27 Old Advertising Tins Dealers Keep Behind the Counter
Printed tin was the cheapest way to put a brand in a kitchen, and for roughly eighty years manufacturers packed everything from cocoa to axle grease in lithographed metal. The container was meant to be emptied and discarded, which is why the survivors carry the prices they do.
Dealers sort these by graphics first and rarity second. A dented tin with a spectacular image outsells a mint one with a dull label almost every time, which is the opposite of how most antiques work.
Key-Wind Coffee Tins
These opened by winding a strip of metal off the rim with a small key, which means the lid and the key are missing from most survivors. The lithography on the body is often superb, with detailed scenes printed directly on the metal rather than on a paper label.
A tin with its key still soldered to the base is a noticeably better find than one without.
Paper-Label Coffee Tins
Earlier tins carried a printed paper wrapper rather than direct lithography, and paper on metal is a combination that survives poorly. Humidity lifts the label, and rust pushes through from underneath.
A paper-label tin with a complete, unfaded wrapper is considerably scarcer than a lithographed one of the same age, and dealers price it that way.
Cocoa Tins
Small rectangular cocoa containers were produced by dozens of companies and decorated with everything from classical figures to elaborate trade characters. The hinged lids are the common weak point, since the hinge fatigues and tears from the body.
Brands that vanished in company mergers are the ones collectors pursue, since their tins had a short production window.
Baking Powder Tins
Sold in enormous quantities and kept in use until empty, then usually reused for nails or buttons before being thrown out. That second life is what damaged most of them.
Small sample sizes given away by traveling representatives are dramatically scarcer than the full-size versions and bring correspondingly higher prices.
Spice Tins in Matched Sets
Households bought spices in small identical tins that sat together on a rack, and the set is what collectors want. Individual tins are affordable; a complete rack of eight or ten matching tins from one brand is a different proposition.
Fading is uneven across a set, since whichever tin sat on the sunny end lost its color first.
Tea Tins with Transfer Lithography
British tea companies produced some of the most ambitious printed tins of the period, including designs commissioned from established illustrators. The transfer process allowed fine detail that survives well on the metal surface.
Tins depicting scenes of the trade routes and plantations carry both collector and historical interest, and condition on the lid is what the price turns on.
Malted Drink Powder Tins
Malted milk and fortified drink powders were sold in tall cylindrical tins with screw or press lids, and the brands invested heavily in the graphics because the tin sat on a counter. Interior residue attracts damp and rusts these from the inside. A tin that rings cleanly when tapped rather than sounding dull is generally sound.
Mustard Tins
Small yellow tins from the major mustard makers are among the most recognizable objects in any general store display. Their bright base color shows fading immediately, which makes condition easy to assess at a glance.
Early tins with a royal warrant printed on the face are dated by the reign referenced, a useful shortcut for placing them.
Golden Syrup Tins
The green and gold tin with its lion and bee illustration has run largely unchanged for well over a century, which makes dating a specific example a matter of reading small details in the printing and the lid construction. Early examples with a soldered seam rather than a rolled one predate the modern production.
The design’s longevity is itself part of the appeal.
Novelty-Shaped Biscuit Tins
British biscuit manufacturers produced tins shaped as books, vehicles, windmills, and buildings, intended as gifts that would remain in the house after the contents were eaten. Those with working parts, such as wheels that turn or drawers that open, are the ones that command real money.
Missing components are the usual problem, since a tin shaped as a delivery van rarely keeps all four wheels.
Christmas Biscuit Tins
Seasonal tins were produced in one run and never repeated, which gives each year’s design a fixed and knowable quantity. Collectors assemble runs by year from a single manufacturer.
The lids took the wear, since these were stacked in cupboards, and a clean lid is worth far more than a clean base.
Lithographed Candy Pails
Small tin pails with wire handles held sweets and were explicitly designed so a child would keep the pail as a toy afterward. The illustrations feature nursery scenes and animals in bright colors that fade badly in light.
A pail with its original lid and an unbent handle is uncommon enough to draw competition.
Marshmallow Tins
Large shallow tins with elaborate lids held confectionery for store counters, and the lid is usually the only decorated surface. They were reused for sewing supplies in countless households, which paradoxically preserved them.
Examples with the original interior paper lining intact are the ones dealers hold back.
Peanut Butter Pails
Sold in tin pails with wire handles in sizes from one to several pounds, decorated with illustrations aimed squarely at children. The lids rusted from the inside because of the oil content.
A pail with a clean interior and a legible base stamp identifying the packer is at the top of this category.
Lard Pails
Plain by comparison with the confectionery pails, and collected mainly for the brand names of regional meat packers that no longer exist. Their commonness keeps prices low except where the packer was short-lived or local to a collecting area.
Rust staining inside is expected and only slightly penalized.
Popcorn and Chip Tins
Snack manufacturers used large decorated tins for store display and for holiday gift packaging. The size makes them impressive and also makes them vulnerable to denting.
Examples from the earliest decades of the snack food business are scarce because the tins were routinely converted into storage containers and painted over.
Talcum Powder Tins
North East Museums, source: Flickr, No known copyright restrictions
Tall narrow tins with a sifter top, decorated with figures, flowers, and Art Deco geometry depending on the decade. The sifter perforations clog and the shoulders dent easily, so an undented example with a working top is uncommon.
The graphics on these are often the finest miniature lithography in the entire category.
Salve and Ointment Tins
Small flat tins with slip lids held remedies of every description, many with claims that would not survive a modern regulator. They are inexpensive individually and collected by theme or by manufacturer.
The printed text on the reverse is often the most interesting surface, and dealers who display them face-up are missing the point.
Pharmacy and Tablet Tins
Pocket-sized tins for headache tablets and lozenges were produced by the thousand and carried in coats until the printing wore off the corners. That wear is exactly why a crisp example stands out.
Tins from pharmacies that printed their own branding rather than a national brand are the local rarities.
Shaving and Blade Tins
Small tins held soap sticks, blades, and powders, with graphics aimed at a male customer and often printed in restrained two-color schemes. Blade tins in particular were produced in extraordinary variety by competing manufacturers.
Complete tins with original contents still sealed are worth more than empty ones, which is unusual in this field.
Shoe Polish Tins
Flat circular tins with a lever or twist opening, produced by companies that operated internationally and printed in multiple languages. The tins were opened with a knife, which is why the rims on most are mangled.
Early versions with a soldered rather than a pressed construction predate the common examples by decades.
Typewriter Ribbon Tins
Small, flat, and beautifully printed, these were produced in hundreds of designs by competing ribbon manufacturers and thrown away as soon as the ribbon was fitted. They are among the most actively collected tins, largely because the graphics are excellent and the tins store easily.
Designs featuring the manufacturer’s trade character sell well above generic ones.
Phonograph Needle Tins
Steel needles for acoustic gramophones were sold in tiny hinged tins holding a couple of hundred, with designs featuring dogs, dancers, and elaborate typography. They fit in a palm, which makes them one of the few tin categories that can be collected in depth without a warehouse.
Tins with the original needles still inside are preferred and are more common than one would expect.
One-Quart Motor Oil Tins
Before plastic bottles, motor oil was sold in a metal can opened with a spout that punctured the top. Full unopened cans exist and are collected specifically, since an opened one has usually leaked and stained.
The graphics vary regionally, and cans from independent refiners that were absorbed by larger companies are the ones with a following.
Grease and Lubricant Tins
Heavier tins with press lids held chassis grease and specialty lubricants, decorated with racing and aviation imagery that had little to do with the contents. Grease residue preserves the interior metal rather well.
The lids are almost always separated from the correct base, and a matched set with the same brand and size is what dealers look for.
Automotive First Aid Tins
Compact metal kits mounted in vehicles, printed with the supplier’s name and often a diagram of contents on the inside of the lid. The contents are rarely complete, and the printed lid interior is the feature that matters.
Kits issued to fleets or to specific manufacturers carry an additional layer of interest.
Sample-Size Tins
Manufacturers gave away miniature versions of their products at fairs and through door-to-door representatives, typically a third the height of the retail package. Few were kept, since they held almost nothing and were consumed immediately.
A sample tin is routinely worth several times its full-size equivalent, which surprises sellers consistently.
The Metal That Was Meant to Be Thrown Away
The graphic quality in this category is a byproduct of competition on a crowded shelf. Companies commissioned serious illustration and paid for expensive multi-color printing because the tin was the only advertisement most customers would ever see up close.
None of that effort was intended to last past the pantry. The tins that survived did so because somebody decided a printed container was too handsome to bin, which is the same judgment collectors are making now, just a century later and with money involved.
More from Home As We Make It
- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
