26 Sweaters and Coats Worth Buying Secondhand

Secondhand racks are full of knitwear that outlasted the patience of the people who bought it. A wool overcoat cut in 1985 used cloth that would cost more per yard today than the coat sold for new, and it has already proved it can survive four decades of closets, moves and indifference.

Garments that reach a resale floor in good shape have passed a test no showroom can run.

Condition decides everything. Moth damage, felted shrinkage, blown-out elbows and dead elastic separate a bargain from a mistake, and the difference is usually visible in about ten seconds under decent light.

Cashmere Crewnecks From the Two-Ply Era

The word cashmere on a label says nothing about gauge. Two-ply yarn, knit at a tight gauge, produces a sweater that holds shape for twenty years; single-ply featherweight versions sag within two seasons.

Hold the body up to a window and look for thinned spots where light passes through, especially at the elbows and the ribbed cuffs. Check whether the cuff snaps back when stretched.

Good two-ply examples turn up for roughly twenty to sixty dollars against several hundred new.

Shetland Wool Crewnecks With a Crisp Hand

Real Shetland is woolen-spun, slightly hairy, and feels almost scratchy before it softens with wear. That coarseness is the point: the fiber traps air and resists pilling far better than smooth worsted yarns. Genuine examples carry a Scottish mill name and a fuzzy surface that has bloomed rather than matted.

Inspect the underarm seam, which is where a woolen-spun sweater usually fails first. Thrift prices of fifteen to forty dollars are common, and the fabric only improves.

Fair Isle Yoke Sweaters Knit in the Round

Traditional Fair Isle patterning uses two colors per row, carried across the back of the work, which makes the yoke noticeably thicker and warmer than the body. Authentic pieces are knit as a tube and then cut open at the armscye, with the cut edges secured by a steek and bound in yarn or tape.

Turn the sweater inside out and check that binding. A loose one unravels quickly. Expect thirty to ninety dollars for a sound vintage example.

Aran Cable Knits With Honest Weight

A genuine Aran sweater weighs something. Cable, honeycomb and trellis panels consume roughly twice the yarn of a flat knit, so a proper one lands near two pounds on a scale.

Machine-made imitations feel light and hollow by comparison. Look at the shoulder seams, where the weight of the fabric pulls hardest over time, and at the pattern edges for any thinned yarn.

Good ones sell used between thirty and eighty dollars, well below the price of anything hand-knit new.

Norwegian Ski Sweaters With Pewter Clasps

The Setesdal-style lusekofte pairs a dense two-color body with a pewter clasp closure instead of a zipper, and those clasps are the best authenticity check available. Original metal tarnishes to a soft gray and sits on reinforced tape stitched through both layers.

Look for pulled stitches around each clasp base, since that is where strain concentrates. Dale of Norway and similar mills built these to survive outdoor work, not fashion cycles.

Forty to one hundred twenty dollars is typical secondhand.

Camel Hair Overcoats in Their Natural Color

Camel hair is finer than most sheep wool and warmer for its weight, which is why undyed camel coats feel light for how much heat they hold. The tradeoff is fragility: the fiber abrades, and the first sign appears as a faded sheen along the front edges and cuff turns.

Check the lining at the armscye for splits, which are cheap to repair. Coats that cost well over a thousand dollars new routinely resell between sixty and two hundred.

Harris Tweed Jackets Carrying the Orb Mark

The Orb label means the cloth was handwoven by an islander at home in the Outer Hebrides from virgin wool dyed and spun there. It is one of the few textile marks with statutory protection, and it is stitched into the lining, not printed.

Inspect elbows first, then the lining under the arms, then the pocket corners. Tweed itself almost never wears out; the lining does, and a tailor replaces it for less than the jacket costs at forty to eighty dollars used.

Waxed Cotton Field Coats Due for Re-Proofing

Waxed cotton dries out rather than failing, which means a stiff, chalky-looking jacket is usually a good buy, not a ruined one. A tin of dressing and an afternoon with a hair dryer restores water resistance across the entire shell.

What cannot be fixed cheaply is a torn corduroy collar or a broken main zipper, so check both before anything else. Barbour and similar British makers sell used between fifty and one hundred fifty dollars, and both run a repair service.

Wool Duffle Coats With Horn Toggles

The duffle’s closure is its weak point and its tell. Original toggles were cut from buffalo horn and hung on jute or leather loops, and horn shows irregular grain and slight color variation that molded plastic cannot fake.

Tug each loop; frayed rope is a five-minute fix, but a torn anchor patch means restitching through heavy melton. Gloverall built the civilian standard after the naval version.

Sound examples run sixty to one hundred fifty dollars.

Shearling Coats Weighed Before Buying

Shearling is a single hide with the wool still attached, so the suede face and the fleece are one material and cannot separate. The failure mode is dryness: skin that has been stored in a hot attic goes brittle and cracks along fold lines at the elbow and lower back.

Flex a seam and watch for surface crazing. Also note the weight, which often exceeds ten pounds.

Professional cleaning costs real money, so factor it into a purchase price of eighty to three hundred dollars.

Leather Bomber Jackets With Knit Trim

On a flight-style jacket, the leather almost always outlives the knit cuffs and waistband, which stretch out and lose their grip. Replacing that trim is standard work for a leather repair shop and costs a fraction of the jacket.

The real deal-breaker is a cracked zipper tape or a dried-out lining at the shoulders. Press a thumbnail into the hide; supple leather springs back without a white mark.

Prices swing widely, from seventy dollars to several hundred by maker and vintage.

Down Parkas Judged by Loft, Not Label

Fill power describes how much space an ounce of down occupies, and it degrades with body oils and repeated washing rather than with age alone. Lay the parka flat and look for chambers that stay thin while their neighbors puff up, which means the down has migrated or escaped.

Tiny feather quills poking through the shell fabric are normal; a steady trail of them is not. A proper wash with down-specific detergent revives much of the loft for a thirty-to-hundred-dollar purchase.

Peacoats Cut From Heavy Melton

Naval-issue peacoats used melton wool around thirty ounces per yard, dense enough that the cut edges of the pockets need no finishing. That weight is the reason a surplus coat from the 1960s still hangs correctly while a modern one in a lighter cloth collapses at the shoulders.

Check the anchor buttons, which unscrew or sit on shanks and are easily replaced, and check the underarms for felted shine. Surplus examples commonly sell for forty to one hundred dollars.

Loden Coats Built to Shed Rain

Austrian and Bavarian loden is woven loosely, then fulled and brushed so the nap lies in one direction, letting water run off instead of soaking in. The characteristic deep green comes from heavily milled wool that resists wind without any coating.

Look at the back, where a deep inverted pleat allows stride; a split at the top of that pleat is the common failure. These are quietly excellent walking coats and often sit unwanted at fifty to one hundred thirty dollars.

Quilted Barn Coats With Corduroy Collars

The barn coat formula pairs a tough cotton shell with a diamond-quilted lining and a corduroy collar, and each part ages differently. The shell fades attractively, the quilting stitches break, and the corduroy goes bald at the neck.

Run a hand inside to find loose batting drifting away from broken stitch lines, which is repairable but tedious. These are among the most common good coats in thrift stores, generally twenty-five to sixty dollars, because owners buy them for one season of yard work.

Mohair Cardigans With a Visible Halo

Mohair comes from angora goats and is brushed after knitting to raise a halo of long fibers that catches light. That halo is also a liability, since it snags on watch bands, zippers and rough tables.

Look for flattened patches where the nap has been crushed and cannot be revived by steaming. Because mohair does not felt as readily as sheep wool, these often survive careless laundering that would ruin a lambswool piece.

Twenty-five to seventy dollars is a fair range.

Lambswool Vests for Layering Under a Jacket

A sleeveless sweater solves the problem of bulk under a suit jacket, and secondhand supply far exceeds demand because few people think to look. Check the arm openings, where ribbing stretches and loses recovery, and the lower hem, which takes abrasion from belts and chair backs.

Lambswool refers to the first shearing and is softer and springier than standard wool, though it pills more readily. Fifteen to thirty-five dollars buys a good one from a Scottish or Italian mill.

Boiled Wool Jackets That Cannot Fray

Boiled wool is knit first and then deliberately shrunk in hot water until the fibers lock together into a dense felt. The result behaves like fabric rather than knitwear: cut edges do not unravel, so these jackets often have no facings, no lining and raw hems by design.

Inspect for thin, papery areas at the elbows where the felt has compressed further. The construction makes them nearly impossible to damage by accident, and they turn up around thirty to eighty dollars.

Alpaca Sweaters With Serious Drape

Alpaca fiber is hollow and contains no lanolin, which makes it warmer than wool by weight and tolerable for people who react to sheep fiber. It also has almost no memory, so a heavy alpaca sweater grows through a day of wear and needs flat drying to recover its dimensions.

A stretched-out neckband is the first thing to check, since ribbing in pure alpaca rarely springs back. Expect thirty to ninety dollars, with Peruvian mill labels the safest bet.

Merino Base Layers Checked for Thinning

Fine merino base layers wear out from the inside, and the damage shows as translucent patches at the shoulder blades and lower back where a pack or a chair rubs. Hold the garment against a bright window before buying, because a thinned area becomes a break in the knit within a few washes.

Odor resistance is the real selling point, and it survives in used garments as long as the fiber does. Ten to thirty dollars, which is a quarter of retail.

Trench Coats With Their Liners Intact

The removable liner is what turns a rain shell into a three-season coat, and it is missing from most secondhand trenches. Check the buttons or zipper track inside the body before anything else; a coat with its liner is worth two without one.

Then examine the storm flap stitching, the D-rings on the belt and the collar hook. Cotton gabardine at a high thread count sheds water on its own.

Sixty to two hundred dollars covers most quality examples.

Varsity Jackets Combining Melton and Leather

The classic letterman construction sets a heavy melton wool body against leather sleeves, with knit trim at collar, cuffs and hem. The two materials age at different rates, so a jacket can show cracked sleeve leather over a perfectly sound body.

Check the leather at the inner elbow, where flexing concentrates, and look at how chenille patches are attached, since loose ones tear the wool beneath. Genuine older examples with school patches run fifty to two hundred dollars.

Fishermen’s Smocks in Heavy Cotton Drill

The smock is a pullover work garment with a single front pouch pocket and no closure beyond a short neck opening, designed so nothing catches on rigging. Cotton drill versions soften dramatically with washing and reach their best state after several years, which is exactly why used ones beat new.

Look at the pocket edges and the neck placket for fraying. Breton and British makers still produce them, and secondhand pieces sit around twenty to fifty dollars.

Hand-Knit Cardigans Seamed by Hand

A hand-knit garment gives itself away at the seams, which are joined stitch by stitch rather than overlocked by machine. Turn it inside out; mattress-stitch seams look like a flat ladder with no bulk. Many hand-knit cardigans arrive with a length of matching yarn wound inside a pocket, left by the knitter for repairs.

Check the button band for stretch, since that edge carries the most strain. These sell for astonishingly little, often fifteen to forty dollars.

Chore Coats in French Moleskin or Twill

The chore coat is three patch pockets, a flat collar and a button placket, cut from cotton twill or moleskin dense enough to stand on its own. French versions in faded indigo have become collectible, but the useful ones are ordinary workwear that has already softened and faded honestly.

Check the pocket corners and the elbow, and look for triple-needle stitching, which signals a garment built for repeated laundering. Twenty-five to seventy dollars buys a very good one.

Anoraks Cut From Sixty-Forty Cloth

The mountain anorak pulls over the head, closes partway with a zipper, and carries a large kangaroo pocket across the front. Classic versions use a sixty-forty blend of cotton and nylon, where the cotton swells when wet to slow water and the nylon supplies tear strength.

The wear points are the pocket mouth and the hood drawcord channel. Aging elastic in the cuffs is the usual complaint and the usual repair. Thirty to ninety dollars is normal.

What a Cuff Remembers About Its Owner

Every one of these garments carries a record of how it was treated, and reading it takes less skill than most buyers assume. Ribbing that has lost its spring, a shine at the underarm, a lining split along one shoulder: each says something specific about years of wear, and each has a known cost to fix or ignore.

The pricing on a resale rack almost never reflects that record. It reflects floor space.

That gap is the entire opportunity. Cloth this heavy, this densely woven or this carefully spun is expensive to make and therefore rare at any price now, while the coats and sweaters made when it was ordinary keep circulating at prices set by the hurry to move inventory.

Cedar blocks and a careful look under good light handle most of the risk. What remains is a wool coat for the price of a meal.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.