacturer logos on the head are collected by marque, so spread the bag out and look at the heads rather than the blades.

Shoe Polish and Shine Kits

A wooden shine box with its brushes and tins is worth more assembled than the sum of its parts. The graphics are the draw: polish tins with intact lithographed lids and glass dressing bottles with unfaded paper labels sell as advertising, not as supplies.

Horsehair brushes with stamped wooden backs are the other component buyers want. Check that the footrest is still attached and that the hinges have not rusted through the lid.

The Filing Cabinet

Filing cabinets get skipped because paper looks like paper. Inside them sit stock certificates with engraved vignettes, Series E savings bonds, deeds, and correspondence with intact stamps and cancellations that philatelic buyers want on cover.

The other reason to open the drawers is documentation: original receipts, warranty cards, and manuals that establish the provenance of the furniture and appliances being sold in the next room. That paperwork can add more to a piece than a cleaning would.

Sleeves of Negatives and Slide Carousels

Film gets thrown away first at estate sales because nobody can see what is on it without equipment. Kodachrome slides in carousel trays, medium-format negatives, and glass-plate negatives all carry the same content value as prints and often better resolution.

Open a sleeve and smell it, since acetate film in decay gives off a sharp vinegar odor that signals the emulsion is already shrinking away from the base. Anything that smells clean and lies flat is worth taking.

Hatboxes on the Closet Shelf

Hatboxes sit above eye level and get overlooked at nearly every sale. Inside are men’s felt hats by Stetson and Dobbs with their sweatbands and interior labels intact, and women’s millinery with the trim still attached. The box itself frequently outsells the hat, since department store boxes printed with defunct store names are bought as display pieces.

Press gently on the crown and check the brim edge for splits, because a cracked felt crown cannot be restored.

Bins of Fabric and Notions

Fabric bins are sold by volume and bought by weight, which means the price never reflects what is in them. Feed sack cotton prints, barkcloth yardage from the 1940s and 1950s, and unused wool are the pieces quilters and sewists pay for.

Metal zippers, wooden spools with paper labels, and unopened pattern envelopes all sell separately. Shake out anything folded and look for moth grazing on wool and for shattering on old silk, which splits along the fold lines and cannot be repaired.

Coin Jars and Change Dishes

Change dishes are the fastest profitable sort at any sale. United States dimes, quarters, and half dollars struck in 1964 and earlier are 90 percent silver, and half dollars from 1965 through 1970 are 40 percent silver. Wheat cents run from 1909 to 1958, and the 1943 issues struck in steel stand out immediately because they are gray.

Look at the coin edges rather than the faces, since a solid silver-gray edge separates the silver from the copper-striped clad coins instantly.

Boxes of Paperbacks

Paperbacks are the cheapest box at any sale and occasionally the best one. Ace Doubles, printed head to tail so each novel has its own front cover, are the format collectors chase, along with Dell mapbacks and midcentury pulp titles with strong cover illustration.

First printings are identified by the number line or the publisher’s own code, not by the copyright date. Spine creases, sunned spines, and a clipped price on the cover each knock the value down a tier.

The Basement Shelf of Jars

The jar shelf is dismissed as canning supplies, and most of it is. What is not: Atlas E-Z Seal and Kerr Self Sealing jars in the earlier embossed styles, Drey-marked examples, and anything in amber or cobalt glass rather than clear or aqua.

Zinc lids with intact milk glass liners sell on their own. Run a fingertip around the sealing surface of the rim, since a chip there drops a jar from collectible to decorative in one pass.

What the Sorting Never Reached

Estate sales are priced by the visible and the nameable. A dining set gets researched; a taped box marked with a season does not, and the difference in effort is where the entire business lives.

The containers that stay closed longest are the ones organized by habit rather than by value, which is why a sewing basket and a change dish outperform a curio cabinet more often than anyone expects.

None of this requires expertise so much as sequence. The people who do well at these sales are not identifying rarities on sight; they are opening the things nobody opened, in a consistent order, before the room fills.

The rarity identification happens later, in the car, with the lot already bought.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.