26 Old Board Games on Thrift Shelves Collectors Buy

The board game shelf at a thrift store is arranged by size, which is the only sorting criterion that has ever been applied to it. Everything is priced the same, taped shut, and shelved spine-out, and nobody has opened a single box to count what is inside.

That is the opportunity and the risk together. A complete game in a sound box can be worth a hundred times the sticker, and an identical box missing four pieces is worth nothing at all, and the only way to tell is to look.

Victorian Lithographed Games From McLoughlin Brothers

The chromolithographed boards and box lids produced by McLoughlin Brothers in the late nineteenth century are collected as graphic art rather than as games, and the artwork on the lid frequently outvalues everything inside. Prices reach levels that have nothing to do with playability, driven by the color printing and the survival of the paper. 

Edge wear on the box corners is universal and expected. These almost never reach a thrift shelf, but they do reach estate sales in the same town.

Early Milton Bradley Boxed Games

Milton Bradley’s earliest games were sold in shallow boxes with printed paper labels, and the graphics carry the same appeal as the McLoughlin material at a lower price point. Card and paper components inside were made to be handled and rarely survive complete. 

Sellers photograph the lid separately, because that image is what generates interest. Water staining on paper labels is the flaw that most reduces value.

Parker Brothers Games From Before the First World War

Parker Brothers issued dozens of titles in the decades around the turn of the twentieth century, many of them tied to news events, expeditions, and popular fiction of the moment. The topical ones are the most collected, since they document a moment that everyone has since forgotten. 

Original instruction sheets are frequently missing and can sometimes be sourced separately. Look for the maker’s address printed on the lid, which narrows the production window.

Early Monopoly Sets With Wooden Tokens

Monopoly is the most common game in existence and almost all of it is worthless, which is why the specific early editions matter so much. Sets with wooden houses, wooden pawns, and the early box styles predate the metal tokens most people picture. 

Regional and pre-standardization printings show board variations that collectors document carefully. Condition of the board fold lines determines whether an early set is a display piece or a parts donor.

Avalon Hill Bookcase Wargames

The bookcase format puts a hex map, a counter sheet, and a rulebook into a box designed to be shelved like a novel, and the surviving copies are collected title by title. Unpunched counter sheets are the single most valuable condition detail in the category and should be checked before anything else. 

The spine label is what identifies the title on a shelf, and a faded spine hurts a listing. Titles from the earliest production years carry different box art and command premiums.

Sealed Wargame Modules and Expansions

Expansion modules were printed in smaller runs than base games and were bought by fewer people, which reverses the usual supply relationship. A sealed module in shrink wrap sells to collectors who have no intention of playing it. 

Counters, maps, and rule inserts must all be present for an opened module to have real value. Publisher and print run are worth confirming, since several popular systems were reprinted by later companies.

The American Heritage Command Decision Series

Milton Bradley’s American Heritage line packaged historical conflicts with molded plastic pieces and boards that were considerably more ambitious than the company’s family titles. The series is collected as a run, and the individual titles vary widely in how easily they turn up. 

Plastic ships, aircraft, and figures are the components that disappear, and a complete count against the rules is the only reliable check. Box art on this series is strong enough that damaged copies still sell to display buyers.

Dune in Its Original Edition

The board game adaptation of the novel, published in the late seventies, combined asymmetric factions with a bidding and betrayal structure that was unusual for its moment. Original copies with intact counters and the faction player aids sell well into collector territory. 

Later licensed reissues are distinct products and should never be described interchangeably with the original. Box corner splits are the standard damage and reduce price meaningfully.

Cosmic Encounter with Its Original Alien Sets

The first edition and its expansion sets introduced dozens of alien powers, each of which broke a rule of the game in a different way. Complete sets with every power card present are what collectors pursue, and counting the cards against a published list is essential before pricing. 

Expansions were sold separately and are considerably scarcer than the base game. Card wear from actual play is common because this was a game people genuinely used.

Dark Tower with a Working Turret

The electronic tower at the center of this game contains a motorized carousel and a light display, and the question that determines its price is whether the mechanism still turns. Battery corrosion in the compartment is the usual cause of failure and is sometimes reversible. 

Complete copies include plastic figures, cards, and the tower, and copies missing the tower are worth almost nothing. Sellers test and photograph the tower running rather than describing it in text.

Milton Bradley Electronic Games of the Eighties

Electronic sound and light components turned several mid-eighties titles into experiences that a plain board could not deliver, and those components are precisely what fails first. Working units in complete boxes sell at multiples of nonworking ones. 

Corrosion, missing battery doors, and dead speakers are the common problems and should be tested in the store when possible. Original instruction booklets are frequently the missing piece.

Dungeon and the Early TSR Boxed Games

Boxed games published by TSR in the seventies and early eighties are collected alongside the role-playing material from the same company, and the crossover audience pushes prices well above their appearance. Print run and box art variations are documented in collector references and determine value. 

Counters, cards, and the map must all be present. The company name and address printed on the box helps date a particular printing.

Dungeons and Dragons Boxed Basic Sets

The boxed introductory sets are shelved with board games in most thrift stores because the box shape matches, which is why they turn up in this category at all. Different printings carry different cover art and different contents, and knowing the sequence is the entire skill. 

Dice, particularly the early soft plastic sets and the crayon supplied for inking them, are frequently missing. Rulebooks alone have their own separate market.

HeroQuest and Its Expansion Packs

The plastic dungeon furniture and painted-quality miniatures in this game generated a following that has outlasted the publisher relationships behind it. Complete copies require counting a long list of small plastic components, and any listing without a full count is treated with suspicion by buyers. 

Expansion packs are scarcer than the base game by a wide margin. Regional editions differ in contents and are worth identifying before pricing.

Talisman in Its Early Editions

The fantasy adventure game went through several editions with substantially different components, and the earlier ones are collected specifically. Character cards, plastic figures, and the numerous small tokens all have to be present. 

Expansions added board sections that clip onto the main board and are individually collectible. Later reprints by different publishers use different art and are a separate product entirely.

Games With Three-Dimensional Plastic Boards

Titles built around a plastic contraption rather than a printed board depend entirely on their moving parts, and those parts break. Complete examples with every plastic element intact and functional are far scarcer than the number of boxes on shelves suggests. 

Assembly is often required, and pieces are lost between plays rather than in storage. Sellers who assemble and photograph the mechanism sell faster than those who list a closed box.

Mystery Date and the Themed Games of the Sixties

Games marketed to girls in the sixties carry period graphics that collectors buy for the artwork as much as for play. The plastic door mechanism in the best-known title is the component that determines completeness. 

Card decks with the illustrated figures must be counted against the rules. Prices vary sharply between the original release and the later reissues, which use different art.

Television Tie-In Games From the Sixties and Seventies

Nearly every popular program of the era licensed a board game, and those games are now collected by fans of the program rather than by game collectors. That audience pays for box art and does not always require completeness, which makes damaged copies more sellable than they would otherwise be. 

Short-lived programs produced short print runs and the scarcest games. The licensing information printed on the box confirms the year.

Space Race Games From the Sixties

The period between the first satellites and the lunar landings produced a wave of games about rockets, orbits, and planetary travel, most with strikingly optimistic artwork. Collectors of space memorabilia buy these outside the game market entirely. 

Metal and plastic rocket tokens are the pieces that go missing. Games issued by aerospace companies as promotional items are the scarcest subcategory.

Bookshelf Games From the 3M Series

The 3M bookshelf series packaged strategy games in slim wood-grain boxes designed to look like books on a shelf, and the series is collected as a run. Some titles are common and some are genuinely difficult to find, and the difference is not obvious from the box. 

Wooden and plastic components must be counted, since the boxes were often reused for other purposes. Shelf wear along the spine is the standard condition problem.

Acquire in Its Early Editions

The hotel chain and stock trading game has been reissued repeatedly, and the early editions with plastic buildings and specific tile designs are the ones collectors want. Tile counts are fixed and easily verified against the rules. 

The playing board differs between editions in ways that are quickly visible once known. Later mass market versions have very little collector value.

Masterpiece With Its Complete Art Deck

The art auction game reproduced paintings from a major museum collection on cards, and the cards are the reason the game is collected. A complete deck with no replacements sells to buyers who have no interest in playing. 

Different printings used different selections of paintings. Card corner wear and creasing reduce value in the same way it would for any card collectible.

Games With Bakelite and Catalin Playing Pieces

Before injection-molded plastic, game pieces were made in early plastics that have color and weight no modern piece matches. Loose pieces from these games are bought by jewelry makers and collectors of early plastic regardless of the game they came from. 

Butterscotch and marbled colors carry premiums. Identification by weight and warmth rather than by appearance is the reliable method.

Mah Jongg Sets in Fitted Cases

Tile sets in leather cases or wooden boxes with sliding lids turn up in estate collections and are shelved with games by default. Tiles carved from bone and bamboo, joined in two pieces, are older and more valuable than solid plastic tiles. 

Complete sets require a specific count including flowers, seasons, and blanks, and counting is essential before pricing. Racks, dice, and scoring sticks belong with a full set.

Carrom and Crokinole Boards

Wooden flicking-game boards from the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries carry printed surfaces, and many are double-sided with different games on each face. Original playing pieces, rings, and pegs are commonly missing and are reproducible. 

Age and maker are identified by the printing at the board edge. Warping across the playing surface is the defect that makes a board decorative rather than usable.

Chess Sets Sold as Games

Chess sets end up on the game shelf priced as games rather than as the objects they often are. Carved wood, bone, and early plastic sets in fitted cases are worth examining piece by piece. A complete set of thirty-two in a matched material is what matters, and a single replaced piece changes the category. 

Weighted bases and felted bottoms indicate a better grade of set.

What the Box Lid Preserves

A board game is a set of ideas printed on cardboard, and the ideas survive fine on their own. What does not survive is the specific object: the counters unpunched, the pawns still bagged, the instruction sheet folded the way the factory folded it. 

That object is what the collecting market is actually buying. Which explains the peculiar economics of the thrift shelf. 

The same title sits there in three copies at the same price, one complete and two gutted, and the store has no incentive to distinguish them. The person who opens the boxes is not smarter about games than anyone else in the aisle. 

They are simply the only ones counting.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.