25 Sewing Notions Quilters Snap Up

Walk into any estate sale where a sewing basket has surfaced and watch how fast the tin gets picked clean. Quilters and stitchers know that the tools and trims of past generations often outperform what sits on store shelves now, and the good ones are getting harder to find.

What follows are the notions that disappear first.

Mother-of-Pearl Buttons on Original Cards

Iridescent shell buttons still stitched to their printed backing cards draw the fastest bidding at estate sales. Cut from real oyster and mussel shell before plastics took over in the 1940s, each one carries a faint rainbow sheen no synthetic reproduces.

A complete card with every button in place and the maker’s name legible can bring several times the price of loose examples, since condition and packaging drive value. Buyers look for the hand-drilled centers and the slight size variation that mark genuine shell rather than molded imitation.

Bakelite Buttons

Early plastic buttons made from Bakelite, the phenolic resin patented by Leo Baekeland in 1907, have a devoted following that overlaps with jewelry collectors. Carved, laminated, and dyed in deep reds, greens, and butterscotch tones, they were once cheap novelties and now change hands for surprising sums.

A quick rub to warm the surface releases a faint chemical scent that helps buyers separate authentic Bakelite from later look-alikes. Deeply carved or figural examples in strong colors command the highest prices.

Wooden Spools of Coats & Clark Cotton Thread

Empty wooden thread spools have become a currency of their own among crafters, and the ones stamped Coats & Clark or J&P Coats are the most familiar. The company stopped winding thread on wood in the mid-1970s, switching to plastic, which fixed a hard cutoff date for the genuine article.

Buyers use them for garland, drawer pulls, and display, so even spools without thread sell in bundles. Full spools with intact paper labels and legible price stamps carry a premium over bare ones.

Feed Sack Fabric

Cotton sacks that once held flour, sugar, and animal feed were printed in cheerful patterns during the Depression so thrifty women could resew them into dresses and quilts. Manufacturers competed on print designs, knowing shoppers chose brands by which fabric they wanted most.

Uncut sacks with the original brand printing still visible are the rarest, since most were washed and cut generations ago. Prices climb for florals and novelty prints in unfaded condition.

Singer Featherweight Attachments

The Singer Featherweight 221 sewing machine has a cult following, and the little accessories that came with it are collected separately. Ruffler feet, tuckers, binders, and hemmers stamped with Singer part numbers fit into the original green or black attachment boxes.

A complete boxed set with the instruction booklet and every foot present can be worth as much as some machines. Rust-free chrome and an intact box lid make the difference between a keeper and a parts lot.

Wiss Pinking Shears

The zigzag edge that keeps woven fabric from fraying comes from pinking shears, and the American maker Wiss of Newark, New Jersey, built some of the sturdiest. Their heavy chromed models from the 1940s and 1950s still cut cleanly after decades because the geared blades were forged rather than stamped.

Collectors and working sewers both chase them, which keeps prices firm. A pair that still pinks a crisp edge without gaps is worth far more than a decorative rusted one.

Sterling Silver Thimbles

Thimbles cross from the workbasket into serious collecting, especially the sterling silver ones with dimpled tops and decorated bands. Some were advertising giveaways stamped with a shop or product name, while others were engraved keepsakes given as gifts.

A hallmarked sterling example in a fitted case draws the most interest, since silver content and maker’s marks anchor the value. Dents and worn rims lower the price, so unblemished pieces stand out.

Tomato Pincushions

The red stuffed tomato with its little attached strawberry is one of the most recognized objects in sewing, and vintage examples predate the mass-produced versions sold today. The strawberry is filled with emery powder meant to scour and sharpen pins pushed into it.

Older ones made of wool felt with hand-stitched seams outsell the newer velveteen imports. Firm stuffing and unfaded fabric keep the value up.

Wooden Darning Eggs

Before cheap replacements made mending obsolete, a smooth wooden egg or mushroom slipped inside a sock to hold the fabric taut for darning. Turned from maple, boxwood, or exotic hardwoods, some had handles and some were plain, and a few hid a compartment for needles inside the handle.

Collectors favor the darkly patinated antique ones and any with maker’s stamps. Cracks or splits knock the price down sharply.

Hexagon Paper-Piecing Templates

English paper piecing wraps fabric around precut paper shapes, and the six-sided hexagon is the signature form behind the classic Grandmother’s Flower Garden quilt. Vintage brass and celluloid templates turn up alongside stacks of hand-cut paper pieces, sometimes cut from old letters and catalogs.

Reused papers with visible period handwriting or printing are a bonus that historians actually study. Complete sets in the original envelope sell above loose finds.

Olfa Rotary Cutters

The rotary cutter transformed quilting when the Japanese company Olfa introduced the first one in 1979, borrowing the idea from a pizza wheel. The round blade lets a quilter slice through several layers of fabric against a ruler far faster than scissors allow.

Early models with the original yellow handle are collected by quilters who remember the change they brought. Since blades are replaceable, buyers care most about a smooth, unbent handle and a working blade guard.

Aunt Martha’s Iron-On Transfers

Aunt Martha’s hot-iron transfers put embroidery designs within reach of anyone with an iron, printing patterns in a special ink that released onto fabric under heat. The brand ran designs for tea towels, pillowcases, and quilt blocks, including days-of-the-week kitchen motifs that defined mid-century linens.

Unused transfer sheets that still hold enough ink for one more press are the ones buyers want. Numbered envelopes with the artwork intact bring more than loose, faded sheets.

Chenille Needles

Chenille needles have a large eye and a sharp point, made for pulling thick yarn or multiple floss strands through tightly woven cloth. Vintage packets from makers like Boye and Milward, printed with era graphics, sell as much for the packaging as the steel inside.

A needle that has stayed dry keeps its nickel plating and its point, while a rusted one is worthless to a stitcher. Full packets with every needle seated in the original paper hold their value best.

DMC Embroidery Floss

The French company DMC has spun cotton embroidery floss since the 1800s, and its color numbering system is a standard that generations of stitchers memorize. Old wrapped skeins carry paper bands with numbers and logos that date them, and discontinued colors bring out determined buyers finishing decades-old projects.

A skein with its band intact and no fading is worth more than a loose, tangled length. Boxed assortments of vintage colors sell as complete sets.

Wooden Embroidery Hoops

The two-ring frame that holds fabric drum-tight for stitching was once turned from steam-bent hardwood with a brass tension screw. Vintage wooden hoops feel and grip differently than the plastic ones sold now, which is why hand embroiderers seek them out.

Screw-tension models branded for specific mills add interest for collectors beyond their working use. A hoop that still clamps evenly without warping is the one worth buying.

Seam Rippers

The little forked tool that slices unwanted stitches is a workbasket staple, and vintage ones had turned wooden or Bakelite handles instead of molded plastic. Some doubled as thread cutters or came fitted into the lids of sewing kits.

Collectors like the ones marked with sewing machine brand names, since they were packed with new machines. A sharp point and an unchipped handle set the good ones apart.

Tailor’s Chalk

Flat triangular cakes of tailor’s chalk mark cutting and stitching lines that brush away when the work is done, and the metal chalk wheels that dispense powdered chalk are collected too. Older chalk came in tin holders printed with tailoring supply names now long gone.

Full cakes in unopened wrappers or original boxed sets are what buyers reach for. A cracked cake still works, but pristine packaging drives the price.

Tracing Wheels

A tracing wheel rolls a dotted line through dressmaker’s carbon to transfer pattern markings onto fabric. Vintage ones had spiked steel wheels and wooden handles, and serrated versions left a heavier mark than smooth-edged ones.

Buyers seek the ones branded by known notions makers and any with unusual bone or Bakelite handles. Free-spinning wheels without rust are the keepers.

Vintage Sewing Patterns

Paper patterns from Simplicity, McCall’s, and Butterick are collected for their cover art as much as their cut pieces, capturing the silhouettes of every decade. Complete envelopes with all the tissue pieces and the instruction sheet are what serious sewers pay for, since a missing piece can sink a project.

Early printed patterns and designer name collaborations command the strongest prices. Brittle tissue and torn envelopes drag the value down.

Bias Tape Makers

A bias tape maker is a little metal funnel that folds a cut fabric strip into binding as it passes through under a hot iron. Vintage metal ones in graduated sizes came carded with instructions and are collected in complete size runs.

The older all-metal versions outlast the plastic replacements, which is why sewers still hunt them. A clean, unbent funnel with the original card is the prize.

Dritz Snap Fasteners

The Dritz name, now part of Prym, sat on countless cards of metal snap fasteners sold in dime stores for decades. Cards of gripper snaps, along with the pliers made to set them, turn up in old sewing boxes and sell as vintage notions.

A full card with every snap and cap present, the price still stamped on the back, is what buyers want. Tarnish and missing pieces cut the value.

Hook-and-Eye Cards

The paired metal hook and its catch fastened dresses and waistbands long before zippers took over, and they were sold stitched to printed cards. Vintage cards from makers such as De Long and Clinton carry graphics that date them to the 1930s and 1940s.

A complete card with black-and-silver finishes untarnished draws collectors of sewing ephemera. Rust or empty stitching spots lower the appeal.

Quilting Stencils

Thin plastic or brass stencils cut with channels let a quilter trace repeating designs onto a quilt top before hand quilting. Vintage stencils for feathered wreaths, cables, and clamshells turn up in old quilting bags, sometimes hand-cut from oilcloth or cardboard.

Buyers value the branded plastic ones and any unusual patterns no longer in production. Uncracked stencils with clean channels are the ones that still work.

Wooden Quilt Hoops

Larger than an embroidery hoop, a wooden quilt hoop holds a section of a full quilt taut for hand quilting away from a floor frame. Vintage hoops mounted on turned wooden floor stands let a quilter work seated, and the standing models are the most sought after.

Steam-bent hardwood rings with a strong tension screw outlast the fabric worked in them. A hoop that clamps evenly without cracks earns the higher price.

Needle Books

A needle book is a little folder of felt pages that keeps sewing needles from rusting and getting lost, and advertising versions were given away by thread companies and insurance agents. The printed paper covers, often with cheerful graphics, make them collectible beyond their use.

Some still hold their original assortment of needles pressed into the felt. Bright, uncreased covers with the needles intact bring the most.

The Quiet Economy of the Workbasket

What ties these objects together is that they were never meant to be saved. They were consumables and tools, bought to be used up or worn out, which is exactly why the survivors in good condition are scarce.

A card of buttons still full, a spool still labeled, a needle book with its needles in place, each one dodged the ordinary fate of being emptied and thrown away.

The people buying them now are rarely just decorators. Many are working quilters and sewers who trust old steel and hardwood over new plastic, and who know that a Depression-era feed sack or a boxed Featherweight foot carries a story stitched into every use.

In their hands the workbasket keeps earning its keep, one small find at a time.

More from Home As We Make It

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.