25 Thrifted Frames and Mirrors Flippers Turn a Profit On
Nobody donates a frame because it stopped working. They donate it because the photograph inside stopped mattering, which means the frame itself often arrives in perfect condition and priced at four dollars.
Mirrors follow the same logic with more weight and more risk. Both categories reward anyone willing to look past whatever terrible print is sitting in the opening.
Ornate Gilt Gesso Frames
Antique frames built from carved wood covered in gesso and water gilded are a specialist market in their own right, with dealers who handle nothing else. Genuine water gilding shows warm red or grey bole beneath worn high points, while later composition frames reveal white chalky gesso instead.
Large 19th century frames with intact corners sell to art dealers who need period-correct housing for period paintings.
Starburst Mirrors
The radiating spike mirror, produced in gilt wood, brass, and painted metal from the 1950s onward, became the single most reproduced mid-century decorative object. Genuine period examples have hand-assembled rays with slight irregularity and often a hand-cut mirror rather than a machine-perfect circle.
Large diameters over thirty inches command dramatically more than the small ones flooding the market.
Venetian Etched Mirrors
Murano workshops produced mirrors framed in mirrored glass panels with wheel-cut floral etching and applied glass rosettes. The rosettes and the delicate crest at the top are the pieces that break, and replacements are effectively unobtainable.
Complete examples with all decoration intact and only light silvering loss are worth serious money and worth serious care in transport.
Barbola Mirrors
Barbola describes the composition paste flowers applied to mirror frames and vanity pieces in the 1920s and 1930s, hand-painted in soft pastels. English examples on triple vanity mirrors and small easel mirrors are the common forms.
The applied flowers chip readily, so an intact frame with unfaded original paint is what buyers are looking for.
Faux Bamboo Brass Frames
Hollywood Regency brass frames cast to imitate bamboo segments, along with the matching faux bamboo wooden versions, have a persistent interior design following. Sets of matching frames in graduated sizes sell far better than singles because they are bought for gallery walls.
Original lacquer that has not been stripped is preferred, though brass polishes back easily when it has.
LaBarge Chinoiserie Mirrors
The Michigan firm produced hand-painted chinoiserie and églomisé mirrors from the mid-20th century, many signed and dated by the individual decorator on the reverse. That signature is the detail most sellers never look for and the one that lifts the price.
Reverse-painted glass panels are the fragile element and cannot be restored convincingly.
Syroco Molded Resin Mirrors
Syracuse Ornamental Company molded wood-pulp and resin decorative pieces from the 1890s, and its mid-century mirrors imitate carved gilt wood convincingly from a few feet away. The pieces are light, which is the fastest way to distinguish them from real carved frames.
Sunburst and ornate oval Syroco mirrors sell steadily, and warping or cracking in the resin is the usual disqualifier.
Tramp Art Frames
Made from layered, notch-carved scrap crate and packing box wood by itinerant and immigrant craftsmen from the 1870s to the 1930s, these frames are genuine American folk art. Deep layering, applied hearts and stars, and any original painted surface all add value.
The category is well documented by folk art dealers, and good examples sell far above what their humble materials suggest.
Convex Bullseye Mirrors
Eugene Kim, Source: Flickr, licensed under CC by 2.0
The round convex mirror in a gilt frame with applied spheres around the rim, often topped by a carved eagle, dates to the Federal period and has been reproduced ever since. Genuine early examples have hand-blown convex glass with slight distortion and irregularity, while modern versions are perfectly uniform.
Original gilding, the eagle intact, and the small chain and rosettes present all matter.
Federal Mirrors with Reverse Painted Glass
Early 19th century tabernacle mirrors combine a mirror panel below with a reverse-painted glass scene above, framed in gilt columns. The painted panel is almost always damaged or replaced, since flaking is inevitable over two centuries.
An original painted panel in readable condition transforms the value of an otherwise ordinary mirror.
Brass Easel Frames
Small brass photograph frames with hinged easel backs, produced from the late Victorian period onward, are easy to overlook in a bin of miscellaneous metal. Marked examples, particularly with sterling or with Art Nouveau repoussé work, are the ones worth separating.
The original glass and an intact easel strut are what buyers verify.
Sterling Silver Picture Frames
Silver frames from the Edwardian period through the mid-20th century turn up regularly and are frequently priced as plate. The hallmark is stamped on the frame edge or the back, and English hallmarks give a precise year.
Dents in the thin silver are common because the frames are wood-backed and hollow, and severe damage is expensive to repair.
Art Deco Chrome and Glass Frames
Frames combining chrome, black glass, and stepped geometric forms belong to the 1930s and photograph beautifully against modern interiors. Original mirror or black vitrolite glass panels are the fragile components.
Pitted chrome is the standard flaw and the reason to pass, since replating a frame costs more than the frame is worth.
Cheval Mirrors
Full-length mirrors on a swinging floor frame are heavy, expensive to ship, and consequently sold locally at prices that reward anyone with a van. Mahogany and walnut examples from the Victorian and Edwardian periods, and the mid-century teak versions, both have markets.
Silvering loss around the edges is normal and generally accepted rather than a reason to reject.
Rattan and Wicker Mirrors
Woven rattan mirrors, including the elaborate peacock and sunburst forms from the 1960s and 1970s, cycle in and out of fashion but currently sell strongly. Structural integrity is the entire question, since dried rattan snaps and cannot be invisibly mended.
Large statement pieces over three feet across are the ones with the best margins.
Danish Teak Framed Mirrors
Scandinavian mirrors with solid teak or rosewood frames, sometimes with a small shelf below, were made as hallway and bedroom pieces. Maker’s marks appear branded on the reverse and are worth checking, since named designers add substantially to the value.
The teak needs oiling rather than refinishing, and an over-sanded frame loses its character and its price.
Turner Wall Accessory Mirrors
The Turner Manufacturing Company produced framed mirrors and wall art for the American mass market from the 1940s through the 1970s, and its label appears on the reverse. The pieces are unashamedly decorative rather than fine, which is precisely their appeal now.
Gilt and antiqued mirror panels in ornate plastic frames sell to buyers styling maximalist interiors.
Faux Tortoiseshell Frames
Frames finished to imitate tortoiseshell, in painted wood, celluloid, and later plastics, have a steady following among traditional decorators. Genuine antique celluloid examples yellow and can become brittle, so condition varies enormously.
Pairs and sets sell better than singles, following the general rule for anything hung on a wall.
Florentine Gilt Wood Frames
Italian gilded wood frames and trays with hand-applied floral decoration and distressed gold finish were exported to America in quantity through the mid-20th century. The Florentine label or an Italian import stamp usually appears on the reverse.
These are consistent sellers because they read as expensive and cost very little to acquire.
Trumeau Mirrors
The French trumeau combines a mirror panel with a painted or carved panel above, originally built into the space between two windows. Genuine 18th and 19th century examples are architectural in scale and priced accordingly, while 20th century reproductions are far more common.
Original paint and an intact upper panel are the two things that determine which category a piece falls into.
Brutalist Metal Mirrors
Torch-cut and welded metal mirrors in the manner of Curtis Jere and the Belgian metal artists of the 1960s and 1970s are the current high point of that revival. Signed Jere pieces command a large premium, but unsigned examples in the same idiom still sell well.
Rust and separated welds are the two structural concerns worth inspecting.
Homco and Burwood Plastic Frames
Home Interiors and Gifts sold molded plastic frames and wall décor through home party sales from the 1960s onward, and the pieces are unmistakably of their era. Individually they are worth very little, but grouped sets in matching finishes sell to buyers assembling ornate walls cheaply.
This is a volume business rather than a treasure hunt.
Pressed Tin Frames
Late 19th and early 20th century frames stamped from thin sheet metal with embossed floral and geometric borders were an inexpensive alternative to carved wood. Original paint and gilding, and any that retain their period photograph or advertising insert, add real interest.
Rust and distortion in the thin metal are the usual reasons to leave one behind.
Domed Bubble Glass Frames
Convex glass frames, often oval with a deep gilt or wooden surround, housed the formal portraits that hung in American parlors from the 1890s to the 1920s. The domed glass is the valuable part and is nearly impossible to source as a replacement.
Frames with intact original glass sell readily to people restoring family portraits and to decorators who use them empty.
Arts and Crafts Oak Frames
Quartersawn oak frames with visible joinery, hammered copper corner details, and simple flat profiles came out of the American Craftsman movement and its many imitators. Original finish is essential, since the appeal rests on the wood grain and the honest construction rather than on decoration.
Frames with hand-hammered metal accents or a maker’s stamp are the ones worth researching.
Empty Space Sells
There is a particular economics to frames and mirrors that separates them from every other resale category. The object has no function of its own, no mechanism to fail, and no content to date it, which means a frame from 1890 competes on equal terms with one from last year.
That neutrality is why the good ones keep selling. A buyer is not purchasing a picture or a reflection, they are purchasing a border, and the borders that were built well enough to outlast their contents are the only ones still available.
More from Home As We Make It
- 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
- Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
- Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
- 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
- 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is
Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.
