28 Brooches Dealers Pull From Jewelry Lots

A mixed jewelry lot looks like a tangle of chains, orphaned earrings and plastic beads. Experienced dealers ignore most of it and reach straight for the pins.

Brooches carry maker marks on flat backs, hold up better than delicate chains and often turn out to be the most valuable pieces in the pile.

What earns a brooch a spot in the keep pile comes down to a signature, a material or a style that collectors already search for. Condition then decides the price.

Trifari Pins With the Crowned Mark

Trifari was among the leading American costume jewelry houses, and designer Alfred Philippe shaped much of its best work from the 1930s onward. Dealers flip every pin looking for the crowned T above the name, a mark tied to the company’s mid-century output.

Sterling pieces from the 1940s, including the Lucite-bellied animals collectors call jelly bellies, draw the most attention. Missing or replaced stones, worn plating and loose Lucite all cut value, so price depends heavily on condition.

Coro Duettes That Split Into Two Clips

Coro held patents in the early 1930s for the Duette, a frame that let two dress clips join into a single brooch. Dealers recognize the mechanism immediately, and complete sets with both clips and the original frame are the ones worth pulling.

Many examples feature rhinestones and enamel in Art Deco and floral designs. Buyers check that the clips still close firmly and that the frame is not bent.

A Duette missing a clip loses much of its appeal, and value depends on condition.

Eisenberg Original and Eisenberg Ice

Eisenberg began as a Chicago clothing company that pinned sparkling brooches to its dresses, and shoppers wanted the jewelry more than the clothes. Pins marked “Eisenberg Original” from the 1930s and 1940s are the prize, with large, heavy settings and high-quality Austrian crystal.

Later pieces carry the “Eisenberg Ice” name. Dealers check for dark or cloudy stones and loose prongs, since replacements are hard to match.

Resale value depends on condition, and the early signed brooches can bring several hundred dollars.

Unsigned Miriam Haskell Floral Brooches

Miriam Haskell pieces from the early decades often carry no mark at all, which is why dealers study construction instead of backs. Haskell work features hand-wired seed pearls, glass beads and intricate filigree backing, much of it designed by Frank Hess.

A dealer who recognizes the style can pull an unsigned piece from a lot that others overlooked. Missing pearls, broken wires and worn gilt all reduce value, and prices depend on condition, age and whether the attribution holds up.

Marcel Boucher Enameled Birds and Flowers

Marcel Boucher trained at Cartier before opening his own firm in New York in the 1930s, and his brooches show that fine-jewelry discipline. Enameled birds, flowers and insects with crisp detail are the pieces dealers look for.

Many Boucher pins carry inventory numbers stamped on the back, which help identify designs in reference books. Chipped enamel, replaced stones and weak pin catches are common problems.

Prices depend heavily on condition, and the rarer figural designs attract strong collector bids.

Hattie Carnegie Figural Pins

Hattie Carnegie built a fashion empire in New York, and her costume jewelry line produced whimsical figural brooches that collectors still chase. Animals, exotic figures and insects with enamel and colored stones turn up most often.

The Hattie Carnegie signature, often in script or block letters on a small plaque, is the first thing a dealer checks. Worn enamel, missing stones and loose parts reduce value quickly.

The more unusual the figure, the stronger the interest, but condition always sets the final price.

Weiss Rhinestone Brooches

Albert Weiss founded his company in New York in 1942 and became known for rhinestone brooches with rich color and heavy sparkle. Weiss pins often include aurora borealis stones, which have a rainbow coating that flashes under light.

A signed back comes first, followed by a hard look for dark stones whose foil has failed. Floral sprays, bugs and Christmas designs are common finds.

Resale value depends on condition, since dull or replaced stones make a big difference.

DeLizza and Elster Pieces Sold as Juliana

DeLizza and Elster produced jewelry in New York that was rarely signed, and collectors now call much of it Juliana after a paper tag the company used for a short period. Dealers identify these brooches by construction, including open backs, specific stone shapes and a distinctive way of linking parts.

Reference guides and collector groups help confirm attributions. Missing stones and bent settings are common.

Prices depend on condition and confirmation, and a correctly identified piece can bring far more than an unsigned lookalike.

Schreiner Brooches With Inverted Stones

Schreiner of New York made some of the most unusual costume jewelry of the mid-twentieth century, often setting stones upside down so their points faced outward. The effect gives the pieces a spiky, textured look that is easy to spot in a lot.

Many Schreiner pins are unsigned, so dealers rely on construction and the inverted stones. Missing or cracked stones and loose prongs are common issues.

Value depends on condition, and larger pieces in strong colors draw serious buyers.

Taxco Silver Pins With Eagle Marks

Mexican silver from Taxco carries a strong following, and brooches from the mid-twentieth century are a regular find in mixed lots. Many pieces from roughly 1948 to 1980 carry an eagle assay mark with a number identifying the workshop.

That mark, along with names like William Spratling, Los Castillo and Margot de Taxco, tells a dealer the pin is worth a closer look. Bent pin stems and worn inlay are common problems.

Prices depend on condition, maker and design, and signed pieces from known workshops sell strongly.

Georg Jensen Silver Brooches

Georg Jensen, the Danish silversmith, founded his workshop in Copenhagen in 1904, and his brooches remain among the most sought-after silver pins. Designs often feature leaves, birds and flowing Art Nouveau lines.

Dealers look for the Georg Jensen mark, a design number and sterling or 925 stamps. Wear on the silver and bent pins affect value, but polishing too hard can damage detail.

Resale value depends on condition and design, and early pieces can bring high prices.

David-Andersen Enamel Leaf Pins

David-Andersen, a Norwegian silver firm, produced guilloche enamel brooches in the mid-twentieth century that remain popular with collectors. Leaf shapes, butterflies and flowers in bright enamel over sterling or gilded silver are the classic designs.

Dealers check for the David-Andersen mark and look closely for chips or cracks in the enamel, which are costly to repair. Scandinavian enamel from other makers turns up too, but the signed pieces sell best.

Value depends heavily on enamel condition.

Carved Bakelite Brooches

Bakelite, an early plastic, was used in colorful carved brooches during the 1930s and 1940s. Dealers test pieces with hot water or a commercial polish, since genuine Bakelite gives off a chemical smell and the polish often turns yellow.

Carved flowers, fruit and animals in bold colors are the most sought after. Cracks, chips and repairs lower value, and fakes are common.

Prices depend on condition, carving depth and color, and figural pieces can bring strong prices.

Victorian Mourning Brooches

Mourning jewelry boomed after Prince Albert died in 1861, and Queen Victoria’s long grief set the fashion for decades. Brooches from the period often hold a lock of braided hair under glass or use jet, black enamel and dark stones.

Whitby jet, mined on the Yorkshire coast, feels warm and light in the hand, while the black glass sold as French jet feels cold and heavy. Cracked crystals, missing hair and replaced pin stems all cut value, so condition and any engraved names or dates drive the price.

Shell Cameos From Torre del Greco

Cameos turn up in nearly every estate lot, and dealers sort them fast by material. Shell cameos, many carved in Torre del Greco near Naples, are the most common, while hardstone and lava examples tend to bring more.

Molded plastic and glass copies show no tool marks and often have a seam, so a loupe settles most questions. A buyer holds a shell cameo up to light to check for cracks.

Carving quality, frame metal and damage all matter, and price follows condition closely.

Scottish Agate and Cairngorm Brooches

Scottish pebble jewelry took off in the Victorian era, helped along by the royal family’s fondness for Balmoral. Brooches set polished agates, jasper and bloodstone into engraved silver, often in the shape of dirks, knots, shields and circles, and many center on a smoky or golden quartz known as a cairngorm.

Dealers press each stone gently to find loose or glued inlay. Cracked or replaced stones are common and costly.

Many pieces carry no marks at all, so value rests on condition, workmanship and stone quality.

Karat Gold Brooches

Brooches marked 10K, 14K or 18K are pulled from every lot, since the gold content alone sets a minimum value. Dealers test questionable pieces and weigh them to calculate scrap value.

Many karat gold pins from the mid-twentieth century are also well-designed pieces worth more than melt. Missing stones and bent pins affect resale, but they do not change the gold content.

Price depends on weight, design and condition, and signed gold brooches can bring premiums.

Studio Silver by Ed Wiener, Sam Kramer and Art Smith

Greenwich Village studio jewelers of the 1940s and 1950s made silver brooches that look closer to sculpture than to costume jewelry. Ed Wiener favored bold abstract shapes, Sam Kramer added glass eyes and odd stones to surreal forms, and Art Smith worked in large, sweeping curves inspired by dance and African art.

Their pieces usually carry a stamped name or studio mark, which dealers confirm before paying up. Scratches are expected, but a bent or cracked form hurts. Value depends on the maker, the design and condition.

Kenneth Jay Lane Statement Pins

Kenneth Jay Lane launched his costume jewelry line in the 1960s and built it on the idea that fake stones could be worn with total confidence. His brooches lean toward big faux gems, enamel animals and pieces inspired by Indian and Byzantine designs.

Early work is often stamped K.J.L., later pieces read Kenneth Lane, and a line sold through Avon carries his initials too. Dealers sort by mark, since the early pieces draw the most interest.

Missing stones and worn gold tone lower the price.

Stanley Hagler Hand-Wired Brooches

Stanley Hagler built his reputation on hand-wired floral brooches crowded with glass beads, seed pearls and tiny flowers on filigree backing. The work often draws comparisons to Miriam Haskell, but Hagler pieces tend to be larger and more colorful.

Dealers look for the oval plaque reading Stanley Hagler N.Y.C., and later pieces made by his longtime designer Ian St. Gielar carry similar marks. Repairs are difficult, so every missing bead or snapped wire counts.

Big, dense brooches bring the most, and condition sets the ceiling.

Czechoslovakian Glass Brooches

A stamp reading “Czechoslovakia” on the back of a brooch helps date it, since the country used that name from 1918 until the split at the close of 1992. Pieces from the Art Deco years often combine faceted glass stones in vivid colors with brass filigree settings. Dealers look for bright, unscratched glass and settings that have not darkened too heavily.

Large center stones in blue, green or amber draw the most interest. Missing or cloudy stones pull the price down, so condition drives value.

Signed Christmas Tree Pins

Christmas tree brooches fill holiday jewelry lots, and most are inexpensive and unsigned. Dealers pick through them for names such as Eisenberg, Stanley Hagler and Hollycraft, whose trees bring noticeably more.

Some Hollycraft jewelry from the 1950s carries a year stamped beside the company name, which makes dating easy. Buyers count the stones on every tree, since a few gaps can halve the appeal, and check for worn gold tone on the branches.

Demand peaks in the fall, and condition still sets the price.

World War Two Sweetheart Pins

Sweetheart pins let families show that a husband, son or boyfriend was serving during World War Two. Many are small brooches with branch insignia, wings, anchors or eagles in sterling, gold-filled metal, enamel or plastic, and some use mother-of-pearl.

Dealers look for clear branch markings and sterling stamps, since those pieces sell to both jewelry buyers and military collectors. Bent pin stems and worn enamel are common.

Price depends on material, branch and condition, and unusual designs draw the strongest interest.

Rebajes Copper Brooches

Frank Rebajes, a Dominican-born artist, sold hand-formed copper jewelry from a New York shop beginning in the 1930s and remained active into the 1960s. His brooches feature masks, animals, leaves and abstract forms in a simple, graphic style.

Dealers look for the Rebajes signature stamped on the back. A warm, even patina is often welcome, but heavy verdigris, deep scratches and bent pins lower value.

Larger figural pieces sell best, and condition plays a big role in what a buyer will pay.

Theodor Fahrner Marcasite Brooches

Theodor Fahrner’s firm in Pforzheim, Germany, made silver jewelry that ranged from Jugendstil designs to crisp Art Deco pieces set with marcasite, enamel and colored stones. Many brooches carry a TF mark inside a circle, and later pieces may read Original Fahrner.

Dealers check that mark first, then count the tiny marcasites, which fall out easily and are hard to replace well. Chipped enamel and bent pins reduce value. Signed Art Deco examples in good condition can bring prices well above ordinary marcasite pins.

Lea Stein Layered Acetate Animals

French designer Lea Stein began making jewelry from layered cellulose acetate in 1969, and her playful animal brooches now have a devoted following. The fox known as Goupil is her most recognized design, alongside cats, birds and other figures.

Genuine pieces carry a pin back marked Lea Stein Paris, which dealers check before anything else, since imitations exist. Cracks, chips and delamination between layers lower value.

Price depends on condition, design and color, and rare figures draw bids from dedicated collectors.

Chanel CC Logo Brooches

A Chanel brooch with the interlocking CC logo is one of the most valuable things a dealer can pull from a mixed lot, and one of the most faked. Authentic pieces carry an oval plaque or stamp, and many from the 1990s onward include a season code made of a two-digit year and a letter.

Dealers check that code, the weight and the quality of the plating and stone settings. Missing stones, worn gold tone and peeling faux pearls lower value, and authentication and condition set the price.

Italian Micromosaic Brooches

Micromosaic brooches pack hundreds of tiny glass pieces into scenes of Roman ruins, birds and flowers, and many were sold to travelers on the Grand Tour in the nineteenth century. The finest examples use extremely small tesserae that look like painting from a short distance.

Dealers study the mosaic under magnification to spot missing pieces, cracks and filler. Gold or silver frames add value, while gilt metal and later tourist pieces bring less.

Condition, detail and age drive the price.

Why the Pin Gets Picked First

A mixed jewelry lot rewards the buyer who knows where to look. Brooches offer more clues than almost anything else in the pile, with flat backs that hold signatures, patent numbers and silver marks.

They also survive decades of storage better than fine chains. That combination makes them the first stop for dealers who have to decide quickly.

A great name still cannot rescue a damaged piece. Missing stones, replaced stones, bent pin stems and broken clasps can cut a brooch’s value in half or worse.

The pieces that pay combine a known maker with careful ownership. Dealers pull them first because the pin has already done the talking.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.