27 Old Tin Signs and Advertising Pieces Pickers Pull From Barns and Garages
Barn walls have always doubled as storage. Farmers nailed old porcelain signs over drafty gaps, garages used them as shelf backs, and plenty of feed store thermometers simply stayed on the post where a salesman hung them in 1952.
Those afterthoughts now drive one of the steadiest corners of the antique market. Gas station collectors, soda fans and country store specialists all compete for the same rusty rectangles, and a sign that spent decades facing a barn wall instead of the weather can arrive looking almost new.
Sinclair Dinosaur Porcelain Signs

Sinclair put a green brontosaurus to work in the early 1930s, and the dinosaur became one of the most recognizable figures along American highways. Porcelain station signs from the 1950s, including double-sided versions that hung from tall posts, are the pieces pickers hope to spot behind a tractor.
Chips around the mounting points are expected, but large losses across the dinosaur itself pull the price down sharply. A clean, glossy double-sided Sinclair dino sign brings anywhere from about 2,000 to more than 6,000 dollars depending on size, while faded or heavily chipped examples sell for a fraction of that.
Mobilgas Pegasus Shields and Discs

Socony-Vacuum, the forerunner of Mobil, adopted the flying red horse as its trademark in the early 1930s, and the Pegasus spread across thousands of service stations. Porcelain shields reading Mobilgas, along with large Pegasus discs, turn up in farm sheds where old dealers stored them after a rebrand.
A sharp small shield has brought around 800 to 1,500 dollars, and big discs climb much higher. Gloss is everything with these signs, because the red horse fades and the white field shows every chip and rust bloom.
Reproductions are everywhere, so collectors look for real porcelain layers, a slight ripple in the surface and period grommets.
Texaco Star Signs With Date Stamps

Texaco porcelain is unusually friendly to researchers because many signs were stamped with a date along the lower edge. A round Texaco star sign marked 1958 or a lube sign dated in the 1940s can be placed precisely, which reassures collectors wary of fakes.
The red star and green T layered on white show chips easily, and a sign with fresh-looking color and minimal edge loss sells far better than one with pitting. Mid-sized Texaco porcelain usually brings a few hundred to a couple thousand dollars.
Six-foot station signs are another matter, since they are hard to move and store, so the smaller wall pieces often see more competition.
Gulf Orange Disc Signs

Few logos read from a distance like the Gulf orange disc, and that bold simplicity is exactly why decorators and petroliana collectors fight over it. Porcelain Gulf signs came in a range of sizes, from small pump plates to large double-sided station discs.
Orange porcelain fades toward a dull peach after years of sun, so a disc that kept its punch is worth noticeably more. Edge chips and rust around the bolt points are normal, though a deep chip through the lettering is a real deduction.
Smaller Gulf porcelain has brought roughly 400 to 1,200 dollars, and large clean discs go well past that.
Red Crown Gasoline Signs From Standard Oil

Standard Oil of Indiana sold its gasoline under the Red Crown name, and the crown image appeared on porcelain signs, globes and pump plates across the Midwest. These pieces show up regularly in rural Illinois, Iowa and Indiana outbuildings, sometimes still screwed to a barn door.
Collectors grade them on gloss, color and how much of the red crown remains intact, since chips through the crown hurt more than chips along a border. Depending on size and condition, a Red Crown porcelain sign brings anywhere from several hundred dollars to a few thousand.
Fakes are common enough that period mounting hardware and honest wear patterns get a hard look before any money changes hands.
Mobiloil Gargoyle Signs

Before the Pegasus took over, Vacuum Oil marketed its Mobiloil lubricants with a red gargoyle, a strange and memorable mascot that collectors love. Gargoyle signs in tin and porcelain hung in garages and implement dealers from the early twentieth century into the 1930s.
Because they are older than most station signage, many have rust creeping in from the edges, scratches from years of handling and faded red. A decent Gargoyle sign brings several hundred dollars, while crisp porcelain versions in strong condition have sold well into four figures.
Complete examples with clear lettering are scarce, and the odd, grinning mascot keeps pulling in people who never cared about motor oil.
Pennzoil Bell Signs

Pennzoil built its brand around a Liberty Bell image, and its yellow signs topped by the bell were standard equipment at garages for decades. Tin versions turn up more often than porcelain, and both kinds were commonly reused as patches on sheds and chicken coops.
That rough second life means many have nail punctures, bends or paint loss. An average tin Pennzoil sign brings around 150 to 400 dollars, and porcelain bell signs with good gloss reach higher figures. Collectors forgive a little honest wear on the tin examples but expect much better surfaces on porcelain, where a patched or touched-up face is a dealbreaker for many.
Coca-Cola Porcelain Button Signs

The round red Coca-Cola button became a fixture on store fronts in the 1950s, typically in sizes from about 24 inches up to 48 inches across. The design was simple, a red disc with the script logo, sometimes with a bottle added, and stores mounted them high above doors.
Coca-Cola is one of the most reproduced brands in the hobby, so weight, porcelain thickness and the maker marks along the edge get close inspection. A genuine 24-inch button in good condition has brought roughly 500 to 1,200 dollars, with larger and cleaner examples priced above that.
Chips in the script and faded red cut value fast, and a heavy repaint usually ends serious interest.
Prestone Antifreeze Thermometers

Prestone handed out porcelain thermometers to service stations by the thousands, and they were made to be bolted outdoors where customers would see them every cold morning. Their tall porcelain bodies featured the Prestone name above a long scale, and many still hang inside old garages.
The glass tube and its clips are the weak point, because a missing or broken tube lowers interest considerably. A Prestone thermometer with an intact tube and bright color usually brings around 150 to 450 dollars, with mint examples doing better.
Collectors also look closely at chipping along the curved top and bottom, where years of ladders and car doors left their marks.
Dr Pepper 10-2-4 Signs

Dr Pepper encouraged drinkers to have a soda at 10, 2 and 4 o’clock, and the 10-2-4 clock face became part of its advertising through the middle of the twentieth century. Signs, thermometers and bottle cap shapes bearing that slogan are prime finds in Texas and across the South.
The die-cut versions, including a hand holding a bottle, draw the most competition. Fading in the red, scratches across the logo and rust spreading from mounting points all matter when pricing.
Small tin 10-2-4 signs have brought around 200 to 500 dollars, while large porcelain cap signs move into four figures in strong condition.
Pepsi-Cola Double-Dot Signs

Older Pepsi signs use a script logo with two dots between Pepsi and Cola, a style the company dropped around 1951. That detail makes double-dot signs easy to date as earlier than single-dot ones, and collectors pay accordingly.
A clean double-dot Pepsi sign has brought several hundred dollars, and rare shapes or large porcelain versions push past 1,000 dollars. Tin and porcelain versions both exist, often with the red script set on a cream or yellow background.
Surface rust and fading are common on tin examples pulled from barns, while porcelain ones tend to show edge chips instead.
Two-Sided Soda Flange Signs

Flange signs stick out from a wall at a right angle so passing drivers could read them from either direction, and soda brands like NuGrape and Hires Root Beer used them heavily. Because the flange folds over and attaches with screws, the bend often cracks the porcelain or rusts through on tin versions.
Both sides must be judged, and a sign with one great face and one ruined face prices much closer to the weaker side. Flanges also attract decorators because they display well in kitchens and garages.
Good examples generally bring 300 to 1,000 dollars depending on brand and condition.
Rainbo Bread Screen Door Push Bars

Long before automatic doors, bakeries and soda companies paid to put their names on the push bars across grocery store screen doors. Rainbo Bread push bars, often in porcelain with bright lettering, are among the most common and recognizable examples from the 1940s and 1950s.
Because hands pressed against them all day, wear tends to be concentrated in the middle, and collectors watch for scratches, chips and missing brackets there. A Rainbo push bar in solid shape has brought roughly 100 to 300 dollars, which keeps them within reach for new collectors.
Double-sided versions add interest, since the shopper leaving the store saw an ad too.
Salada Tea Door Push Plates

Vertical push plates were mounted on wooden store doors at hand height, and tea companies like Salada used them to remind shoppers on the way in. Porcelain Salada plates are small, usually narrow rectangles, which makes them easy to overlook in a box of garage odds and ends.
Condition depends heavily on whether the screw openings have chipped outward, and on how much rubbing the center took from years of traffic. Bright color and sharp lettering earn a premium.
Most Salada door push plates bring around 100 to 250 dollars, with near-mint examples placed at the upper end.
DeKalb Flying Ear Seed Corn Signs

DeKalb Agricultural Association of Illinois marked its dealers with the winged ear of corn, one of the best-known logos in farm advertising. Embossed tin versions in several sizes, plus some on Masonite, were nailed to fence posts and barn sides across the corn belt.
The signs face left or right, and many collectors try to assemble matched pairs. A tin DeKalb sign in decent shape brings about 200 to 600 dollars, and new old stock examples with crisp color go higher.
Weather has hit most survivors hard, so pickers grade them by fading, edge rust and the condition of the embossed wing.
Purina Checkerboard Signs

Ralston Purina marked its feed with a red and white checkerboard, and the pattern wrapped dealer signs, store displays and thermometers across rural America. Purina Chows signs were often hung on feed mill walls where dust and moisture did steady damage over decades.
Faded reds turning pink, rust under paint and bent corners are the usual issues. The checkerboard pattern makes even a weathered sign attractive to decorators, but collectors save their money for strong color.
Small tin Purina signs bring around 100 to 300 dollars, while large porcelain dealer signs with bright checks have brought well over 1,000 dollars.
John Deere Dealer Signs

John Deere dealer signage carries the leaping deer trademark, and the deer design changed several times over the twentieth century, helping collectors place a sign in its era. Older dealer signs in tin, porcelain and lighted versions are pulled from implement shops and farm sales every year.
Because Deere collectors are so devoted, competition is intense even for weathered pieces. A modest tin John Deere sign brings a few hundred dollars, and large older porcelain dealer signs have brought several thousand.
Fading in the green and yellow, missing frames on lighted signs and rust along seams all chip away at those numbers.
Pam Lighted Advertising Clocks

The Pam Clock Company of New Rochelle, New York, built lighted advertising clocks for soda, beer, oil and dairy brands, and its round convex glass faces became a mid-century standard. Brands from Dr Pepper to Vernors hung Pam clocks above store counters. Buyers check that the clock runs and lights, because rewiring and motor work add cost and risk.
A working Pam clock with a popular brand brings about 400 to 1,200 dollars, while scarce oil company versions have brought more. Cracked glass faces are hard to replace, and faded graphics behind the glass lower interest quickly.
Neon Advertising Clocks

Lighted neon clocks, many made in the 1930s and 1940s, gave gas stations and diners a glowing timepiece with a brand name ringed around the dial. They were heavy, built from metal cases with neon tubes behind the glass, and many sat in garages after the business closed.
Value depends on whether the neon still lights, the condition of the transformer and the presence of the correct face and hands. Retubing and rewiring can cost a few hundred dollars, which buyers subtract from offers.
A sound neon clock with an automotive brand has brought roughly 800 to 2,500 dollars.
Diamond Dyes Store Cabinets

Wells, Richardson and Company of Burlington, Vermont, sold Diamond Dyes to general stores in wooden cabinets with lithographed tin fronts. Designs such as The Governess show children and fashionable scenes, and they are prized by country store collectors.
A complete Diamond Dyes cabinet with a strong tin front brings about 1,000 to 3,000 dollars. The tin panel is the heart of the value, so scratches, dents and faded colors on the front lower the price significantly.
Many of these cabinets stayed in stores for decades, then moved to farmhouses, where they held tools and nails.
Planters Mr. Peanut Counter Jars

Planters Nut and Chocolate Company adopted Mr. Peanut after a 1916 contest, and the monocled peanut soon appeared on glass store jars that held nuts on countertops. Jar shapes include barrel, square and fishbowl styles, many with embossed Planters lettering and peanut finials on the lid.
The original lid makes a huge difference, because a jar without its correct top loses much of its value. Collectors check for chips on the rim and cracks in the glass. A good Planters jar with a period lid brings around 150 to 500 dollars, and rare styles have brought more.
Sherwin-Williams Cover the Earth Signs

Sherwin-Williams has used its paint can pouring over the globe since the 1890s, and the Cover the Earth image ended up on porcelain signs at hardware stores everywhere. These signs often surface in old hardware and paint store stock rooms or barns where owners stored them after remodeling.
The red paint flowing across the globe makes chips easy to spot, and fading in the red reduces appeal. A strong Sherwin-Williams porcelain sign brings around 400 to 1,500 dollars, with smaller tin pieces priced lower.
Large porcelain versions are especially sought, since few advertising images say so much with a single pour of paint.
Dutch Boy Paint Signs

National Lead Company marketed Dutch Boy paint with a painted image of a boy in overalls holding a brush, a trademark that appeared on tin and porcelain signs for much of the twentieth century. Die-cut Dutch Boy figures are the prize, since they show the character in full and look striking on a wall.
Flat signs are more common and easier to find in hardware store basements and farm sheds. Paint loss, rust and scratched faces all lower value.
Die-cut Dutch Boy signs have brought 500 to 1,500 dollars in solid condition, while flat versions go for less.
Champion Spark Plug Displays

Champion spark plugs were sold from countertop tin cabinets and racks that let mechanics grab the right plug quickly, and the brand also produced bright tin and porcelain wall signs. The bowtie style Champion logo appeared on many of these displays, which often stayed in rural garages long after the business shut down.
A Champion display or sign brings around 200 to 800 dollars, depending on condition and age. Missing drawers, dents and wear to the lithographed graphics all matter to collectors, and displays with their inner trays intact draw the most interest.
Goodyear Winged Foot Signs

Goodyear tire dealers hung signs bearing the winged foot logo, a design taken from the mythological Mercury that has appeared on Goodyear advertising for more than a century. Porcelain dealer signs from the early to mid twentieth century are durable but heavy, which is why they often turn up in garages instead of being moved.
Collectors focus on the strength of the blue and gold colors and on chipping around the edges. Some signs are double-sided, which adds value if both faces hold up.
A good porcelain Goodyear sign brings several hundred to over 1,000 dollars.
Red Goose Shoes Signs

Red Goose Shoes, based in St. Louis, advertised with a bright red goose that appeared on signs, store displays and promotional items for children. Die-cut tin and porcelain geese are among the most sought pieces, since they make a striking display on shop walls.
A die-cut Red Goose sign in nice condition has brought 500 to 1,500 dollars, with smaller flat signs selling for less. Fading of the red, rust spots and chipped edges all count against value.
Shoe stores remodeled often, so plenty of these signs went home with employees and ended up in garages.
Morton Salt Umbrella Girl Signs

Morton Salt introduced its girl with an umbrella and the slogan When It Rains It Pours in 1914, and the image appeared on tin and porcelain store signs for decades. The design changed over time, so the girl’s dress and hair help collectors date a sign.
Morton signs come from general stores and grocery stock rooms, and many were tucked away when stores closed. Rust, faded blue and bends are the usual issues.
Older Morton signs bring around 200 to 800 dollars in good condition, while later and more common versions bring less.
Rust, Gloss and the Price of a Second Life

Every sign on this list was made to be looked at for a few years and then thrown away. Most were, which is precisely why the survivors matter so much to collectors today.
The ones that lasted usually did so by accident, nailed over a crack in a barn wall or stacked behind a workbench where no one thought about them again.
Condition decides almost everything in this hobby, and the gap between a faded sign and a glossy one can be thousands of dollars. Reproductions have flooded the market, so weight, porcelain layers, honest wear and period hardware all count.
For pickers, the lesson rarely changes from one farm sale to the next: the sign nobody bothered to move is often the one worth moving now.
More from Home As We Make It

- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
