25 Board Games Worth Listing Incomplete

A game box missing a few cards and a pawn looks like an easy donation. For certain titles, that same box is a parts supply that strangers across the country are hunting for.

Replacement-part buyers, restorers and collectors finishing their own sets pay real money for single pieces, and the most wanted pieces are often the ones that rarely survived.

The catch is honesty. A listing that names exactly what is present and exactly what is missing sells, while one that says “mostly complete” invites returns and bad feedback.

Dark Tower and Its Electronic Centerpiece

Milton Bradley released Dark Tower in 1981, and the rotating electronic tower that ran the game is the part collectors chase above everything else. A working tower sold on its own can outprice many complete games from the same decade.

Nonworking units still find buyers who repair them or strip them for components, and the small plastic buildings and flags move in lots of their own. Condition decides the price, including any battery corrosion, which sellers should photograph and describe plainly.

HeroQuest Miniatures and Plastic Furniture

Games Workshop designed HeroQuest with Milton Bradley, and the game reached European shelves in 1989 before arriving in North America the following year. Its unpainted monsters, heroes, doors, tables and treasure chests sell individually to players rebuilding original sets.

Demand has held up even after Hasbro brought the game back in 2021. Painted figures appeal to some buyers and put off others, so clear photos matter, and cracked furniture or snapped weapons pull the price down.

Forbidden Bridge With a Working Idol

The 1992 Milton Bradley game Forbidden Bridge centers on a motorized idol that shakes a rope bridge when a player presses its head. Incomplete copies sell because the idol unit and bridge are the hardest pieces to replace, and buyers often already have the explorers and canoes.

The tiny jewels vanish first in most households. Sellers should state whether the motor runs, whether the battery compartment is clean and which jewels, pawns or railing pieces are gone.

Heroscape Figures and Hex Terrain

Milton Bradley launched Heroscape in 2004 with the Rise of the Valkyrie master set, and its prepainted figures and interlocking hex terrain built a loyal following that never really left. Players buy loose terrain in bulk to expand their battlefields, and single figures with matching army cards sell steadily.

An incomplete master set moves well when the listing counts every tile type and size. Figures with bent weapons or missing cards bring less, so value depends on condition.

Axis and Allies From the Gamemaster Series

The 1984 edition of Axis and Allies belonged to Milton Bradley’s Gamemaster series, and its hundreds of small plastic military units are the draw for parts seekers. Players who lost a few battleships or fighters will pay for exact-color replacements from the same era.

Sorting the pieces by nation and unit type, then giving an honest count, makes a listing far easier to buy from. Faded, bent or chewed pieces sell for less than crisp ones.

Fortress America Unit Lots

Another Gamemaster title, Fortress America arrived in 1986 with an invasion of the American mainland as its premise. Its plastic units come in several colors, and owners of damaged or short sets hunt for specific colors to restore balance between the invading forces.

Lots sorted by color and type move faster than jumbled bags of mixed plastic. Buyers also look for the map board and cards in decent shape, so value tracks the condition of every component offered.

Battle Masters and Its Vinyl Mat

Milton Bradley and Games Workshop teamed up again for Battle Masters in 1992, packing the box with a large army of plastic miniatures and an oversized vinyl battle mat. Specialty dealers such as Noble Knight Games have listed the mat by itself, which shows how the parts trade on their own.

The cannon and the tower are popular single pieces too. Creases, stains and missing figures lower the value, so condition notes belong in every listing.

Space Hulk First Edition Components

Games Workshop released the first edition of Space Hulk in 1989, pitting armored Space Marine Terminators against Genestealers in cramped corridors aboard a derelict ship. The corridor sections, door pieces and plastic figures all sell separately to players and to miniature painters who like the older sculpts.

Expansions from the following years add further demand for matching parts. Painted models, bent corridor sections and missing counters all shift the price, which depends on condition above all.

Clue Sets From the Early Parker Brothers Years

Parker Brothers brought Clue to American shoppers in 1949, adapting the British game Cluedo. Weapons and pawns are the pieces most likely to disappear over decades of family game nights, so single early weapons sell to owners patching up heirloom copies.

Replacement listings for items like the lead pipe show up regularly on resale sites. Sellers should identify the edition from the box and rules, since pieces changed over the years and buyers want a true match.

Monopoly Sets With Wooden Tokens

Metal shortages during World War Two led Parker Brothers to swap wooden playing pieces into some Monopoly sets, and those wartime tokens now draw collector interest. Earlier and later metal tokens also sell alone, including retired pieces such as the iron, which left the game in 2013.

Old wooden houses and hotels round out the parts market. A partial set with its original tokens can sell well, but the board, money and cards still need honest condition notes.

Early Risk Sets With Wooden Armies

Parker Brothers introduced Risk to American players in 1959, and early editions used small wooden pieces for armies instead of the plastic figures of later decades. Those wooden sets attract buyers restoring vintage copies and players who prefer the older feel.

Missing a few pieces of one color barely dents interest if the rest is intact. The listing should give a count per color and describe the board, cards and box, since condition sets the price.

Stratego With Wooden Pieces From Nineteen Sixty-One

Milton Bradley’s first American Stratego, released in 1961, used wooden playing pieces, and those pieces now sell individually to owners completing their red and blue armies. A single missing Marshal or bomb can leave a set unplayable, which explains why buyers pay for the exact rank they need.

Specialty parts sellers stock these pieces by rank and color. Faded paint, chipped corners and warped wood all reduce value, so the price of any lot depends on condition.

Scrabble Deluxe Edition Turntable Sets

Selchow and Righter sold a Deluxe Edition of Scrabble with a rotating turntable base, and those vintage boards still sell even when tiles are missing. Loose tiles trade by the letter to players replacing lost pieces and to crafters who use them in projects.

The turntable itself is the draw for many buyers, since it lets the board spin to face each player. A short set should list exactly which letters are gone, and warped boards or sticky turntables lower the price.

Operation and Its Tiny Ailments

Milton Bradley put Operation on shelves in 1965, based on an idea from inventor John Spinello. The small plastic ailments, including the Charley horse and water on the knee, get lost constantly, which keeps demand steady for replacements from matching editions.

The wired tweezers also sell by themselves to owners whose originals broke. Sellers should test the buzzer and light before listing, note any corrosion, and remember that the value of a vintage board depends on its condition.

Voice of the Mummy and Its Hidden Record Player

Milton Bradley’s 1971 Voice of the Mummy hides a small record player under the mummy’s sarcophagus, and a lever makes the pharaoh bark out commands. A working sound mechanism is the part restorers want most, and spare jewels, pawns and the cobra spell piece sell to owners filling gaps. Some hobbyists restore these games full time.

Listings should say plainly whether the record plays, since a silent mummy and a talking one are priced very differently.

Green Ghost With Its Glowing Parts

Transogram marketed Green Ghost in 1965 as a luminous game to play in the dark, with a board raised on legs and cardboard crypts tucked underneath. The large ghost spinner, glowing pieces, crypt covers and keys are all fragile, so single parts sell to owners trying to finish a set.

Collectors know complete copies are scarce, which keeps parts demand healthy. Sellers should list which crypt contents and scenic pieces survive, since condition and completeness drive the price.

Mystery Date and Its Plastic Door

Milton Bradley released Mystery Date in 1965, and the plastic door in the middle of the board is the heart of the game. Players open it to reveal a date card, hoping to avoid the dud waiting behind it.

The door unit and outfit cards sell separately to owners with broken or short sets, and nostalgia keeps interest high. A door that still opens and closes cleanly is worth mentioning, while cracks and missing cards lower value.

Kenner’s Escape From the Death Star

Kenner released Escape From the Death Star in 1977, riding the first wave of Star Wars merchandise into toy aisles. Vintage Kenner collectors buy the game’s cards, board and playing pieces even from incomplete boxes, since the branding carries weight on its own.

Sellers do best by listing every card and piece present. Box wear, creased cards and faded color all affect the price, which depends on condition as much as on the Star Wars name.

The Game of Life From Nineteen Sixty

Milton Bradley issued The Game of Life in 1960 to mark the company’s centennial, with a three-dimensional board and a promotional nod to television host Art Linkletter. The plastic cars, pegs, buildings and spinner from that first edition sell to owners completing their copies.

The board often survives long after the small parts wander off. Buyers expect a clear note on which buildings and cars are present, and value depends on the condition of each piece.

Electronic Mall Madness

Milton Bradley introduced Mall Madness in the late 1980s, and the electronic talking version from 1989 made the game a sleepover staple for a generation. The talking unit is the component buyers want most, followed by the plastic shopping bags, credit cards and store pieces.

A working voice unit can carry an otherwise short set. Sellers should test it with fresh batteries, describe any corrosion and list every missing item, because condition decides what a buyer will pay.

The Omega Virus and Its Talking Computer

Milton Bradley released The Omega Virus in 1992, a talking electronic game in which a computer voice taunts players racing to destroy a virus aboard a space station. The electronic base carries most of the value, and replacement weapon cards and playing pieces sell to owners filling gaps.

Nostalgia for early 1990s electronic games keeps this one moving on resale sites. A listing should confirm the voice works and name any missing parts, since condition drives price.

Stop Thief and Its Crime Scanner

Parker Brothers released Stop Thief in 1979 with a handheld Electronic Crime Scanner that plays footstep and door sounds as players track a hidden thief around the board. The scanner is the one part a buyer cannot improvise, so a working unit sells even without the board.

Hobbyists have even built web apps to stand in for lost scanners. Sellers should test the device and describe the battery compartment, since its condition shapes the final price.

Cootie Bug Parts by the Handful

Herb Schaper’s company in Minnesota introduced The Game of Cootie in 1949, and the plastic bug bodies, heads, legs, eyes and antennae have been getting lost ever since. Parents and collectors buy loose parts to rebuild complete bugs, and early pieces in older colors draw extra interest.

Sorting the parts by type makes a listing easy to shop. Faded color and chewed legs reduce value, so price depends on the condition of each part in the lot.

Cosmic Encounter From Eon Products

Eon Products published Cosmic Encounter in 1977, and its alien powers and later expansions gave it a devoted following that has lasted for decades through several publishers. Players seek original Eon components, including alien power sheets, colored ships and flare cards from the early expansions, to complete their collections.

Partial sets move well when every alien and expansion piece is listed by name. Worn edges, faded sheets and missing ships lower the price, which depends on condition.

Talisman From Games Workshop’s Early Years

Games Workshop published the first edition of Talisman in 1983, and the fantasy adventure game grew through several editions and a long run of expansions. Older character cards, adventure cards and playing pieces sell to players who want to finish sets from a specific edition.

Buyers care about which edition a card came from, so sellers should check the card backs and rules before listing. The condition of the cards, figures and board sets the final price.

Where the Parts Outlive the Box

A game is a set of objects that only work together, which is why losing one small piece can sideline an entire box for decades. The parts market reverses that logic.

A cracked board or a missing pawn stops being a flaw and becomes a detail in an honest description.

Buyers in this corner of resale are specific people with specific gaps to fill. They reward sellers who count, sort and test, and they punish vague listings quickly.

A clear note on exactly what is missing turns a half-finished game into someone else’s missing piece.

More from Home As We Make It

• 18 Affordable Places to Retire in the U.S.
• Antique Glassware That’s Worth Collecting
• Stay-At-Home Jobs That Actually Pay
• 18 Forgotten Snacks from the ’80s and ’90s
• 20 Things That Make a House Look Cleaner Than It Is

Like Home As We Make It‘s content? Follow us on MSN.