27 Pie Plates and Bakeware Collectors Chase

Baking forms outlast the bakers. A pie plate gets thrown out only when it cracks, and a cast iron gem pan effectively never does, which is why nineteenth-century muffin pans still surface at estate sales priced like scrap metal.

Collectors noticed some time ago.

Condition drives everything in this corner of the market. A chip on a rim, the milky haze that forty years of dishwasher detergent leaves on glass, a crack between two gem cups, or a missing springform clip can cut a piece to a fraction of what a clean example brings.

Pyrex Clear Pie Plate No. 209

Corning’s plain nine-inch pie plate is the most common piece of vintage bakeware in America, and it still moves at roughly eight to twenty dollars in clean condition. The value hides in the base stamp rather than the shape.

Corning had already shifted its clear ovenware to tempered soda-lime glass by the late 1940s, which makes the widely repeated claim that the change came in the late 1990s wrong, so what actually separates two plates is the stamp and the surface, and one with crisp raised lettering and no dishwasher haze outsells a cloudy example several times over.

Heavy crazing does not occur in glass, but fine scratching from decades of knife work does, and it permanently dulls the surface.

Pyrex Flavor Saver Pie Plate No. 229

The 229 is the deep one, running about nine and a half inches across with a scalloped, fluted rim and two small tab handles that were meant to catch overflowing fruit juice. Corning marketed it under the Flavor Saver name, and the rim is the entire reason collectors want it, since it gives an ordinary pie a finished pastry edge without crimping.

Clean examples commonly sell in the fifteen to forty dollar range, with chipped flutes dropping a plate to nearly nothing. Count the scallops before buying, because a single cracked point is easy to miss under kitchen lighting.

Fire-King Philbe Sapphire Blue Pie Plate

Anchor Hocking produced transparent cobalt-tinted ovenware through the 1940s under the Philbe pattern name, better known to collectors simply as Sapphire Blue. The same glass batch went into measuring cups, nursing bottles, and loaf pans, so the pie plates are often reunited with matching pieces at shows.

Expect roughly twelve to thirty-five dollars for an unchipped plate, more if the raised lettering on the base is sharp. The blue reads almost gray under fluorescent store lighting and only shows its true color held against a window, which is how experienced buyers check it.

Fire-King Jade-ite Pie Plates

Anchor Hocking produced opaque green Jade-ite ovenware under the Fire-King name from the 1940s into the 1970s, and a period pie plate in clean condition brings roughly forty to a hundred and twenty dollars depending on wear. The trap is a reproduction rather than a fake.

Anchor Hocking issued a Fire-King 2000 line in the year 2000, made in Brazil and marked with that designation, and those pieces regularly appear in listings described as mid-century by sellers who never turned the plate over. Utensil marks show badly on opaque green, and a plate scarred by decades of metal pie servers loses most of its premium.

Glasbake Pie Plates by McKee

Glasbake was the ovenware brand of the McKee Glass Company of Jeannette, Pennsylvania, and the name outlived its originator, since McKee became a division of Thatcher Glass in 1951 and the Jeannette plant passed to Jeannette Glass in 1961, which kept the line running. Plates carry a raised GLASBAKE mark plus a model code such as J-235, which is how collectors date and match pieces.

Values sit modestly at ten to thirty dollars for undamaged clear examples, though opaque white and colored versions climb higher. The glass is noticeably thinner than Pyrex of the same era, which makes chipped rims far more common and clean survivors correspondingly scarcer.

Pyrex Bake-a-Round Glass Bread Tube

Corning sold this cylindrical glass tube through the 1970s so home bakers could produce round-sliced sandwich loaves. It came as a system: the borosilicate cylinder, a wire cradle for the oven, vented end caps, and a cloth sling for lowering dough in.

Complete sets with the box and all the hardware bring roughly thirty to ninety dollars, while an orphaned tube with no cradle is worth a fraction of that. The cradle is the piece that goes missing, since it looks like scrap wire and gets discarded when a kitchen is cleared out.

Nordic Ware Original Bundt Pan

H. David Dalquist developed the fluted cast aluminum pan in Minneapolis around 1950 after members of a local Hadassah chapter asked for something like the heavy ceramic Kugelhopf forms their families had used in Europe. It sold poorly for the better part of sixteen years.

A cake baked in one placed second at the 1966 Pillsbury Bake-Off, and demand became so intense that the pan turned into a fixture of American kitchens. Early examples are noticeably heavier than current production and often carry a Minneapolis marking on the underside.

Clean vintage pans trade in the twenty-five to ninety dollar range.

Mirro Two-Piece Angel Food Pan

The Aluminum Goods Manufacturing Company of Manitowoc, Wisconsin, later renamed Mirro, turned out these ten-inch tube pans by the million, stamped on the base with codes such as 5394M. The removable base and the three small feet rising above the rim are the details that matter, since an angel food cake must cool upside down and those feet hold the inverted pan clear of the counter.

Pans with intact feet and no dents bring about twelve to thirty-five dollars. Anodized darkening is normal, but a pan scrubbed to bare bright aluminum has lost its baking surface.

Ovenex Starburst Pans by Ekco

Ekco’s Ovenex line used pressed steel embossed with a radiating starburst or waffle texture across the baking surface, a pattern that reduced contact between dough and metal and gave loaves a distinctive dimpled crust. Model codes such as N34 appear on the underside.

Muffin pans, loaf pans, and rectangular sheets from the 1930s and 1940s sell in the fifteen to forty-five dollar range with the tin plating intact. Rust is the killer here, because the embossing traps moisture in every dimple and a neglected pan pits in exactly the places that make it worth owning.

Griswold No. 10 Muffin Pan

Griswold of Erie, Pennsylvania, made roughly fifty gem pan designs, and the No. 10 in pattern number 948 is the workhorse: eleven tapered, flat-bottomed round cups, documented in more than a dozen casting variations. Clean examples bring about sixty to two hundred dollars, with the scarcer variations well above that.

Run a fingertip along the webbing between cups before buying, since thermal shock cracks originate there and are nearly invisible under seasoning. A cracked gem pan is decoration, not bakeware, and the price should reflect that.

Griswold Turk’s Head Gem Pans

Patterns 13, 14, and 20 produced the swirled, turban-shaped cups that give these pans their name, and they are among the forms collectors pursue hardest. The spiral flutes cast crisply only in a well-maintained mold, so early strikes show sharp ridges while late ones look soft and rounded.

Condition-dependent prices commonly run from about a hundred and fifty dollars into the several hundreds for sharp, crack-free examples. Nickel-plated and chromed versions exist too, and a plated pan with its finish largely intact is considerably harder to find than the bare iron.

Wagner Little Gem Pans

Wagner Manufacturing of Sidney, Ohio, used letters and catalog numbers rather than Griswold’s simple numerals, and the Little Gem pans under catalog numbers 1320 and 466 came in nine-cup and twelve-cup arrangements. They are lighter than the Griswold equivalents, which collectors read as a sign of the later, thinner casting practice at Sidney.

Prices generally fall between seventy and two hundred dollars for clean iron. The maker’s mark placement shifted over the production run, so a pan with the marking inside the handle rather than on the back can be dated more narrowly than most buyers realize.

Wagner Corn Stick Pans in Three Sizes

Corn stick pans came from Sidney in catalog numbers 1317 through 1319, offered as tea, senior, and junior sizes, and assembling all three is a common collecting goal. Each cup is cast as an ear of corn with kernel detail, and the sharpness of those kernels is the single best indicator of how early in a mold’s life the pan was poured.

Figure forty to a hundred and fifty dollars apiece in clean condition. Preheating the empty pan in the oven before the batter goes in is what produces the crisp shell, a step almost every modern recipe omits.

Kaiser Backform Springform Pans

German-made Kaiser springforms, including the Noblesse line, turn up constantly in American kitchens because they came home in suitcases for decades. Many were sold with more than one base, typically a flat disc and a fluted tube insert, and the value collapses when those extras go missing.

Complete vintage sets run roughly twenty to sixty dollars. Check the latch under tension rather than loose, since a spring that no longer draws the collar tight will leak batter, and replacement clips for discontinued models are essentially unobtainable.

Rehrucken Almond Cake Molds

A Rehrucken mold is a ribbed half-cylinder trough, usually tinned steel or tinned copper, made for the German almond cake of the same name that translates roughly as saddle of venison. The finished cake gets studded with slivered almonds so it resembles a larded roast, which is a piece of eighteenth-century table theater that survived into the modern bakery.

Antique examples with sound tin linings sell in the thirty to ninety dollar range. Worn linings can be professionally re-tinned, though the cost often exceeds the mold’s value.

Kugelhopf Molds from Soufflenheim

The Alsatian pottery village of Soufflenheim has produced glazed earthenware Kugelhopf forms for generations, with spiraling fluted walls around a central chimney and hand-painted decoration on the outside. Older pieces show a warmer, less even glaze than current production and often carry an incised potter’s name.

Expect roughly forty to a hundred and twenty dollars depending on size and condition. These need soaking in water before first use so the porous clay does not pull moisture from the dough, and a mold that was never soaked usually shows a scorched interior.

Gobel Madeleine Pans

Gobel has made tinned steel baking forms in France since the late nineteenth century, and its twelve-shell madeleine pans are the reference example of the type. The shell impressions are shallow and precisely ridged, which matters because the characteristic hump on a madeleine depends on batter hitting a cold, buttered, well-defined depression.

Vintage pans bring about twenty to sixty dollars with their tinning unbroken. Never put one in a dishwasher, since detergent attacks the tin and a stripped pan rusts within weeks, a lesson most secondhand buyers learn exactly once.

Benham and Froud Copper Jelly Molds

The London firm of Benham and Froud stamped its name and a pattern number into the rim of its copper molds through the Victorian era, and those marks are the difference between a decorative copper form and a collected one. Interiors were tin-lined for safety, since bare copper reacts with acidic fruit preparations.

Marked examples in sound condition commonly run from about a hundred and fifty dollars to well past five hundred. The firm’s metalwork is associated with the designer Christopher Dresser, which pulls certain pieces into the design market and away from kitchen collectors entirely.

Victorian Tinned Steel Jelly Molds

Pressed tin molds cost a fraction of their copper equivalents and carry most of the same architectural charm: fluted columns, castle turrets, stepped domes, and fish forms. Many were stamped with a maker’s name or a size number on the base flange.

Sound examples change hands at roughly twenty-five to eighty dollars. Tin fails from the inside, so hold a mold up to a lamp and look for pinprick perforations where rust has eaten through, because a mold that leaks setting jelly is worth only what a shelf ornament is worth.

Yellowware Pudding Molds

Yellowware molds turned out of buff-firing clay under a clear lead glaze were kitchen equipment from roughly the 1840s into the early 1900s, made in both England and the American Midwest. Turk’s cap swirls and ear-of-corn patterns are the forms most often chased.

Prices commonly run sixty to two hundred and fifty dollars, driven by pattern sharpness rather than size. Crazing in the glaze is nearly universal and is tolerated, but staining that has migrated through the crazing into the clay body is not, and it cannot be cleaned out.

Rockingham-Glazed Bennington Molds

The mottled brown Rockingham glaze that collectors call Bennington was produced by the United States Pottery Company in Bennington, Vermont, in the 1840s and 1850s, and by a great many other potteries that never went near Vermont. Treat the name as a glaze style unless a piece carries an actual mark.

Unmarked pudding molds in good condition bring roughly seventy-five to three hundred dollars, and documented marked examples multiply that. The glaze pools darkest in the deepest flutes, so a mold that reads evenly brown overall has usually been refired or is a later reproduction.

Pennsylvania Redware Pie Plates

Lead-glazed red earthenware pie plates made by Pennsylvania German potters between the 1780s and the 1860s are the aristocracy of this field. The rims were crimped with a toothed coggle wheel, and the better plates carry yellow slip trailed across the surface in lines, tulips, or dates.

Simple slip-decorated examples run into the hundreds, while sgraffito plates with figures or inscriptions reach into the thousands at auction. Genuine wear shows as knife scarring in concentric arcs across the floor of the plate, which reproductions almost never bother to imitate.

British Ironstone Pie Plates

Deep, straight-sided white ironstone pie dishes were made in quantity by British potteries including R. Cochran and Company of Glasgow, whose Britannia Pottery mark appears on the underside of many surviving pieces. The body is dense and heavy, and it holds oven heat far longer than thin modern ceramics, which is why bakers still buy them to use rather than display.

Sound plates sell in the thirty to hundred dollar range. Hairline cracks running from the rim are the usual flaw, and they spread once a dish goes back into a hot oven.

Advertising Pie Plates from Regional Bakeries

Commercial bakeries sold pies in stamped tin plates carrying their own names, often with a deposit refunded when the plate came back. Mrs. Smith’s of Pennsylvania used plates marked Mello-Rich, and Table Talk of Worcester, Massachusetts, stamped its name across the base of thousands more.

Individual plates are cheap, usually five to twenty-five dollars, which makes this the entry point for anyone building a collection on a small budget. Regional bakeries that closed decades ago command the premium, and the deposit wording pressed into the rim helps date a plate to within a decade or so.

Pie Birds and Pie Funnels

A pie funnel is a small ceramic cone set in the middle of a double-crust pie to support the pastry and carry steam out through its opening. Plain white Victorian funnels are the earliest common form, and the novelty figures came later, with the English firm Nutbrown among the makers of the familiar blackbird versions from roughly the 1950s onward.

Plain funnels sell for fifteen to thirty dollars, while scarce figural models reach well past a hundred. Reproductions are abundant, so check for genuine glaze wear inside the steam vents.

Springerle Rolling Pins

Springerle pins are carved with grids of small intaglio panels that press anise cookie dough into raised pictures, and antique German and Swiss examples in fruitwood are the ones collectors want. Hand-carved pins show slight irregularities between panels that machine-cut later versions lack.

Prices range widely, roughly eighty dollars for a worn common pin up to several hundred for a deeply carved early one with an intact handle assembly. Never wash one, since water swells the end grain and blurs the carving permanently, and a single soaking can destroy a two-hundred-year-old pin.

Brown Bag Cookie Art Shortbread Molds

Hill Design produced stoneware shortbread and cookie molds in New Hampshire under the Brown Bag Cookie Art name through the 1980s and 1990s, each one dated in the clay along with the design. Peter Rabbit from 1988 and the Nutcracker from 1991 are among the patterns people actively pursue.

Most sell in the fifteen to sixty dollar range, with retired designs bringing more. The dating is the useful part for buyers, since a mold with its year impressed on the reverse cannot be passed off as an antique, and the market for them is honest about being recent.

The Shapes That Outlived the Recipes

Very few people now bake a Rehrucken, set a jelly in a copper turret, or press anise dough with a carved fruitwood pin. The forms survived anyway, because a tinned steel trough and a cast iron gem pan are nearly indestructible objects with no obvious reason to be discarded.

What collectors are buying is a record of what kitchens once did every week.

The market rewards exactly the pieces that were used least. A crisp Turk’s head pan, an unscratched Pyrex plate, a springform with both of its bases, a redware dish that somehow escaped the knife: each one is worth what it is because somebody put it in a cupboard and mostly left it there.

The best-preserved bakeware is the bakeware that failed at its job.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.